Before you reject a Wisconsin worker for a conviction, check the three exceptions the statute spells out, then run the substantial relation test if none applies. Each exception is narrow and carries its own condition, and every one of them is defeated by a pardon. If no exception fits, you are back to comparing the circumstances of the offense against the circumstances of the job.
- Exception one: Refusing to hire an installer of burglar alarms who has been convicted of a felony and has not been pardoned.
- Exception two: Refusing to hire in the classified service someone convicted under 50 USC 3811 for refusing to register with the selective service system, who has not been pardoned.
- Exception three: An educational agency refusing to hire or terminate someone convicted of a felony who has not been pardoned.
- Substantial relation test: When no exception fits, a conviction matters only when the circumstances of the offense substantially relate to the circumstances of the particular job.
- Write your reason: Before communicating a rejection, write one paragraph naming the offense, the job duty, and the point where they meet.
What the statute actually allows you to consider
Wisconsin law does not make every conviction an automatic bar. It also does not forbid every use of a conviction record. The line runs through a "substantial relation" test and a short list of named exceptions.
The statute's general standard states that under (4)(b) to (d), an individual convicted of any felony, misdemeanor, or other offense whose circumstances substantially relate to those of the particular job or licensed activity is covered, as detailed on the Wisconsin Legislature page for statute 111.335.
Put in plain words: a conviction matters when what happened lines up with what the job requires. A theft conviction and a cash-handling job have circumstances that meet. A theft conviction and a job that never touches money are much harder to connect. Document the connection in writing before you say no.
This post covers three specific exceptions where the statute says outright it is not employment discrimination because of conviction record to refuse to employ. Those three sit on top of the substantial relation test. Each one is narrower than it first looks, and each carries its own condition. If any of the three applies to your situation, you have a clean statutory answer. If none applies, you fall back to the substantial relation analysis, and you should be able to explain it.
The three exceptions in plain words
All three exceptions come from the same statute page. Each one is a standalone carve-out. None of them replaces the substantial relation test for convictions outside their scope.
Exception one: burglar alarm installers and felonies. The statute states it is not employment discrimination because of conviction record to refuse to employ as an installer of burglar alarms a person who has been convicted of a felony and has not been pardoned for that felony. The job title is specific. The offense level is specific. The condition is a pardon that has not happened. If a pardon was granted for that felony, this exception does not protect your refusal, and you fall back to substantial relation.
Exception two: classified service and selective service refusal. The statute states it is not employment discrimination because of conviction record to refuse to employ in a position in the classified service a person who has been convicted under 50 USC 3811 for refusing to register with the selective service system and who has not been pardoned. Two limits matter here. The conviction must be under that federal statute, not a general draft-related charge. The position must be in the classified service. A pardon once again defeats the exception.
Exception three: educational agencies and unpardoned felonies. The statute states it is not employment discrimination because of conviction record for an educational agency to refuse to employ or to terminate from employment an individual who has been convicted of a felony and who has not been pardoned for that felony. This one covers hiring and termination. It is limited to an educational agency. It is limited to felonies. It does not reach misdemeanors.
The statutory carve-outs side by side
Here is how the three exceptions compare on the facts the statute gives you.
| Exception | Who it covers | Conviction type required | Pardon removes it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Burglar alarm installer | Position: installer of burglar alarms | Felony | Yes, a pardon removes it |
| Classified service | Position: classified service | Conviction under 50 USC 3811 (selective service refusal) | Yes, a pardon removes it |
| Educational agency | Employer: educational agency | Felony | Yes, a pardon removes it |
Three things jump out when you line them up. Every exception has a pardon escape hatch. Two of the three turn on felony status. Only one keys to a specific federal conviction. Read the table left to right before you rely on any single column.
How the substantial relation test works when no exception fits
Most hiring decisions will not land inside any of the three exceptions. A warehouse supervisor reviewing a misdemeanor is not an educational agency, not a classified service post, and not a burglar alarm installer. In that case you are back to the substantial relation standard from the statute.
The statute frames the question around circumstances. The circumstances. Both the offense and the job have circumstances, and you are checking whether they substantially relate.
Practically, that means writing down two lists before you decide. On one side, what the job actually requires day to day. On the other side, what the conviction record shows. Then you look for points where they touch. The stronger and more specific the touch points, the more defensible your decision.
A useful habit: if you cannot name a specific touch point in one or two sentences, you do not yet have a substantial relation. Send the person a plain question about the record instead of rejecting on a hunch. A short, specific follow-up can resolve the issue on its own.
As a practical judgment of your own, timing can help. In your own judgment, a conviction closer to the conduct of the job makes the relation easier to show. A recent conviction and an immediate job duty sit close together. A decades-old conviction and an unrelated duty sit far apart.
If the language of the statute leaves a question open in your situation, re-read the exact carve-out text and check whether your facts fit every element it names. If they do not fit, you are on substantial relation, and your written explanation of the link between offense and job does the work.
Two more carve-outs worth knowing before you decide
Beyond the three exceptions above, the statute contains related carve-outs. They are not part of the three above, but they change the analysis when they apply.
One carve-out concerns businesses licensed under a specific section. The statute provides that it is not employment discrimination because of conviction record to refuse to employ a person in a business licensed under the section the statute names. If your business type falls within that licensing scheme, check the licensing rules themselves before you rely on a general conviction policy. The licensing rule may already define what counts as disqualifying.
Another carve-out reaches broadly across offenses tied to a licensed activity. The statute says it is not employment discrimination because of conviction record to refuse to employ or license, or to bar or terminate from employment or licensure, any individual who has been convicted of any offense listed in the statute text. Read the list in the statute text itself before you use this one. The list is the boundary, and anything outside it falls back to substantial relation.
Both carve-outs share a pattern with the three main exceptions. They name a condition. They protect a refusal only when the condition is met. Step outside the condition and the protection disappears.
Another pattern worth flagging: some Wisconsin positions are governed by their own rules set by a licensing body or a public employer's classification system. When the position sits inside such a scheme, pull that scheme's language next to the statute. You are looking for overlap. If the scheme already disqualifies the conviction, your decision cites both. If the scheme is silent, you are back on substantial relation.
None of these carve-outs authorize a blanket policy of rejecting every person with any conviction. Wisconsin law keeps pulling you back to the relationship between this offense and this job. Your documentation is what makes that relationship visible if anyone reviews your decision later.
A checklist to run before you send the rejection
Use this order every time. It takes a few minutes and it protects both the person applying and your organization.
Step one: confirm the record. Make sure you are looking at a conviction, not an arrest, a charge that was dismissed, or a record from a different person with a similar name. A conviction record is the starting point for everything in this statute.
Step two: check the three exceptions. Is the position an installer of burglar alarms? Is it in the classified service with a selective service refusal conviction under 50 USC 3811? Is the employer an educational agency and the conviction a felony? Each answer applies only when every condition is met: the alarm-installer answer needs an unpardoned felony, the classified-service answer needs a 50 USC 3811 conviction with no pardon, and the educational-agency answer needs a felony with no pardon. Note whether a pardon exists.
Step three: check the licensed-business carve-outs. Does your business sit under the licensing scheme the statute names? Does the conviction appear on the offense list the statute names? Pull the language and read it before you rely on it.
Step four: run substantial relation. Write the job's core duties. Write the conviction's circumstances. Name the points where they touch. If the touch points are vague, you do not have a substantial relation yet.
Step five: consider asking the person. A short, specific question about the record often gives you what you need. It also shows you treated the decision as an individual judgment, not a blanket rule.
Step six: write your reason before you communicate it. One paragraph naming the offense, the job duty, and the point where they meet. If you cannot fill that paragraph, hold the rejection and revisit steps four and five.
Step seven: apply the same steps to every person in the same role. Consistency across identical roles is what makes an individualized analysis credible rather than a pretext.
Run the checklist even when you believe an exception applies. The exceptions are narrow, and a narrow exception is easy to misapply. Two minutes of reading beats a complaint you answer months later.
Mistakes that get Wisconsin employers into trouble
Several patterns show up repeatedly when conviction decisions go wrong.
Rejecting on arrest instead of conviction. The statute's language attaches to conviction record. An arrest with no conviction does not trigger the same analysis.
Ignoring a pardon. All three exceptions in this post contain a pardon condition. If a pardon exists for the felony in question, the exception no longer protects your refusal.
Applying a blanket no-felonies rule. A blanket rule skips the substantial relation test the statute sets up. Wisconsin employers who write blanket rules lose the ability to explain any individual decision.
Skipping the written reason. If your reasoning lives only in someone's memory, you will reconstruct it differently each time you are asked. Write it once, at the time of decision.
A related pattern is subtler. Some employers treat the three exceptions as if they are the whole statute. They are not. They are specific carve-outs. The substantial relation test continues to govern everything they do not cover.
Related guides
- Interview Scorecard Example for Consistent Hiring Teams
- Hiring Decision Debrief: Notes to a Recorded Decision
- Conviction timing rules for 3 jurisdictions
Questions hiring managers ask about Wisconsin conviction decisions
Do the three exceptions mean I can reject any person who mentions one of these situations? No. Each exception carries a condition. The alarm installer exception requires the position and an unpardoned felony. The classified service exception requires the federal conviction type and the position type. The educational agency exception requires the agency, the felony, and no pardon. Check every element before you rely on the exception.
Does a pardon always defeat the exception? Each of the three exceptions contains a pardon condition. If a pardon exists for the conviction in question, the exception no longer protects your refusal, and you return to the substantial relation analysis under the statute.
What if the conviction does not appear on any list? Then you are on substantial relation. Write the job duties, write the conviction's circumstances, and name the points where they touch. If the touch points are thin, ask the person a specific question before you decide.
Should I tell the person which exception I am relying on? Plain language works best. Name the position, name the conviction, and name the point where they meet. You do not need legal phrasing. You need a reason another person can read and follow.
Where do I check whether a position sits in the classified service? Your own HR classification records answer that. The classified-service exception is written for that specific kind of position, so confirm the position's status against your own personnel or classification documents.
What if the job type is close to one of the exceptions but not exact? Close is not exact. The exceptions name their scope precisely. If your position sits one step outside the named scope, you are on substantial relation, and your written reasoning does the work.
Who handles disputes under this statute in Wisconsin? Read the statute's own provisions for how a dispute is raised, and ask your counsel if your situation does not map cleanly onto the exceptions above.
General information, not legal or tax advice.