Before a new hire's first paycheck, check withholding forms, other jobs, extra withholding, pay dates, and time records.
Key takeaways
- Collect required withholding information without filling in answers for the employee.
- Match payroll entries to the employee's withholding choices.
- Write down the first pay period and pay date.
- Confirm time records and explain how to correct missed punches.
A missing form, a withholding setting nobody reviewed, or a pay date that doesn't line up with the pay period can turn a good first week into a confusing one. Small firms often handle payroll setup with a checklist that lives in someone's head, and that works until the person who knows it is out sick the week a new hire starts.
Picture a new office manager who starts on a Monday. Their tax form is half filled out, they have a part-time job they didn't mention during the interview, and the payroll system is set to a pay schedule that doesn't match your firm's calendar. Nothing about that is unusual. Each problem is small, and each one shows up on the first check.
This post walks through five checks to run before the first pay run. None of them requires specialized tools. They do require a little time before the employee's start date, and a habit of asking the same questions every time. The examples focus on federal withholding, which the IRS covers, and identify agencies to consult about state or city requirements. Nothing here is legal advice. Pay rules differ by location, so when a question goes beyond what's written here, confirm the answer with your payroll provider, accountant, or the labor agency that covers your state.
1. Collect the withholding forms before the first run
Start with paperwork. The federal Form W-4 tells your payroll system how much income tax to withhold from each paycheck. The IRS publishes answers about the 2020 Form W-4 that explain what the form asks and how the steps fit together. It's worth reading before you walk a new hire through it, because the questions that look simple on the surface often have a second layer.
Ask the new hire to complete the form, then review it for blanks before you enter anything into payroll. Check whether a blank field needs an answer, and don't fill it in on the employee's behalf. Ask the employee to supply any missing required information. While you're reviewing, confirm that the name and Social Security number on the form match the employee's records.
State and local withholding is a separate step. Check your state's revenue or tax agency for applicable withholding requirements. Build a short list for your location: which forms apply, who needs them, and where they go in your system. Mark each one as received when it arrives. A written list is the simplest way to avoid the scramble that happens when a form is discovered after the first check. For help choosing sources, see withholding form agency guides.
A simple way to organize this is a three-column tracker: the form, its status, and the date you reviewed it. You don't need special software. A spreadsheet or a checklist in your onboarding tool does the job, as long as the same person checks it every time.
2. Ask about other jobs before you choose a withholding setting
The Form W-4 has a section for employees who hold more than one job, and it's an easy part to skip. The IRS asks the question directly: Which option in Step 2 should I use to account for my multiple jobs? That's the right question to ask, and you can't answer it for the employee. You usually can't see their other jobs, so the answer has to come from them.
Start by asking plainly whether the new hire has another job, or expects to take one during the year. If the answer is yes, the IRS notes that "to be accurate, you should furnish a 2020 Form W-4 for all of these jobs." Your role is to record what you receive and to keep the form on file, not to decide whether the employee has filled out the other one correctly.
Next comes the Step 2 choice. The IRS ties this choice to how similar the pay is at each job. In its words, "if the pay at each job is more similar, choosing Step 2(c) is more accurate than choosing Step 2(b)." Read both options with the employee and let them choose, since they know their pay at each job better than you do.
The IRS also points out that "in general, making these adjustments on the Form W-4 for the highest paying job increases accuracy." If the new hire's other job pays more than yours, that's useful to know, because the adjustments may belong on the form for that job. Tell the employee and let them decide where the adjustment goes.
Don't offer a guess about which option fits. If an employee wants a detailed answer, point them to the IRS guidance or to a tax professional. A short script keeps you consistent: "I can enter what's on your form. For advice on your situation, check the IRS guidance or talk with a tax preparer."
Write down the answer the employee gives, the date, and which form version they used. If the answer changes later, you'll have a clear record of what was known at the start, and you won't have to reconstruct it from memory during a busy month.
Two mistakes come up often with this section. The first is treating it as a one-time task, when the employee's situation can change. A new job, a change in household, or a raise at the other job can change the right answer. Set a reminder to ask again at the start of each year, and ask again whenever the employee mentions a change. The second is assuming an answer is wrong just because it looks unusual. An unusual answer is a reason to ask a follow-up question, not a reason to override the form.
3. Check the extra-withholding line in Step 4(c)
Step 4(c) gives the employee a place to ask for extra tax to be withheld from each paycheck. The IRS describes the step this way: "you will generally be guided to enter an additional amount to withhold in Step 4(c)." In practice, the form points to a line where the employee writes an amount if they want one. That choice belongs to them.
Two checks here. First, make sure what's in your payroll record matches the form, including a blank line. A blank line means no extra amount was entered on the form, so don't add one by default. Second, if the form and the payroll entry ever disagree, fix the entry to match the form, and note the change in the employee file. Don't correct the form yourself, and don't assume the employee meant something different from what they wrote unless they tell you so.
It also helps to walk the form with the employee during onboarding and point to each field they completed. Employees sometimes read a number in one section as applying to another, especially when they're rushed. A quick walk-through can help catch those mix-ups before they reach payroll.
Expect questions. Some employees will ask whether they should have extra tax taken out because of a bill they got last year. That's a reasonable question, but the answer belongs with the employee and a tax professional, not with you. Keep your response plain and consistent, so every new hire hears the same answer.
After the first check, compare the withholding on the pay statement with what the form suggests. If something looks off, check your entry before assuming the form is wrong. That habit catches errors early, and it works for every hire, not just the first one.
Keep a short note in the employee file that records the Step 4(c) entry, the date it was set, and who entered it. When a question comes up months later, that note answers it faster than digging through emails. It also protects both sides: the employee knows what was done, and you know what you were working from.
Illustrative example: an extra-withholding mismatch
This example checks data entry; it does not recommend an amount for the employee.
4. Lock down the first pay date and the pay period
The pay period is the stretch of work a paycheck covers. The pay date is the day the money is paid. They're related, but they aren't the same, and the first check is where small firms often mix them up. Write both down before the first run: the first day of the new hire's first pay period, the last day of that period, and the date the check will be paid.
Example schedules include weekly, biweekly, semi-monthly, and monthly. Pick the one your firm actually runs, and make sure the new hire's first pay period is set up on that schedule. A mismatch between the system's calendar and your actual calendar is an easy way for a first check to arrive late or early.
A hire who starts partway through a pay period needs a clear rule for how that partial period is paid. Suppose someone starts on the Wednesday of a period that runs Monday through Sunday. Your firm needs to decide, in writing, how the partial week is counted, whether it appears on the regular check, and whether any time before the start date is included. Don't make that decision on the fly. Decide it ahead of time, put it in the offer packet or onboarding email, and apply it the same way for every partial period.
Check your pay timing against the rules where you operate. Check the pay timing requirements applicable to the employee and location. Find the rule for your state, write it down, and check your schedule against it before the first run. If the answer isn't clear, ask your state labor agency or a payroll advisor rather than guessing. Use the first payday rules guide to organize that review.
If the first period includes overtime, plan for it. Know how your firm records overtime, when it will appear on the check, and who approves it. Surprises here are easy to avoid with one clear sentence in the onboarding email, and they are the kind of surprise that turns a good first week into a complaint.
Finally, tell the new hire how they'll receive the first check, whether by direct deposit or another method your firm uses, and roughly when it will arrive. Setting this expectation in writing reduces calls in the first week, and it gives the employee something to check against when the money shows up.
Before the first check is issued, it also helps to walk through a sample pay statement with the new hire. Point to the gross pay, the withholding lines, and the net amount, and explain in one sentence what each one means. A five-minute walk-through can help answer questions about unexpected amounts.
5. Confirm time records and what counts as work time
The last check covers the hours that feed the paycheck. Before the first run, confirm that your time system matches how the new hire actually works. A system built for a front desk doesn't always fit a warehouse floor, and a schedule that works on paper can break down once people start clocking in.
Start with what counts as work time. Ask supervisors to list the activities that happen before a shift, during it, and after it, such as setting up a station, putting on required gear, or a short handoff meeting. Decide which of those count as work time and write the answer down. Then check your rule against the applicable wage rules for pre-shift and post-shift tasks.
Required uniforms and protective equipment often come up here. If the job requires employees to put on or take off gear, the time that takes can be a question. Don't leave it to chance. Make a rule, explain it during onboarding, and record it in the policy you give each employee. A clear rule costs little to write and saves a lot of argument later.
Second, approvals. Decide who approves hours, how an employee requests overtime, and what happens when someone works hours that were not approved. Make it clear that unapproved hours still need to be recorded accurately. Whether discipline applies for unapproved hours is a policy question. How those hours are paid is a legal question, so check your state's rules before you write that part of the policy.
Third, walk the new hire through clock-in and clock-out on day one, and have them confirm their first timesheet. A quick review in the first week catches missed punches before they reach the first check. Keep a simple log of any time-related exceptions during the first month, including missed punches, approved overtime, and changes to shift times. These notes make it much easier to answer questions when they come up on payday. For the system review, use the time clock setup checks.
Give the new hire's direct manager a copy of the time rules too. Managers are often the first person an employee asks about a short shift or a missed punch, and a manager who gives a different answer than payroll creates more confusion than the original problem. One short document, shared with both the manager and the employee, keeps everyone working from the same rules.
Putting the five checks together
Run these checks in order before the first pay run: forms on file, other jobs asked about, Step 4(c) reviewed, the pay period and pay date set, and time records confirmed. Write down each answer, so the next hire's onboarding takes less time than this one did. A short written checklist that the same person follows every time does more good than a long policy binder that nobody opens.
Pay rules change, and state and local details matter. Treat this list as a starting point, not a substitute for checking the rules where your firm operates. When in doubt, ask the IRS for federal questions, your state revenue or tax agency for state withholding, and your state labor agency for pay timing and work-time questions.
A well-run first paycheck won't make a new hire's first week perfect. It does remove one of the most avoidable reasons for that week to go wrong, and it tells the new hire that your firm pays attention to details from the start.
Today, open the next hire's onboarding checklist and mark each of the five checks as reviewed or needing follow-up before the pay run.
Questions about the first paycheck
Who should own each check?
Assign one owner to each check. The person who handles forms doesn't have to be the person who sets the pay schedule, but someone should be named for each of the five areas, and that name should be written on the onboarding checklist. When a question comes in on the first Friday, everyone knows where it goes.
Where should signed forms go?
Store the signed forms in the employee file, following your firm's record-keeping practice. Keep the paper or scanned copy with the rest of the onboarding packet so that anyone who needs to answer a question about the setup can find it without asking the new hire to resend anything.