A worker offer puts a number on paper, and it also sets the terms a new hire will live with from the first day. A short review before you send the offer is worth the time, even when the role feels routine.
Key Takeaways
- Check the costs a worker must cover to do the job, and see whether any of them cut pay below minimum wage.
- Write down the real factors behind pay differences between workers in similar roles before you set a rate.
- Decide early whether a worker is an employee or a contractor, and put the matching written terms in place.
- Keep the worksheet, reasons, and contract together with the offer file so the decisions are easy to find later.
This post covers three pay areas that hiring managers and small staffing teams should check before any offer goes out. The first is the costs a worker must cover to do the job. The second is whether pay between workers in similar roles can be explained. The third is which written terms apply when the worker is a contractor rather than an employee. Each area comes with questions you can answer before the offer is sent.
Each rule below is tied to the place or agency that states it, and the section names that source. Rules from one state or agency do not carry over to another, so read the linked page before you rely on any of them. This post is general guidance, not legal advice, and it does not replace advice from someone who knows your situation. Hiring managers can do the first pass on these three areas, but the person who approves pay should review the final numbers before anything is sent. Treat the three sections below as a checklist to work through with your team before each offer, and keep the completed checklist with the offer file so the decisions are easy to find later.
Can a worker be made to pay for items the job requires?
In Oregon, an employer is prohibited from requiring an employee to pay for required items when doing so reduces their wages below minimum wage. Under Oregon's Minimum Wage Law (ORS 653), the Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries (BOLI) says that employers are prohibited from requiring employees to shoulder the expense of required items if doing so has the effect of reducing their wages below minimum wage. Because the rule comes from Oregon's law, it belongs to Oregon, and you should not assume it applies in another state without checking that state's own rules.
| Item on the list | Who pays | Check to run |
|---|---|---|
| Tools | Write who pays | Compare cost against minimum wage |
| Uniform | Write who pays | Compare cost against minimum wage |
| Safety gear | Write who pays | Compare cost against minimum wage |
| Travel | Write who pays | Compare cost against minimum wage |
The same BOLI page includes an example about travel. It describes Donna, who normally works the graveyard shift, from 12:00 midnight to 8:00 a.m. In the example, a supervisor offers Donna a bus ticket for travel from 6:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m., but Donna chooses to drive her private vehicle instead. This post repeats only those facts. Read the full example on the page before you apply it to a role of your own, because a short quote can leave out details that matter. Our related guide on Oregon travel time pay cases walks through more travel scenarios.
Start with a plain list of everything a new hire must have to do the job. Write down each tool, uniform, piece of safety gear, piece of equipment, and any travel you require. Next to each item, write who pays for it. Going through the list with whoever runs payroll catches items that one person would miss.
Where the worker pays for something you require, work out what that cost does to their pay for the first pay period. Put the result next to the minimum wage that applies where the job is located, and write down both numbers. If the worker would fall below minimum wage after that cost, stop and get advice before the offer goes out. A problem found on a worksheet is far easier to fix than one found after the first paycheck.
If the check fails, you have a few general choices. You can change what you provide, change the rate, or change the terms of the role. Each choice needs a new check against the same list. Do not patch one line and assume the rest still holds, because a change to one item can affect the pay math for the whole first pay period.
Travel deserves its own line on the list. Decide whether the worker must get to a site, and if so, whether you offer transport or leave the choice to the worker. The Donna example describes a supervisor's offer and the worker's choice, so write down both for any role that involves travel. A short note in the offer file makes the terms easy to look up when the worker asks about them.
Check the offer wording as well. An offer should say what the worker must provide, what the company provides, and how any travel is handled. Vague wording such as "tools as needed" can be read two ways, and the worker and the company may not read it the same way. Plain sentences, settled before the offer is sent, are easier to defend than a clarification written after the worker asks.
Keep the worksheet with the offer file. If the role changes, run the list again, because a change in travel or equipment can change the cost picture. If you are a staffing team placing workers at a client, ask the client which items it expects the worker to bring, and write its answer into the offer before it goes out.
Run the pay math on the same pay period the worker will see on their pay statement. Use the same hours, the same rate, and the same deductions you plan to use, so the check reflects what the worker will actually receive. A check built on different assumptions than the real paycheck can pass when the real one would fail.
Does a pay gap between similar workers need an explanation?
In an EEOC compensation discrimination investigation, a pay disparity that is left unexplained leads an investigator to find "cause." The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission publishes this in its guidance on compensation discrimination. The guidance is written for investigators, so it describes how investigators test pay. Read it that way, and use it to check your own reasoning. If you are setting rates across similar roles, our pay equity checks before an offer cover the same ground from the employer's side.
| Factor behind pay | Record that supports it | Note to keep |
|---|---|---|
| Experience | Payroll record | Written at the time of the decision |
| Performance | Payroll record | Written at the time of the decision |
| Certifications | Payroll record | Written at the time of the decision |
| Shift each person works | Payroll record | Written at the time of the decision |
The guidance describes the steps in order. Once similarly situated employees have been identified, the next step is to determine whether the charging party receives less compensation than similarly situated employees outside his or her protected class. To make that comparison, the investigator should request relevant payroll data from the respondent if that information has not already been provided.
The explanation is tested too. If the respondent does provide a nondiscriminatory reason, the guidance says an inquiry should be made into whether it satisfactorily explains the pay differential. The guidance also says that a respondent who gives an explanation that is "too vague, is internally inconsistent, or is facially not credible" should lead the investigator to find "cause."
The guidance also includes an example with dollar figures. It describes experience and performance differences that account for an $8000 pay gap in one comparison and that account for only a $3000 difference in another. Read the full example on the page, because the two figures are only part of it.
Before you set a rate, list the workers who do similar work and what actually separates their pay. Experience, performance, certifications, and the shift each person works are the kinds of factors a team may weigh. Write down only the factors you really used, and do not add reasons after the fact to fill a gap.
Write each reason down with the record that supports it. A reason that is vague, does not match your records, or cannot be shown for every worker in the group is weak. Compare your written reasons with the payroll records you keep, and fix any mismatch before the offer goes out. A reason written at the time of the decision is easier to check than one written afterward.
Record the date each rate was set and the person who set it. If the rate changes before the offer is sent, record that change too, with its reason. A file that shows how a number was reached is easier to review than one that shows only the final figure.
Use the same standard for every new hire in a role. If one offer is explained with specific experience and another with a vague phrase, the difference will be hard to explain later. Apply the same factors to each person, and keep the notes in the same format, so that anyone reviewing the file can follow the reasoning. If you place workers at a client, ask the client which factors it uses for the role, check whether your offer matches them, and put the client's answer in writing.
If you cannot explain a gap with a reason you can support, do not write a reason you cannot support. Adjust the offer, or take the question to the person who approves pay and document the decision. A reason is only useful if it still holds when someone reads it later.
If a current worker asks why a new hire is paid differently, answer with the factors you wrote down. Do not invent a reason in the moment. Say you will check, then follow up in writing with the same factors you recorded.
Does a freelancer or contractor need a written contract?
In New York, yes, once the services total $800 or more: the hirer must give a detailed written contract and timely and full payment. The New York Attorney General states this on its wages and pay page, which sits under its workers' rights section. The rule is New York's. Contractors in other states may be covered by different rules, so check each state's own requirements. For how worker status is decided in the first place, see our worker status tests.
| Pay area | Rule or example from the source | Number or threshold |
|---|---|---|
| Required items (Oregon, BOLI) | Employers are prohibited from requiring employees to shoulder the expense of required items if doing so reduces wages below minimum wage | Minimum wage |
| Pay gaps (EEOC guidance) | An unexplained pay disparity leads the investigator to find "cause" | $8000 and $3000 (example) |
| Contractors (New York AG) | Freelancer or contractor services totaling $800 or more require a detailed written contract and timely and full payment | $800 |
| Pay area | Rule or example from the source | Number or threshold |
|---|---|---|
| Required items (Oregon, BOLI) | Employers are prohibited from requiring employees to shoulder the expense of required items if doing so reduces wages below minimum wage | Minimum wage |
| Pay gaps (EEOC guidance) | An unexplained pay disparity leads the investigator to find "cause" | $8000 and $3000 (example) |
| Contractors (New York AG) | Freelancer or contractor services totaling $800 or more require a detailed written contract and timely and full payment | $800 |
The $800 figure refers to services totaling that amount. Keep a running total for each contractor rather than looking at one payment at a time, so you know when the threshold is reached.
Decide early whether a role will be an employee or a contractor, and make the offer say which one it is. A single offer letter that is unclear on this point invites questions about pay timing and paperwork.
Once a contractor's services may reach the threshold, put the terms in writing before work starts. Good practice is to describe the work, the agreed amount, and the payment dates in one document. The quote says "detailed" without listing what that must include, so decide for yourself how much detail the contract needs, and treat this as general advice rather than a requirement.
Set the payment dates before work starts, so the timing is settled from the first day rather than negotiated later. Pay the full agreed amount on time, and record each payment with its date. If an invoice is later disputed, a written contract and a dated payment record are the first documents to pull together.
If a payment will be late, tell the contractor before the due date and write down the new date. A short written message keeps the record accurate and gives both sides the same dates.
Confirm who on your team will sign the contract and who will approve each payment. Name one person for each step, and write the names in the offer file. This keeps payment timing from depending on memory.
Keep your copy of the contract and the payment record together in one place. If your state or city has its own contractor rules, check them too, since this section covers only the New York rule. Keep the contract and payment records for as long as your own policies or your advisor require.
Before any worker offer goes out, check the three areas together: the costs a worker must cover to do the job, how the pay compares with similar roles, and which written terms apply to contractors. Use the linked pages for exact wording, and get advice on any point the pages leave open.