Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

3 benefit facts for offers under equal pay and the ACA

Under the ACA, an applicable large employer need not offer minimum essential coverage to part-time employees to avoid a shared responsibility payment.

  • Skill is judged by what the job requires, not what the person holds
  • A responsibility change breaks equality inside a group of otherwise equal jobs
  • Benefits belong inside the wage under the California Equal Pay Act definition
  • An ALE need not offer minimum essential coverage to part-time employees to avoid a shared responsibility payment
  • A part-time employee's premium tax credit cannot trigger an employer shared responsibility payment

Both touch a benefits line in your offer letter. Here is how to read them before you send.

Recruiters at small firms write offers every week. The offer carries a salary number and a list of benefits. Somewhere behind both sits a set of rules. Two of those rules get cited in the same conversation: the Equal Pay Act, and the ACA employer shared responsibility rules. This post separates the two, shows what each one actually says about benefits, and gives you three facts you can apply the next time an offer goes out.


What does "substantially equal work" mean when you are writing an offer?

It means you compare what the two jobs require to do the work, in practice, not what titles suggest. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission writes the standard plainly: two jobs require equal skill if the experience, ability, education and training required are substantially the same for each job ( EEOC, Section 10 Compensation Discrimination).

Notice what that sentence leaves out. It says nothing about what the applicant happens to hold. A degree the applicant happens to hold does not change what the job asks for. The EEOC cites a case where an accounting degree was irrelevant because the job never required one.

So the test for you as a recruiter is functional. Before you set the salary and benefits for an offer, ask what the role actually demands. Write the job description from the work, not from a posting you copied. Then compare the new role against roles you already pay.

Responsibility matters just as much. If you hand one person in a group of otherwise equal jobs a different task carrying a significant degree of responsibility, that person's job is no longer equal to the others. The EEOC also tells investigators to check the reverse: whether employees of the lower paid sex are being denied a chance to take on the extra responsibility that the higher paid employees already carry. If your promotion or stretch-assignment pattern lines up with gender, the EEOC tells investigators to consider it, so the pay pattern may be examined too.

A claimant in one of the EEOC's examples was a hotel clerk who alleged she was paid less than a man doing substantially equal work.

What this means at offer time: build your offer from the job's real requirements. If two offers differ in pay or benefits, be able to point to a difference in skill, effort, responsibility or working conditions. A difference in who applied for the job is not on that list.


Which benefits count as wages in an equal pay comparison?

All of them do, if you are looking at the California standard. The California Equal Pay Act defines "wages" and "wage rates" to include all forms of pay — not limited to salary — and the list runs long: overtime pay, bonuses, stock, stock options, profit sharing and bonus plans, life insurance, vacation and holiday pay, cleaning or gasoline allowances, hotel accommodations, reimbursement for travel expenses, and benefits ( California Department of Industrial Relations, California Equal Pay Act).

Read that list again as a recruiter. "Benefits" appears as its own term at the end. Vacation and holiday pay sit inside the definition of wages. Life insurance sits inside it. So a comparison that looks only at base salary is comparing a slice, not the whole.

That changes how you structure an offer. If two employees do substantially equal work, and one carries a richer benefits package, the gap is part of the wage picture. You do not get to wave it away as "non-cash" or "just perks" under the California Equal Pay Act, whose definition sweeps benefits in; other jurisdictions' definitions must be checked separately.

This is where the two rules on this page pull in different directions, and you need to hold both at once. The California definition tells you what counts when you are measuring wages.

The three benefit facts

Here they are, one each:

  1. Skill is judged by what the job requires, not what the person holds. The EEOC's standard: experience, ability, education and training that are substantially the same for each job, compared on the characteristics of the jobs themselves.

  2. A responsibility change breaks equality inside a group. If one employee in a group performing otherwise equal jobs is given a different task requiring a significant degree of responsibility, their job is not equal to the others' — and investigators should consider whether the lower paid sex has been kept from that work.

  3. Benefits belong inside the wage under California's definition. The California Equal Pay Act lists benefits, vacation and holiday pay, life insurance, allowances, reimbursements, bonuses and stock inside its definition of wages and wage rates.


How does the ACA fit into a benefits decision on an offer?

The ACA part of your offer letter is about who qualifies for your health plan and how your hours count, and it runs through a test called applicable large employer status. The Internal Revenue Service page on the topic spells out how you determine whether you are an applicable large employer ( IRS, Determining if an employer is an applicable large employer).

Two facts from that page matter when you write an offer to someone who will not work full-time hours:

  • An ALE need not offer minimum essential coverage to its part-time employees to avoid an employer shared responsibility payment.
  • A part-time employee who receives the premium tax credit for buying coverage through the Marketplace cannot trigger an employer shared responsibility payment.

Put plainly: a part-time hire who takes marketplace coverage does not cost you a shared responsibility payment on their account. And you are not required to put them on your minimum essential coverage to avoid that payment.

This is a clean answer to a question recruiters get in the offer call. A person working below full-time hours asks why they are not on the company plan. You can say the rules do not require the company to cover them for this purpose, and their own coverage does not create a penalty for the company. You can keep the rest of the offer discussion on salary and the benefits you are actually providing.

Do not carry that answer over to a full-time hire. The two facts above are written for part-time employees. Whether an ALE must offer coverage to a full-time employee to avoid a shared responsibility payment is a separate test, and the source you have in hand here does not state it. Ask your tax adviser before you answer a full-time hire on that point.

The table below pulls the three benefit facts and the two ACA statements into one view you can check against an offer before it goes out.

What you are decidingThe rule that appliesSource
Does this degree change the skill comparison? Compare jobs on experience, ability, education and training required — substantially the same for each jobEEOC Section 10
Does a new task change the comparison? A different task requiring a significant degree of responsibility makes that job unequal to the othersEEOC Section 10
Do benefits count as wages? Wages include salary, overtime, bonuses, stock, profit sharing, life insurance, vacation and holiday pay, allowances, reimbursements, and benefitsCalifornia Equal Pay Act
Must you cover a part-time hire?An ALE need not offer minimum essential coverage to part-time employees to avoid a shared responsibility paymentIRS ALE page
Does their marketplace coverage hurt you?A part-time employee's premium tax credit cannot trigger an employer shared responsibility paymentIRS ALE page

How do you compare two offers you are about to send?

You write both offers from the same factual base, then check them against the three benefit facts. Start with the job requirements. If the roles need substantially the same experience, ability, education and training, treat them as equal in skill for this purpose. If one role genuinely needs a credential the other does not, write that into the job description before you set the number.

Next, check responsibility. If one of the two people will carry a different task with a significant degree of responsibility, note it in the file. The comparison changes. You are no longer comparing equal jobs.

Then walk the benefits line item by item. Under the California definition, vacation, holiday pay, life insurance, allowances, reimbursements, bonuses, stock and profit sharing all sit inside wages. If Offer A carries a longer holiday schedule or a life insurance benefit Offer B lacks, that is a wage difference.

On the ACA side, sort the hire by hours first. If the person will be part-time, you know the two facts: you are not required to offer them minimum essential coverage to avoid a shared responsibility payment, and their marketplace premium tax credit will not trigger one either. Put that in the benefits section of the offer in plain words. Then run the same check on your existing employees doing the same role. If the part-time role sits next to a full-time role doing substantially equal work, the benefits difference between them needs the same functional explanation.

The pattern that gets firms in trouble is drift. Offers written at different times, by different people, from different examples. Two people doing the same job end up with different holiday schedules or different life insurance values, and nobody wrote down why. The equal pay test is a comparison test. It needs a comparison you can defend.


What should the offer letter say about benefits, line by line?

Say what you are providing, in the terms the law would use to measure it. Name the health plan and who is eligible under it. Name vacation and holiday pay with the amounts or schedules you actually offer. Name life insurance if you provide it. Name any allowance, reimbursement, bonus or stock component.

If the role is part-time, add the ACA sentence in your own words: the company is not offering minimum essential coverage for this role to meet the employer shared responsibility rules, and coverage the employee buys through the Marketplace does not create a shared responsibility payment for the company.

If the role is full-time, leave that sentence out and ask your tax adviser what your obligation is before you promise a start date on coverage. The IRS page you have in hand addresses part-time employees on both points. It does not settle the full-time question.

Keep the file with the offer. Save the job requirements you wrote, the responsibility notes, and the benefits list. If a question comes up later about why two offers differ, the file is the answer.


What happens if two people in the same job end up with different benefits?

Then you have a wage difference on a job the Equal Pay Act may treat as substantially equal, and the EEOC's functional standard applies. The EEOC's standard is functional: the analysis of the skills the jobs actually require.

Those explain how the gap happened. They do not place the difference inside skill, effort, responsibility or working conditions.

The responsibility angle is worth one more look because it cuts both ways. The EEOC directs investigators to consider whether employees of the lower paid sex are being discriminatorily denied the opportunity to assume the additional responsibilities that the higher paid employees already carry. If your stretch assignments, your "senior" labels, and your richer benefit packages all travel the same direction, note it: investigators should consider whether employees of the lower paid sex are being denied the chance to take on the additional responsibilities borne by the higher paid employees.


What should you do before the next offer goes out?

Three checks, in order, and none of them takes long.

Check the job requirements. Write them from the work. Confirm that experience, ability, education and training are what the role needs, not what a favored applicant happened to have. If two roles are being compared, compare their characteristics as jobs.

Check the responsibility split. If anyone in the group has a different task with a significant degree of responsibility, record it. If the pattern of who gets those tasks tracks with gender, fix the pattern before the pay pattern attracts the same question.

Check the benefits line. Under the California Equal Pay Act, treat vacation, holiday pay, life insurance, allowances, reimbursements, bonuses, stock and profit sharing as part of wages when you compare; check your own state's definition separately. Sort the hire by hours for the ACA questions, and write the part-time sentence only when the role is part-time.

Do these three checks on the offer you are about to send. Then do them on the offer you sent last month, because that one is also still out there.

Related guides: Break and meal pay: 3 sources to read before a shift offer · Check pay equity before approving an offer: 5 checks · Equal pay claim deadlines: 2 years, or 3 if willful.

Sources