Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Race, color and national origin: 3 intake checks

Race, color and national origin allegations can overlap; record each basis the person alleges without forcing a single label. Intake staff can record the terms the person uses without choosing between race and color first, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

Key takeaways: 3 intake checks

  • Record race and color together when the person alleges both.
  • Keep the person's exact words beside each national origin or race entry.
  • Name any association described, and check the source's employment or labor organization scope.

The same text, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, says discrimination against a Native American may be race and/or national origin discrimination. One allegation can touch more than one basis, so the file should record that overlap instead of forcing a single label on the charge.

Who these race, color and origin rules cover

The EEOC guidance says the following sections describe some specific kinds of charges that can be raised under the Title VII bases, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. That wording places these examples under Title VII, so record each example under the source that names it. Keep the person's own words beside each example so a later reviewer can trace the entry.

The Kansas text covers a labor organization, according to Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes, and its wording addresses exclusion and expulsion from membership. Its scope is a labor organization, so do not carry that scope into your hiring file. Read the statute's scope before you cite it in an employer's file.

The Maryland text includes the wording "determine compensation or the terms, conditions, or privileges of employment," according to Maryland General Assembly. Treat that phrase as the Maryland source's own wording, and do not use it to decide who counts as an employer. Record the Maryland citation with any Maryland-based entry so the scope stays clear. A reviewer can then check the wording against the statute before relying on it.

Use the same scope check for each source before you record it. Ask which publisher wrote the wording, which statute or chapter it comes from, and whether it names employers, labor organizations or something else. Write the answer beside the basis.

Do not treat one publisher's rule as every firm's rule, and do not treat one jurisdiction's rule as the rule everywhere. Those limits come from the scope of each source, and they apply to the examples in this article as well. Name each source in full, with the state or agency that published it. A file that names its source can be reviewed later without guessing.

The table below sets out the quoted sources used in this article.

PublisherPageQuoted wording
Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes44-1009 race, religion, color, sex, disability, national origin or ancestry
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity CommissionSection 2 Threshold Issues may be race and/or national origin discrimination
Maryland General AssemblyLaws - Statute Text determine compensation or the terms, conditions, or privileges of employment

Race and color: alleging one or both

Race and color may both be alleged

The guidance observes: "Courts, however, do not always distinguish them." You can read that line as a warning against forcing one choice between race and color when the person's allegation names both. Your intake form should leave room for both words instead of a yes or no question about only one of them. Use this as a working rule until your team has a written policy.

Consequently, an investigator generally need not determine whether an adverse action was based on race or on color as long as the charging party alleges one or the other, or both, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. In the file, record race and color together whenever the person names both, and keep the person's wording beside each term.

Write down the exact word the person used for race or color, so a later reviewer can see the original wording. Copy the phrase as the person wrote or said it, rather than paraphrasing it. Your notes should not replace the person's words with a label chosen by the reviewer. Keep both lines in the file.

Keep the intake entry limited to the bases the person alleges. Place reasons for any hiring decision in separate debrief notes. Do not add a conclusion about the decision to the race or color line itself.

A single line can hold both terms, separated by a comma. Check the entry after saving it to confirm that every alleged term appears. If the person later adds or drops a term, update the entry and note the date of the change.

Race and national origin: a shared overlap

Race and national origin may overlap

The word "may" in the EEOC example marks the overlap as possible, not automatic. Keep that sentence in mind when a person's allegation involves a Native American. Record the person's exact words alongside the bases you mark.

Your entry can list race and national origin together when the person's allegation fits both terms. Mark each term as its own line, so each basis can be searched separately. Avoid combining both terms into one vague note that a reviewer cannot sort.

Record the person's words first, then mark each basis the person names. Do not add a basis from your own reading of the facts. If the person names only one term, mark that term and leave the other blank rather than guessing.

The Kansas text lists national origin beside race and color, according to Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes, though its wording is for labor organizations. Do not carry the Kansas list into hiring notes as if it set employer rules.

Review each entry for race and national origin before closing it. Confirm that the person's words, the bases marked, and the source named all match. Fix any mismatch while the file is still open. Note the reviewer's name and the review date.

Association example: adverse action against a white employee

Association with someone of another race can be a basis

The EEOC guidance gives this example, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: "it is unlawful to take an adverse employment action against a white employee because s/he is married to an individual who is Native American or because s/he has a mixed-race child." You should read that sentence as covering association with a spouse or child, not only the employee's own race.

Your entry should say which form the person describes. Name the relationship in the person's own words, not in your summary of it. Note the characteristic the person names, exactly as the person phrased it.

The example concerns an employee, so label the entry in the same terms the guidance uses. If the person is an applicant rather than an employee, note that difference in the entry rather than changing the guidance wording.

Do not present the EEOC example as a court ruling. The text calls it an example, so record it as guidance and keep the source name with the entry. Keep the page link too, so the next reader can check the wording at its source.

Other bases and how they can arise

The EEOC guidance says, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, that the following issues can arise under any of the bases. Use that phrase as a reminder to check each basis the person names. Ask the person which terms describe the concern, and write each answer down.

The guidance, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, gives an example under sex: Title VII prohibits a male supervisor from sexually harassing his male subordinates on the basis of sex. This example names sex as its basis, so keep it out of race and national origin entries.

The Kansas text lists race, religion, color, sex, disability, national origin or ancestry for labor organizations, according to Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes. Note that the quoted wording covers exclusion and expulsion from membership in a labor organization.

When a person names a basis outside the overlaps above, write it in the entry as the person states it. Then find the source that names that basis before you cite it. Do not borrow wording from one publisher to describe another. Each source keeps its own scope.

Record each other basis on its own line, next to the matching race, color or national origin entries. Keep sex and disability entries apart from race entries, so each category can be reviewed by itself.

What to record in an intake file

Start each entry with the person's exact words about race, color, national origin or any other basis. Copy the words without paraphrase, so a later reviewer sees what the person actually said. Your entry should then list the terms the person used, separate from any conclusion the team reaches. Keep the two parts in different fields or lines. A reviewer reading the file should be able to tell the allegation from the decision.

Mark every basis the person names, and leave race and color both marked when the person names both. Update the marks and record the date when the person adds or drops a basis.

Add a line for the source that names each basis, using the publisher and a short title rather than a bare link. Each source line should show which scope the source covers.

Record the date you received the charge and the date of any change to the marked bases.

Finish the entry by checking that each marked basis has the person's phrase beside it. Remove any mark that has no supporting wording, or flag it for review.

Illustrative example: updating an intake entry

An illustrative file starts with 1 alleged basis: race. The person later adds color. The reviewer updates the entry to show 2 bases, preserves the person's words and dates the change. The entry records the allegation separately from any conclusion about the hiring decision.

For a separate record of interview assessments, use the interview scorecard for consistent hiring teams.

Your next step: add a field to your intake form where the reviewer lists each basis the person alleges, with race, color, national origin, or more than one checked.

Questions about race, color and national origin charges

Must an investigator decide between race and color?

Generally no, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, as long as the charging party alleges one or the other, or both. Your file can therefore record whichever term the person states, or both. The reviewer should not add a term the person did not state.

Can a national origin claim also be a race claim?

Yes, the EEOC example allows that overlap for discrimination against a Native American, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. The word "may" marks a possibility, so record the person's words first. Mark each basis the person names.

Is marriage to someone of another race covered?

Yes, the EEOC marriage example describes protection against adverse action based on that association, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. That example names a white employee and a Native American spouse; those specific circumstances do not establish a rule for other pairings or exclude them from protection. Ask the person to describe the relationship in the person's own terms.

Which bases does the Kansas text list?

The Kansas text lists race, religion, color, sex, disability, national origin or ancestry, according to Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes, for labor organizations. Its quoted wording addresses exclusion and expulsion from membership, along with discrimination against employers. Use that list as a comparison point, not as hiring rules.

What does the EEOC example about sex show?

The EEOC example identifies sex as the basis for harassment of male subordinates by a male supervisor, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. The example names sex as its basis, so keep it separate from race and national origin entries. Record that example under sex when the allegation is sex-based.

Can more than one basis be marked?

Yes, mark each basis the person names. Keep the person's wording beside each mark.

Sources