If you set starting pay or decide who gets a new hire's first projects, you are making decisions that the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) addresses in its guidance on race and color discrimination. This post takes three of them in turn, explains what each one says in plain terms, and finishes with checks you can run before an offer or a first assignment is final.
Key Takeaways
- Race bias cannot affect assignments, performance measurements, pay, training, mentoring or networking, discipline, or any other term of employment.
- Record who got which first assignment, who else was available, and why, at the time you make the call.
- Tie each early performance rating to job-related facts written down as they happen.
- Write a dated, job-related note behind every starting pay figure and use the same method for each hire in a role.
- Have a second person read the record before a one-person decision goes out.
This post is written for recruiters and hiring managers at small firms who set starting pay and first assignments. It stays with what the guidance says. Read the full guidance before you act on anything here, and take a question about a specific offer to an employment lawyer.
Which parts of the job does race bias have to stay out of?
The EEOC says employers cannot permit race bias to affect work assignments, performance measurements, pay, training, mentoring or networking, discipline, or any other term, condition, or privilege of employment.
| Term covered | Guidance statement | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Work assignments | Race bias cannot affect them | EEOC |
| Performance measurements | Race bias cannot affect them | EEOC |
| Pay | Race bias cannot affect them | EEOC |
| Training | Race bias cannot affect them | EEOC |
| Mentoring or networking | Race bias cannot affect them | EEOC |
| Discipline | Race bias cannot affect them | EEOC |
The list is wider than the offer letter, and the guidance says the list is not limited to these terms. For someone who sets up a new hire, the decisions it covers include the starting pay figure, the first assignments and who gets the most visible work, the training the new hire is offered, who they are paired with for mentoring, the people they are introduced to for networking, and how you respond when a problem comes up. Discipline is on the list too, so the same standard applies when something goes wrong, not only when a job is offered.
The guidance also names several of these items separately. Performance measurements and training appear on their own, not only as parts of pay. That means the criteria you use to judge a new hire's early work, and the training you choose for them, are decisions the guidance addresses in their own right. Look at them that way when you make them.
Training and networking deserve the same attention as pay. Suppose a new hire is invited to one internal group and not another, or is recommended for a course that a peer is not. Each choice may have a sensible explanation. Because the guidance lists training and networking among the terms race bias cannot affect, write down who was offered what, and why, at the time you make the offer.
Consider a simple case. Suppose you hire two people in the same month for the same role. Both start within the same pay range. One is handed the client-facing project that everyone wants, and the other gets internal cleanup work. Each decision might look reasonable on its own. Taken together, they are the kind of assignment decision the guidance covers, so you should be able to explain both of them, with reasons unrelated to the new hire's race.
When one person makes all of these calls, nobody else may see the reasoning behind them. That is why the written record described later in this post matters. The record is what lets you explain a decision after the fact, and it is also what makes you check the reasoning before the decision is made.
How can a first assignment affect pay later?
Race bias in how work is assigned can affect pay later. The EEOC's guidance gives an example involving a person named Mary. In it, the EEOC says that "the evidence suggests that race bias affected how managers assigned Mary work, which in turn stalled her career development and affected her pay." The statement is in the EEOC's section on race and color discrimination, and it is worth reading in the original text.
Notice that the example describes a chain rather than a single decision. First came the way managers assigned Mary's work. That stalled her career development, and the stall affected her pay. The harm the guidance describes runs through the assignments before it reaches the paycheck. A pay figure can look fine on the day it is set and still be the end point of a process that began with a first assignment.
For a recruiter, the first assignment is the start of that chain. Less challenging work can mean fewer chances to build experience, and the Mary example names career development as the step between an assignment and a pay outcome. The example does not say what will happen in any particular firm, so treat it as a description of how the chain can work, not a prediction about your own team.
Assignments are easy to make and hard to reconstruct. A quick conversation about who takes which project leaves no record unless you make one. A practical check is to keep a short list for each new hire: the first three assignments, who else was available for each one, and why this person was given that work. Write the list when the assignment is made, not later from memory.
Over a few months, the lists also show patterns that no single assignment would. One new hire may get a project involving a client, a second may get similar client work only after a delay, and a third may never be asked. You can see that only if the lists exist side by side, so keep them in one place.
Then compare the lists for people hired in the same period. If one person keeps getting routine work and another keeps getting stretch work, you should be able to say why in job-related terms. If you cannot, a written note does not resolve a gap that cannot be tied to job-related facts; change the assignment, or review the reason before it is used again.
The lists also help with a second question: whether the work matches the role. If the role description says one thing and the work given says another, write down the difference and the reason for it. A gap between the role and the work is worth explaining in writing before anyone else has to ask about it.
Can a performance evaluation count as race bias when pay follows from it?
Yes. The EEOC's guidance includes an example involving a person named Daniel. In it, the guidance says "there is reasonable cause to believe Daniel's performance evaluations, and thus his pay, were racially discriminatory." That passage appears in the EEOC section on race and color discrimination, where the example is set out with its findings.
| Point | What it covers | What the guidance says | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Terms covered | Work assignments, performance measurements, pay, training, mentoring or networking, discipline | Employers cannot permit race bias to affect these or any other term, condition, or privilege of employment | EEOC |
| Assignments and pay (Mary) | How managers assigned her work | The evidence suggests race bias affected how her work was assigned, which stalled her career development and affected her pay | EEOC |
| Evaluations and pay (Daniel) | His performance evaluations | There is reasonable cause to believe his performance evaluations, and thus his pay, were racially discriminatory | EEOC |
| Nondiscriminatory reason (Daniel) | Pure personality clash | The clash has to be one not rooted in the alleged bias | EEOC |
The example also shows what the investigation looked for. It found "no evidence of a nondiscriminatory reason" that explains Daniel's treatment. The guidance gives a pure personality clash as one example of a nondiscriminatory reason, and it qualifies that example in its own text: the clash has to be one "not rooted in the alleged bias." The qualifier is the part to keep in mind. A personality explanation does not settle the question on its own, because the reason has to be one that is not rooted in the bias being examined.
Evaluations feed pay, so treat them as pay decisions. When you rate a new hire's early work, write down the job-related facts behind each rating: the deliverables, the deadlines met or missed, and the feedback you gave at the time. A rating you cannot tie to facts is harder to defend, and the Daniel example shows how an evaluation can carry into pay.
Timing matters here too. Write the facts down as they happen, and record the date each one was observed. A rating written at review time from notes made at the time is easier to explain than one written from memory alone, and the notes keep the rating tied to what was actually seen.
Ratings also benefit from a second reader. If the manager who rates someone is also the person who set the first assignment, ask another manager to read the facts behind the rating before it is used for pay. The second reader does not need to agree with every judgment. Their job is to ask whether each rating points to something that was observed.
The table below compares the three points side by side.
| Point | What it covers | What the guidance says |
|---|---|---|
| Terms covered | Work assignments, performance measurements, pay, training, mentoring or networking, discipline | Employers cannot permit race bias to affect these or any other term, condition, or privilege of employment |
| Assignments and pay (Mary) | How managers assigned her work | The evidence suggests race bias affected how her work was assigned, which stalled her career development and affected her pay |
| Evaluations and pay (Daniel) | His performance evaluations | There is reasonable cause to believe his performance evaluations, and thus his pay, were racially discriminatory |
How do you write down the reason for a starting pay figure?
Starting pay is one of the terms the EEOC lists, so the reason for it should be something you can state and show.
Keep the reasons specific. A note that says "good fit" or "seemed sharp" does not explain a number to anyone who reads it later, including you.
Here is what a usable note can look like. For a support role with a set range, the note might read: "Offer at the middle of the range. Range set before interviews began." The note states facts tied to the job, and anyone reading it can check them. Compare that with a note that says only "strong hire," which gives a reader nothing to check.
Apply the same method to every hire for the same role. If the method changes from one person to the next, the notes will show a difference that you will have to explain. A consistent method is easier to describe, and easier to check, than a set of separate judgments made for each person.
If a new hire asks how their pay was set, answer with the same facts you wrote down. Avoid giving a different explanation from the one in your note. If the note cannot support the answer you want to give, that is a sign to look again at the number, not to change the explanation.
If a new hire pushes back on the figure, the same note is your starting point. Listen to what they say, check whether it changes any fact in the note, and then either explain the number with those facts or revise it and record the change with its date. Keep the conversation on the job-related facts rather than on the person.
What should you check before a starting offer or first assignment is final?
Before a starting offer or first assignment is final, check that you can explain each one in job-related terms, and that the explanation does not depend on the new hire's race. The checks below turn the three EEOC points into a routine you can repeat for every hire.
| Check | What to confirm | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Assignments | First three assignments, who else was available, and why this person was given the work | EEOC list of covered terms; the record is this site's suggested step |
| Training and mentoring | What was offered, to whom, and why | EEOC list of covered terms; the record is this site's suggested step |
| Evaluations | Which facts will rate early work, and a plan to write them down at the time | EEOC list of covered terms; the record is this site's suggested step |
| Starting pay | The dated, job-related facts behind the figure | EEOC list of covered terms; the note is this site's suggested step |
| Second look | A second person reads the record before a one-person decision goes out | This site's suggested step |
- Pay: A dated note exists for the starting figure, and it names the facts behind the number.
- Assignments: You have written down the first three assignments, who else was available for each, and why this person was given that work.
- Training and mentoring: You have recorded what was offered, to whom, and why. The guidance lists both among the terms it covers.
- Evaluations: You know which facts you will use to rate early work, and you have a plan to write them down at the time they happen.
- Second look: For any decision made by one person, a second person reads the record before the offer or assignment goes out.
None of these checks needs special equipment. A folder for each hire, with dated notes, is enough to keep the reasoning in one place. Put the offer and the assignment list in the same folder, so that the record is complete when someone asks about it.
If a check fails, do not wait for the next review cycle. Pause the decision, write down the facts you have, and decide whether the number or the assignment should change before it is final. A failed check is information you can act on while the offer is still open, and it costs far less to fix then than after the hire has started.
The list in the guidance reaches beyond the offer letter, so keep the file going after the hire starts. Review it after the first evaluation and again after the first round of assignments. Ask whether the notes still support each decision, and whether they support it for every person hired in the same period. If they do not, fix the decision or the record, and write down what you changed and when.
For the full discussion behind these points, read the EEOC's section on race and color discrimination in its entirety.
Related guides: Race bias complaints: 4 evidence sources to gather first · Race bias in hiring: 4 checks before you decide · 3 benefit facts for offers under equal pay and the ACA.