Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

3 new-hire costs and setup duties to fix before day one

Small firms often hand onboarding to the same person who runs payroll, builds the schedule, and answers the phone. That person is usually juggling three questions at once: which costs the new hire should not carry, which setup work needs paid time, and when money can be taken back out of a paycheck. Each one looks small on its own.

This post works through those three questions using rules from state agencies and state regulations. The rules come from specific states, so read them as examples of how the questions get answered, and check the rules where your people actually work. Where a source does not answer a point, this post says so and offers general practice instead.

Key takeaways

  • List every required exam before the offer and decide who pays for each one.
  • Schedule setup tasks inside the paid shift and record the decision for each task.
  • Check overpayment recoveries against the two conditions in the quoted rule before any deduction.

Who pays for a physical or shots a new hire is required to have?

Under Washington's rules, a required pre-employment physical cannot be charged to the employee, and that includes preventive inoculations recommended by public health authorities. The regulation in Chapter 296-126 WAC reads: "If preemployment physical examinations, including preventive inoculations, recommended by public health authorities are required of employees, such examinations shall not be at the expense of the employee."

Item to settleRequirementStateSource
Required pre-employment physicalNot at the expense of the employeeWashington Chapter 296-126 WAC
Preventive inoculations recommended by public health authoritiesCovered by the same rule as the physicalWashington Chapter 296-126 WAC

The condition sits in the first half of that sentence: the examination has to be required of employees. That makes the first job a list, not a phone call. Before you post the role or make an offer, write down every exam, test, or vaccination the job asks for as a condition of hiring or of continuing to work. Read the job description line by line. A role that involves food, patients, children, driving, or equipment with safety rules may carry requirements that nobody mentioned when the job was first described. Those are the items that tend to surprise a new hire on day one, and they cost the most goodwill when they arrive as a bill.

Once the list exists, give each item an owner. For each one, the firm either pays the provider directly or reimburses the hire through a process the hire can see before the appointment. The Washington text speaks to who bears the expense, not to how the bill gets paid, so the firm has room to choose the method. What it does not have room to do is leave the hire holding the cost and call the appointment a personal errand. A hire who is told to "book your own physical and we'll sort it out later" has been handed a cost the employer created, and that is a poor way to start a job.

Put the answer in the offer letter, not in a reminder email sent just before the first shift. A short paragraph is enough: name the exam, say the firm arranges and pays for it, and say when and where it happens. If the billing arrangement is still unclear when the offer goes out, settle it then.

Two smaller points belong on the same list. The first is timing. An exam booked a week or two ahead of the first shift leaves room to handle results, follow-up appointments, or a rebooking. An appointment made the morning of day one leaves none. The second is the record. Keep a copy of the request, the appointment confirmation, and the payment or reimbursement in the onboarding file. A simple record shows who arranged and paid for what, and it protects both sides if someone later remembers the conversation differently.

Consider how this plays out for a single hire. The offer letter names the exam, says the firm books it and pays the provider, and gives the clinic's location and a contact name. The office manager confirms the appointment the following Friday and saves the confirmation in the onboarding folder. Nothing about that process is complicated, but every step is written down, and the new hire never has to ask whether the cost is theirs. Compare that with a hire who learns about the exam on the morning of the start date and is asked to pay up front. That second version is the cost the Washington text rules out when the exam is required of employees.

Outside Washington, the same planning still works, even though the quoted rule does not apply there. Decide who pays before the offer, write it down, and keep the record. Your state's labor agency is the place to confirm whether its own rules address required exams. The Washington text is one state's answer to the question, and it should be read as one example, not as the rule for your firm.

Is setting up a workstation before the first shift paid time?

Under Oregon's rules, preparatory and concluding activities count as hours worked when they are an integral and indispensable part of the principal activity the employee was hired to do.

Setup task or testStatus under the ruleSource
A server setting up a workstation, preparing coffee, filling condiment jarsHours worked BOLI paid time
A bank teller counting the till before the business opens Hours workedBOLI paid time
Preparatory and concluding activities integral and indispensableHours worked BOLI paid time
Places of employment maintained in a safe conditionRequired under WISHA standards Chapter 296-126 WAC

The page gives two examples. A server's station has to be ready before customers arrive, and a teller's till has to be counted before the doors open. Neither example treats the work as a favor to the employer.

Small firms can miss this point, mostly because the first day feels like a welcome rather than a shift. A new hire may spend the first half hour getting a computer logged in, a badge activated, a workstation arranged, and a few accounts working. If those tasks are needed for the work to start, the time spent on them matches the Oregon test, and it belongs on the timesheet. If the schedule calls that hour "orientation" while the hire is actually doing tasks the job needs, the label does not settle the question. The activity does. Check the paid-time rule for the state where the employee works before applying this test to your own setup tasks.

The practical method is short. Start by listing every setup task for the first day, from parking and the building badge to accounts, equipment, and the workstation. For each task, ask the question the Oregon text asks: is this an integral and indispensable part of the work this person was hired to do? Some questions to ask while you go through the list:

  • Does the job's first task fail if the badge or building access is not working?
  • Can the hire start the work without a particular account or login?
  • Does the workstation have to be arranged, stocked, or configured before the work can begin?
  • Is the item on the list a welcome activity, such as a tour or an introduction, that is separate from the job's work?

Schedule the tasks that pass inside the paid shift, so the start time on the offer includes them. Write down the decision for each task, so the schedule, the pay record, and the hire's understanding all match. A task that does not pass the test can still happen, but it should be scheduled and described honestly rather than folded into the day without a line on the timesheet. The worst version of this problem is a hire who arrives at nine, spends the first hour on setup that everyone assumed was unpaid, and finds out at payday that it was not written down anywhere.

Setup is also physical, and this is where Washington's workplace safety rule comes in. The regulation says: "All places of employment shall be maintained in a safe condition in conformity with the WISHA standards of the department of labor and industries, division of industrial safety and health." The same chapter sets that duty for places of employment in that state. The quoted subsection does not list the specific checks a firm must run, so treat the list below as general practice rather than as a rule.

Before the hire arrives, walk the station as the new person will see it. Check that the chair and desk suit the work. Look for cords and floor clutter that could cause a trip. Confirm that the walkway is clear. If the job uses a tool or machine, make sure it is in working order and that someone has shown the hire how to use it. If a station is not safe, fixing it is a setup task with an owner and a deadline, and it belongs on the same list as the badge and the accounts. Do not leave it for the hire to notice on the first morning.

Can an employer take an overpayment or equipment cost back out of a paycheck?

Washington's rules allow an employer to recover an overpayment from an employee's paycheck only when the overpayment was infrequent and inadvertent. The regulation in Chapter 296-126 WAC says: "An employer can recover an overpayment from an employee's paycheck provided the overpayment was infrequent and inadvertent."

Recovery questionRule or conditionSource
Recovering an overpayment from a paycheckAllowed only if infrequent and inadvertent Chapter 296-126 WAC

The word "provided" makes both conditions required. A one-time mistake, paid by accident, is the situation the text describes. An overpayment that happens again and again, or one the firm chose to make, does not fit the words of the rule. Those two tests are the ones to check when a payroll error turns up, and they are worth writing down so the person running payroll applies them the same way each time.

First weeks are when these errors are most likely. A new hire's rate may be entered wrong, a start date may be set one pay period early, or hours may be counted twice while the timekeeping system is still being set up. None of that is unusual. What matters is how the firm responds. Catch the error early. Tell the hire in writing what was paid, what it should have been, and how the difference will be handled. Then check the next pay period to make sure the fix took. A correction that is explained and small is far easier to accept than a surprise that shows up as a shorter check with no note attached.

The note itself can be short. It should give the pay period, the amount paid in error, the correct amount, and the way the difference will be handled. It should also invite questions and name the person who can answer them. A note that is clear and calm usually closes the matter in one conversation. A note that is vague, or that arrives after the money has already moved, tends to create a second problem on top of the first.

A recovery that fits the Washington test still needs care. The quoted subsection does not address the amount, the timing, or the notice the hire should receive. Talk the correction through with the hire before the money moves, and keep a copy of that conversation in the file.

Equipment is a different question. The sources reviewed for this post do not give a general rule for taking the cost of equipment out of pay. So do not assume that a laptop, badge, or uniform that is not returned can be deducted from a final check. The safer approach is to decide the rules before the hire starts. Decide which equipment is issued, who owns it, what the firm expects back and when, and what happens to a piece that is not returned. Put that in the offer packet, and ask the hire to acknowledge it in writing. Then check your state's rules before any deduction, because the answer may depend on where the employee works.

The four rules from this post are compared below, each with the page it comes from.

SituationWhat the source saysSource
Required pre-employment physical, including recommended inoculationsNot at the employee's expense (Washington) Chapter 296-126 WAC
Preparatory and concluding activities that are integral and indispensableHours worked (Oregon) BOLI paid time
Overpayment recovered from a paycheck Allowed only if infrequent and inadvertent (Washington)Chapter 296-126 WAC
Places of employmentMaintained in a safe condition under WISHA standards (Washington) Chapter 296-126 WAC

Worked example: one offer, three answers settled

Take a small firm making one offer. The offer letter names the required exam and says the firm books and pays for it. It states a start time of nine that includes the first hour of setup: badge, account, workstation. It lists the equipment issued and asks the hire to acknowledge in writing what must come back. At the end of the first pay period, the firm checks that the rate and start date were entered correctly, finds a rate entered too high, and sends a short written note before any correction. Each answer was settled before day one, so the first day runs without a money question.

How do you put the three answers into one first-day plan?

Use one written plan that covers required exams, setup time, and pay rules. Check it at three points: when the offer goes out, the week before the start date, and the end of the first pay period. Each checkpoint is short, and each one catches a different kind of gap before it reaches the new hire.

At the offer stage, the plan should name every required exam and say who pays for it. It should state the start time and include any paid setup tasks inside that time. It should list which equipment is issued and include a short acknowledgment for the hire to sign or return. If a single item at this stage is still unknown, mark it as open and resolve it before the offer goes out, not after the hire accepts.

The middle checkpoint is for confirmation. Check that each exam appointment is booked and that the billing arrangement is set. Walk the station and fix anything that is not safe. Go through the setup list and confirm who will set up each account, badge, and piece of equipment, and when. Make sure the first-day schedule matches the paid setup tasks on the list, so nobody on the team is surprised by a line item on the timesheet.

At the end of the first pay period, check the items that are easiest to get wrong in a new hire's first check. Confirm that the rate and start date were entered correctly. If an error turned up, make sure the correction was written down and explained to the hire. Confirm that the equipment acknowledgment is in the file. If a deduction was considered, check it against the Washington test and your own state's rules before any money moves.

When a checkpoint fails, the plan should say what happens next rather than leaving the gap open. If an exam cannot be booked in time, the offer or the start date needs to move, and the hire should hear that from the firm before the date passes. If a station is not ready, the first-day schedule should change to match, and the change should be written down. If a pay error turns up, the correction follows the steps above. Treating each failure as a planned event, with a named response, keeps a small office from improvising under pressure on the first morning.

When a question goes beyond what this post covers, the right people to ask are the firm's payroll provider, its benefits or health-service vendor, and the state labor agency that enforces wage and safety rules where the employee works. Those contacts can answer state-specific points that the quoted sources do not address. A short email to each one, saved in the file, is a reasonable part of the plan.

Assign an owner to each item. A small firm often has one person doing all three jobs, and that is fine, but the plan should still say who does each task. An unnamed task is the kind that falls between two people who each assumed the other had it. Name the owner on paper, and name a backup for any item that would stall if that person were out on the day the hire starts.

Settling these three things before day one comes down to writing them down. Decide who pays for required exams. List the setup tasks and mark which ones are paid. Set a rule for equipment and for pay errors, and put it in the offer packet. A hire who starts with those answers in hand spends the first day learning the job, not asking who pays for the exam, whether the setup time counts, or why a paycheck came in short.

Related guides: 4 new-hire paperwork mistakes and the fix for each one · New hire pay: 5 checks before the first paycheck · Noncompete checks before a new hire signs: 3 points.

Sources