Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Medical questions on applications: 2 EEOC sample wordings

Related guides: Accessible job application forms: 5 checks · Job post break terms: 4 details to state clearly · 3 California shift terms to put in a job posting.

Why medical questions on applications need care

An application form is often the first place a hiring team asks about health. A question that seems routine, such as asking about past illness, can pull disability information into your files before anyone has made an offer. The wording you choose matters as much as the reason you have for asking.

This is especially true for small teams. Without a legal department on call, a recruiter or a two-person staffing office may write a form in an afternoon and use it for months. Often nobody re-reads it until something goes wrong.

The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) publishes a technical assistance manual on the employment provisions of the Americans with Disabilities Act. That manual includes sample wording. This post looks at two of those samples, at the separate rule for disability self-identification, and at how a small team can put both into practice.

Recruiters and staffing teams often copy questions from older forms, from a client's existing wording, or from a job board's default fields. That habit is how problem wording keeps spreading. Reading each question against what it asks for is a quick check you can run on your own form this week.

The two sample wordings

The manual's first sample asks ( EEOC manual):

Sample wordingFormatTime windowSource
Please list any conditions or diseases for which you have been treated in the past 3 years.List of conditions or diseasesPast 3 years EEOC
Have you had a major illness in the last 5 years?Yes-or-no, "major illness" undefinedLast 5 years EEOC
Both questions reach into medical historyHealth information disclosure3 years and 5 years EEOC

> "Please list any conditions or diseases for which you have been treated in the past 3 years."

The second sample asks ( EEOC manual):

> "Have you had a major illness in the last 5 years?"

Both questions reach into the applicant's medical history. The first asks for a list. It names conditions or diseases and looks back three years. The second is phrased as a yes-or-no question, but it leaves "major illness" for the applicant to interpret, and it looks back five years.

A time window only limits how far back the question reaches. It only limits how far back the question reaches. An applicant who answers either one is giving you health information, whether or not that information has anything to do with the job they want. Even a plain "no" is an answer to a question about health.

When you review your own form, ask three things. What does the wording ask the applicant to disclose? What time period does it cover? Who on your team will read the answer? If the honest answer to the last question is "the recruiter who screens resumes," fix that before the form goes live.

Self-identification is a separate question

Some employers invite applicants to say they have a disability. That is not the same as asking about medical history, and the EEOC manual handles it in its own section. The heading reads ( EEOC manual):

ElementWhat the quoted text saysSource
Heading 5.5(c) Exception for Federal Contractors Covered by Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act and Other Federal Programs Requiring Identification of Disability EEOC
Who may invite Federal contractors and subcontractors covered by Section 503 EEOC
Where invited On a job application form or by other pre-employment inquiry EEOC
Why To satisfy the affirmative action requirements of Section 503 EEOC
Other programs Heading mentions other federal programs; excerpt does not describe them EEOC

> "5.5(c) Exception for Federal Contractors Covered by Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act and Other Federal Programs Requiring Identification of Disability."

The text under that heading says:

> "Federal contractors and subcontractors who are covered by the affirmative action requirements of Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act may invite individuals with disabilities to identify themselves on a job application form or by other pre-employment inquiry, to satisfy the affirmative action requirements of Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act."

Read the scope carefully. The text describes an exception for federal contractors and subcontractors that are covered by Section 503. It is not a general permission for every employer to ask about disability on an application. The invitation is tied to Section 503 affirmative action requirements, so the reason for asking is set by that law and its affirmative action requirements.

The heading also mentions "other federal programs requiring identification of disability." The excerpt does not describe those programs. If one of them could apply to your work, check it separately rather than assuming the Section 503 text covers it.

Compare the rules side by side

The table below uses only facts from the quoted text in this post. It adds no other rule.

ItemWhat the quoted text says
First sampleAsks applicants to list conditions or diseases treated in the past 3 years
Second sample Asks whether the applicant had a major illness in the last 5 years
Self-identification invitation Open to federal contractors and subcontractors covered by Section 503
Purpose of the invitationTo satisfy Section 503 affirmative action requirements
Handling of responses Must follow Section 503 rules on how the information is requested and used, and be kept as a separate, confidential record, apart from regular personnel records

The first two rows are about time windows: three years for conditions, five years for major illness. The last three rows cover who may invite self-identification, why, and how the answers must be kept. Those are the parts to check against your own form.

Handling self-identification answers

The quoted text includes a requirement that is easy to miss when you are focused on the form itself. It says ( EEOC manual):

ObligationWhat the quoted text saysSource
Manner of requestObserve Section 503 requirements on how information is requested EEOC
Use of answers Observe Section 503 requirements on how information is used EEOC
Storage Maintain as a separate, confidential record EEOC
Separation Apart from regular personnel records EEOC
Who this applies toEmployers who request such information EEOC

> "Employers who request such information must observe Section 503 requirements regarding the manner in which such information is requested and used, and the procedures for maintaining such information as a separate, confidential record, apart from regular personnel records."

That sentence covers three things: how you ask, how you use the answer, and where you keep it. The excerpt names the separate record but does not reproduce the Section 503 rules themselves. Read those rules before you decide how your team will use the answers. Do not treat the form's wording as the whole picture.

For a small team, the separation usually comes down to a few habits. Keep self-identification answers in a file that is not the applicant's personnel folder. Limit who can open that file. Write down who has access and why, so the rule exists before the first application arrives. Keep the answers out of the file that screeners and hiring managers review, so the people who decide who gets an interview never see disability information.

Rewriting a bad question

Seeing a fix often helps more than reading a rule. Here is how a team might change the two sample questions so they ask about the job instead of the person's history. These are examples of direction, not approved wording. Have counsel review any final text.

Before: "Please list any conditions or diseases for which you have been treated in the past 3 years."

After: "This role requires [list the essential tasks, such as lifting, standing, or driving]. Can you perform these tasks with or without a reasonable accommodation?"

Before: "Have you had a major illness in the last 5 years?"

After: Remove it. If the job has a real safety requirement, describe that requirement in the posting and ask applicants to confirm they can meet it.

Notice what changed. The rewrite asks about the work, not the person's past. It also gives the applicant a clear description to respond to, which is more useful to you than a vague question about illness.

Before you keep a rewrite, read it out loud and ask whether an applicant could answer it without disclosing a condition, diagnosis, or treatment. If the answer is no, the question still needs work.

Explaining the form to applicants

Applicants often wonder why a form asks an unusual question. Tell them in plain words what the form is for and where their answers will go. A short note at the top of the section works well. Use wording like this, and fill in only what matches your actual process:

"[One sentence on the purpose of this section.] [One sentence on where the answer is stored and who can see it.]"

Staffing teams need one more step. If you place applicants with client companies, the client's form may differ from yours. Ask each client whether it is a federal contractor covered by Section 503 before you send applicants through its form. Tell applicants which company's form they are completing, so nobody is surprised by a question that came from somewhere else.

Online forms and required fields

A field marked as required forces an answer before the applicant can move on. If a health-related question sits in that position, the form effectively demands information that may not be needed for the decision in front of you.

Make sure no question that touches medical history is a required field. Then test the form yourself with the required settings turned on, so you see exactly what an applicant must answer. Check where the tool sends responses, too. Many tools export answers to a spreadsheet, and that spreadsheet can become a file everyone can open. Set its access the same way you set access to the stored self-identification answers.

A review workflow for small teams

Small staffing teams rarely have an employment lawyer on call, so the review process needs to be simple enough to repeat. One workable sequence:

  1. Write the draft questions from the job's real tasks, not from the old form.
  2. Mark every question that asks about health, medical treatment, illness, or disability.
  3. Send the marked questions to an employment lawyer or HR advisor, and keep their notes with the form.
  4. Test the form as an applicant would, including the required-field settings.
  5. Confirm who will receive each answer, and where it is stored.
  6. Record the date of approval and the name of the person who approved it.

The record in step six matters later. If someone asks why a question is on the form, you can show the review, the reviewer, and the date. A form with no approval record is hard to defend, even if its wording turns out to be fine.

What this post does not cover

This post covers the federal EEOC manual's two sample questions and the Section 503 text quoted above. It does not cover every law that could apply to your hiring. State and local laws can add their own rules for medical questions and disability inquiries, and those rules may differ from the federal text. Check them for every state where you hire, and check them again when you open a new office or place applicants in a new location.

A checklist for your application form

These steps are general practice, not legal advice. Check them with an employment lawyer or HR advisor before you publish a form.

  1. Start with the job. List the tasks the role requires and ask whether the applicant can perform them, with or without a reasonable accommodation.
  2. Remove medical history questions. Take out questions about conditions, diseases, or illnesses over a set period unless counsel has reviewed them and confirmed they belong.
  3. Confirm contractor status. Find out whether your company, or the client you are placing someone with, is a federal contractor covered by Section 503 before you add a self-identification invitation.
  4. Separate the invitation. If it applies, put the self-identification step on its own and state its Section 503 purpose in plain words.
  5. Store answers apart. Keep responses in a confidential record outside the personnel file, as the quoted text describes.
  6. Set access rules. Name the people who can see the answers. Screeners and hiring managers should not need them to do their jobs.
  7. Route accommodation requests. When an applicant asks for an accommodation during hiring, send the request to whoever handles accommodations, not to the hiring manager alone.
  8. Recheck the form. Review it when your contract status changes, when a client's form changes, or when you revise any question.

If you have no HR staff, name one person to own the form and its review. A form nobody owns tends to keep its old questions.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Copying an old form. Older forms often contain medical history questions that nobody reviewed.
  • Adding a self-identification question because another company has one. A client's or competitor's form does not decide your obligations.
  • Letting answers flow into the general applicant view. If self-identification answers appear next to resumes in the same screen, they are no longer kept apart.
  • Assuming a time window makes a question safe. As the two samples show, a three-year or five-year limit still asks for health information.
  • Acting on a health answer during screening. Treat any health answer as something to review with counsel, not something to act on while you sort applications.

Final word

Medical questions are easy to add and hard to remove once a form is live. The two EEOC samples give you a simple test: read the question, check its time window, and ask who will see the answer. For federal contractors covered by Section 503, the self-identification invitation has its own purpose, and the quoted text says the answers must be kept as a separate, confidential record. For most teams, the simpler path is to ask about the job and leave health history off the application.

Sources