Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

4 new-hire paperwork mistakes and the fix for each one

The four mistakes are over-collecting identity documents, guessing at employer account numbers, assuming a short filing means no return, and missing return dates under employment tax rules. Each one slows the new hire down, or creates a problem for payroll later. The fixes are small. Most are one decision at the moment you set up the hire.

  • Ask for one List A document, or a List B plus a List C — never both if a List A is presented
  • Pull the employer account number from the account record each time rather than remembering it
  • File the Virginia withholding return whether or not withholding tax is owed; zero still gets reported
  • Write the deposit and filing dates on the same note as the hire's start date, so they travel with the file

What these four mistakes are

The four mistakes are: over-collecting identity documents, guessing at employer account numbers, assuming a short filing means no return, and missing return dates under employment tax rules.

None of these come from carelessness. They come from handoff moments: an offer signed, a start date set, a folder forwarded to the payroll person, and a page nobody opened. The fixes are small.

Mistake one: asking for more identity documents than the rule allows

USCIS runs a document-choice process for employment eligibility verification. It rests on three lists: List A, List B, and List C. USCIS Form I-9 Acceptable Documents explains the structure. The documents on List A show both identity and employment authorization. One document from List A alone satisfies the requirement.

The mistake is treating the lists as a checklist to stack. A recruiter forwards a "bring these" note that asks for a passport, a driver's licence, and a Social Security card. The new hire shows up with all three. The person at the desk, unsure of the rule, takes copies of each and staples them together.

USCIS says the employee presenting an acceptable List A document should not be asked to present any other document. That is a firm instruction. Asking for a second document after a List A shows up is the over-collection error.

The fix has two parts. First, write the instruction for your handoff: the new hire brings one List A document, or a List B plus a List C. Put that line in the offer email or the onboarding note. Second, train whoever receives the documents. They need to know that one List A document satisfies the request on its own.

There is a second over-collection pattern inside List A itself. Employment Authorization Documents carry designs that change over time. USCIS redesigns the EAD card every three to five years to reduce the risk of fraud and counterfeiting. A recruiter who has not looked at the page recently may see an old-design EAD, doubt it, and ask for something else.

That doubt is misplaced. The introduction of new EAD designs does not mean previous designs are invalid. Some EADs issued after a redesign date may still show the earlier design, because USCIS uses existing card stock until supplies run out. The fix here is one line in your notes: an EAD with an older design is still acceptable if it is otherwise valid.

The over-collection mistake also creates work. Handing payroll three documents when one would do means payroll holds three documents' worth of sensitive information. That is a heavier file than the rule calls for.

Ask yourself one question at the desk: what does this document cover, identity or authorization or both? If it covers both, the request is done. Move on.

Mistake two: guessing at the employer account number when payroll starts withholding

When a firm starts withholding, it files under an account number issued for that purpose. In Virginia, the withholding account number carries a suffix pattern. Virginia Tax's withholding page explains it: many accounts carry a suffix of F001, but that will not always be the case.

The mistake is treating F001 as the answer. A small firm sets up one account, sees F001 on the confirmation, and writes it down as the standard. Months later they open a second account for a different class of worker, and the suffix does not match the pattern they assumed.

Virginia Tax gives a concrete example: if you have accounts for both business and household employees, or if you switched to the annual filing status from a previously existing quarterly account, your household employer account may carry a suffix of F002, F003, and so on. The suffix moves with the account's history and type.

The fix is to stop carrying the number in your head. Pull it from the account record each time. When you set up a new hire's withholding, check the account number against the record rather than the last one you wrote down. If you run a small operation from home with only one or two employees, Virginia Tax addresses that setup directly on its page.

The second part of this fix is the handoff note itself. When you forward the new hire's paperwork to payroll, include the account number as it appears on the record. Not a remembered version. The record. If you have more than one account, list which one applies to this hire.

A related over-confidence shows up in the filing cadence. Some firms assume that because they are small, their return schedule is lighter. The obligation to file a withholding return does not depend on the amount, though some employers may be assigned a less frequent (annual) filing status, so a small firm's schedule can differ.

Mistake three: assuming a small or zero-withholding period means no return is due

A return obligation and a payment obligation are two different things. A period with no withholding tax owed still requires a return.

Virginia Tax states the rule plainly: employers must file withholding returns whether or not there is withholding tax owed. The obligation to file does not depend on the amount.

The mistake comes from the first few payrolls of a new hire. A hire starts mid-period. The first check is small, or the period is short, or the withholding is zero because of the hire's own elections. Payroll concludes there is nothing to send, and files nothing.

The fix is a rule on the calendar, not a judgment call: the return goes in on the filing date, whatever the amount. Zero is a number. It still gets reported.

This mistake compounds across a small firm. One hire with a partial period, one hire with an election that zeroes out withholding, one period where the whole team was on unpaid leave. Each of those is a period where the return still goes in. If the habit is to skip the return when the amount is zero, those skips accumulate.

Payroll's checklist should read: calculate what is owed, then file the return for the period. Either way, the filing step happens regardless of the amount. The filing step is unconditional.

Here is how the points you carry into a payroll setup compare.

PointWhat applies
List A document on its ownIdentity and employment authorization covered; no other document requested
List B plus List COne for identity, one for employment authorization
EAD card designRedesigned every three to five years; earlier designs stay valid
Virginia withholding account suffixOften F001; can be F002, F003 with more than one account or a status switch
Virginia withholding return Due whether or not withholding tax is owed

Mistake four: missing employment tax due dates

The IRS publishes employment tax due dates covering the deposit and filing steps that follow each payroll. The dates are fixed. Missing one is a process failure, not a judgment call.

Two rules on that page matter most for a small firm handing new-hire paperwork to payroll.

The first concerns filing after deposits. If you deposited all withheld income taxes when they were due, then you have 10 additional calendar days to file. The filing window extends when the deposit step was completed on time. If deposits slipped, that extension is not available to you.

The second concerns annual returns. These returns are generally due by the last day of February, or by March 31 if filed electronically. The electronic option moves the date by a month. Whether you use it is a decision you make before the season, not the week of filing.

The mistake is treating these as payroll's private calendar. The new-hire paperwork feeds them. A hire whose forms arrive late means a first payroll processed late. The deposit slip then changes your filing window.

The fix is to pull the dates forward into the onboarding step. When you set the start date, write the deposit and filing dates that follow it on the same note. Give payroll that note with the hire's paperwork. The dates travel with the file instead of living in one person's memory.

Electronic filing deserves a specific decision at a small firm. The later date is available when you file electronically. Decide which path you will take before the first return of the year, and tell payroll which one. Half the team assuming paper and half assuming electronic is how a deadline splits in two.

There is an open point here worth naming once. The IRS page gives the general dates and the two rules quoted above. It does not tell you which deposit schedule fits your specific firm's payroll volume. Confirm your deposit schedule with the IRS or a tax adviser. Ask the IRS or your tax adviser which schedule applies to you, and write it on the same note as the filing dates.

The handoff checklist

A handoff works when the receiving person can act without calling you. Here is what travels with the new hire.

  • Identity documents. One List A document, or a List B plus a List C. Note the EAD design point: an older design is still valid if the card is otherwise valid.
  • Employer account number. The exact suffix as it appears on your account record, not a remembered version. If you hold more than one account, name which one.
  • Filing rule. A line saying the withholding return for the period goes in whether or not tax is owed.
  • Deposit and filing dates. The dates that follow this hire's first payroll, plus your chosen path for electronic or paper filing.
  • The filing window rule. Note whether deposits are being made on time, since that determines whether the 10-day extension applies.

Each line takes a minute to add. Skipping any of them pushes the work onto payroll, where it becomes a phone call, a delay, or a missed date.

Related guides: I-9 name mismatch: 4 steps for a new hire's document · 2 Maryland triggers for new-hire sick leave proof · 3 Minnesota time rules for new-hire events.

FAQ

What happens if the new hire shows up with two List A documents? Take the one they offer first. USCIS says an employee presenting an acceptable List A document should not be asked to present any other document. A second List A sitting on the desk is simply not needed. Do not copy it, do not staple it in, and do not ask why they brought it.

Our first hire has zero withholding in her opening period. Do we file? The Virginia withholding return goes in whether or not withholding tax is owed. Zero is reported like any other amount. This is a rule that is easy to miss for partial-period hires, because the natural instinct is to file only when there is something to send.

Is an older-design EAD still fine to accept? USCIS redesigns the card every three to five years to cut down on fraud and counterfeiting. New designs do not make earlier ones invalid. Some cards issued after a redesign date still show the old format, because existing card stock is used until it runs out. Accept the card if it is otherwise valid.

Why did our account suffix come out as F002 instead of F001? Virginia Tax notes that while many accounts carry F001, that will not always be the case. Running accounts for both business and household employees, or switching to annual filing from a previously existing quarterly account, can produce F002, F003, and so on. Read the suffix off the account record each time rather than carrying it forward in memory.

Electronic filing moves our date to March 31. Can we still file on paper? The IRS states these returns are generally due by the last day of February, or by March 31 if filed electronically. Choose one before the season begins and tell payroll which one, so the note in the hire's file gives a single date rather than two.

Sources