Two jobs count as substantially equal when skill, effort, responsibility, and working conditions sit close enough together that a pay gap needs a real reason. The EEOC's six examples show where that line falls and what breaks it.
- Test the duties, not the titles: the standard looks at what the person does each week across skill, effort, responsibility, and working conditions.
- Regular extra duties can justify a gap: two workers regularly hauling heavy crates changes the effort comparison.
- Rotating a duty weakens the gap: when everyone takes a turn, rotation weakens the reason for a standing pay difference.
- Occasional, low-stakes duties carry little weight: an occasional walk-around at day's end is a difference, but a thin one.
- Time of day is out of the test: the guidance says directly it is not a working condition, and different surroundings do not automatically break similarity.
You set pay for two similar jobs. A person asks why one offer is higher. Your answer has to hold up. The EEOC writes short examples for exactly this moment. This post walks six of them.
The examples come from Section 10 of the EEOC's compensation discrimination guidance. Use them as a checklist before you send an offer. When you and a hiring manager disagree, point at the example that matches. When the example matches your facts, adjust the offer.
The standard you are actually testing
Substantially equal work is the test. Equal work in every detail is not the standard. Two jobs count as substantially equal when the skill, effort, responsibility, and working conditions sit close enough together that a pay gap needs a reason.
Skill covers what the person must know or be able to do. Effort is the mental and physical work. Responsibility is what the person must decide or be accountable for. Working conditions include surroundings, hazards, and similar factors. If two roles match on those four, a higher salary for one is a claim waiting to happen.
Time of day is not a working condition in this test. The guidance says so directly: "The time of day or night in which each of the jobs is performed is not a working condition for purposes of determining whether the jobs are substantially equal within the meaning of the EPA." Different physical surroundings do not automatically defeat similarity either.
The easy mistake is to compare titles. Titles are not the test. The test looks at what the person does each week. If you have two "associate" roles, the duties decide. Write the duties down before the offer goes out. With duties written down, the reason for a gap is easy to check.
Scenario one: two salespeople, two departments
The first example: "Example 23: CP, a sales person in the women's clothing department of the respondent's store, alleges that she is paid less than a male sales person in the men's clothing department."
Two departments, same job title. The claim is not about the merchandise. It is about the pay. If the selling work is the same, the gap has to rest on something real.
Ask yourself what would be different in the offer. Same hours. The same customers each shift. Same register work. Same stocking and display duties. Same reporting line. If you cannot name a difference in skill, effort, responsibility, or conditions, the gap is a risk.
Store environments make this easy to test. Walk both departments. Count the tasks. Check whether one role carries an extra duty the other does not. If both roles are the same shape, set the offers the same. When a person moves from one department to another and the offer drops, you need the reason in writing before you send it.
Scenario two: the same gap across a group
The second example widens the claim: "Example 24: CP alleges that she and other female grocery store workers are paid less than males who perform substantially equal work."
One employee's gap becomes a pattern. The word "substantially equal" does the work. If the roles match, the gap covers the group. A hiring manager writing a single offer may not see that.
Before you set pay, list the differences that matter. If the only difference is the person's history in a prior job, that history belongs in the decision for that person.
Small firms feel this fast. Your roster is short. Everyone can see the bands. If two people do the same job and take home different checks, the conversation happens in the break room before it happens in your office. Use the four-part test on the roles first. Then set the ranges.
Scenario three: heavy crates and real effort
The third example adds one duty: "Example 25: Same as Example 24, except two of the male grocery store workers also regularly haul heavy crates from trucks into the store."
Now the jobs are not the same. Hauling heavy crates is effort. Regular hauling changes the role, not the title. The gap has a factual base. On effort, the roles now differ.
This is the scenario that teaches the habit. Write the physical tasks down. Note who does them and how often. "Regularly" matters here. A duty that sits in one person's week and not in another's is a difference you can show. If you change the duty, you change the comparison.
Watch for the reverse mistake. If the crate hauling rotates across the crew, the effort sits with the group. The gap that rests only on a duty nobody holds all the time is weaker. Keep the record current when duties move between people.
Scenario four: extra responsibility, one person
The fourth example is a single role difference: "Example 26: CP, a female sales clerk, claims that a male sales clerk performs substantially equal work for higher compensation."
The word "performs" carries the claim. If the male clerk's week includes something the female clerk's week does not, the claim narrows to that duty. Responsibility is one of the four parts of the test. A higher offer for a role with more responsibility is a different conversation.
Map the week before the offer. Register close. Bank deposit. Vendor calls. Check acceptance. Lockup. If one clerk signs off on deposits and the other does not, you have a responsibility difference on paper. If both do, you do not.
Responsibility has to be real. A duty that appears in a job description but never in the week is not a defense. Ask the manager to name the last time the higher-paid clerk used the duty. If the answer is vague, the offer needs a second look.
Scenario five: rotate the duty, close the gap
The fifth example changes the duty's shape: "Example 27: Same as Example 26, except that CP, her male comparator, and the other sales clerks rotate handling the additional responsibility of determining whether to accept personal checks."
The duty still exists. Now everyone takes a turn. Rotation spreads the responsibility across the group. The roles sit closer together again. The gap loses its clean base.
This is a fix you can use. If a higher-paid role carries a duty that only one person holds, offer rotation. Write the rotation into the schedule. Once the duty is shared, the reason for the standing gap weakens. Keep the roster so you can show who held the duty and when.
Rotation also surfaces a second point. If the duty is rare, its weight in the comparison shrinks. If it is weekly, it carries more. Track the pattern over weeks, not a single shift. Your record should answer the question a person asks: how often does this actually happen?
Scenario six: an occasional walk-around
The sixth example is the smallest difference of the six: "Example 28: Same as Example 26, except the only difference in responsibility between the jobs of CP and her comparator is that the comparator occasionally is given the responsibility for performing a 'walk around' inside the building at the end of the day to make sure nothing is out of the ordinary."
An occasional walk-through. Nothing is out of the ordinary. The duty exists. Its weight is light. The claim still asks whether a gap built on that difference holds.
Notice how much depends on the word "occasionally." Compare it with the crate example. One duty is regular and physical. The other is occasional and low-stakes. Both are differences. They do not carry the same weight when you set two offers next to each other.
Small firms run into this version often. One person locks up. One person checks the alarm log. The duties are tiny. If a pay gap rests only on a duty this size, put the duty in writing, share it if you can, and recheck the bands.
Here is how the six scenarios compare on the key fact each one changes.
| Scenario | What changes in the example |
|---|---|
| Example 23 | Two departments, same selling job |
| Example 24 | Gap extends to a group of workers |
| Example 25 | Two workers regularly haul heavy crates |
| Example 26 | One clerk has more responsibility |
| Example 27 | The extra duty rotates across clerks |
| Example 28 | An occasional walk-around at day's end |
Defenses that hold and defenses that do not
A gap needs a reason that survives scrutiny. The guidance points at merit as a structured defense. It sets a high bar: "A merit system, to operate as a defense, must be a structured procedure in which employees are evaluated at regular intervals according to predetermined criteria, such as efficiency, accuracy, and ability." The system can rest on an objective measure like a test or on a subjective rating.
Read that as a list of conditions. Structured. Regular intervals. Predetermined criteria. Miss one and it does not operate as a defense. A raise that arrives because a manager felt generous in March does not meet the bar. Neither does a rating that changed its scale halfway through the year.
Seniority is another common reason. Two people at the same tenure in the same role should land in the same place. If seniority explains only part of a gap, name the rest.
Market rates and prior salary are reasons people reach for quickly. Treat them carefully. Prior pay describes the person's history, not the job's duties. If your two roles are substantially equal, a history of different past pay is a thin bridge between them.
Credentials that no part of the role uses do not carry weight. Ask whether the higher-paid clerk uses the extra training in the week. If not, drop it from the reason you would write down.
Write the reason in plain words before the offer. If you cannot write it, you do not have it. A written reason you can hand to a person is the cheapest test you will run all year.
Before you send the offer
Use this short pass on every offer where two similar roles sit side by side.
- Duties in writing: list the weekly tasks for both roles.
- Four-part test: check skill, effort, responsibility, conditions.
- Regular duties: mark what happens weekly and what happens rarely.
- Rotation: note who holds shared duties and when.
- Merit structure: confirm the evaluation schedule and criteria.
- Reason on paper: write the gap's reason in plain words.
If any line comes back empty, fix the band or fix the duty. Do not send the offer and hope the question never arrives.
Questions applicants actually ask
"Why does my offer sit below the person next to me?" Answer with the duty, not the title. Name the responsibility or effort difference. Point at the schedule or roster that shows it. If your only answer is a feeling, the offer needs a second look.
"If I take the extra duty, does the band change?" Say yes or no before the swap. If the duty is the difference, write the change into the offer. Update the roster so the record matches the week.
"Does the shift or desk location change anything?" Time of day does not count. Surroundings alone do not decide it, but they still need to be judged. Different surroundings do not automatically break similarity either. Judge the roles on skill, effort, responsibility, and conditions.
"My last job paid more. Can that carry over?" Prior pay describes the person's history. It does not describe your two roles. If the roles are substantially equal, set them on your own bands and explain your own reasons.
"How often does the extra duty have to happen to count?" The EEOC examples here do not set a frequency threshold. Ask your counsel how the duty's frequency reads in your own record. Then decide whether to share the duty or hold it with one person.
What to do this week
Pick the two roles you are most likely to hire again this year. Write the weekly duties for both on one page. Run the four-part test. Mark every duty that is regular, every duty that rotates, and every duty that is occasional.
Then look at your bands. If the gap rests on nothing you can name, close it before the next offer. If the gap rests on a real difference, write that difference in the offer file in plain words. Keep the schedule or roster that proves it.
Two jobs, one gap, one reason. Your reason has to be specific, current, and shared by the people who do the work. Build the record now, while the roles are quiet. The person who asks in six months will ask you the same way the examples do.
Related guides: 3 factors to check when two jobs look equal · Equal pay claim deadlines: 2 years, or 3 if willful · Break and meal pay: 3 sources to read before a shift offer.