Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

3 factors to check when two jobs look equal

What "equal work" actually means on your desk

You have two open roles. The salaries you are about to post differ. A complaint could later say the lower-paid job was equal to the higher-paid one. The question you should ask now is simple: what does the EEOC look at when it judges whether two jobs are equal?

The answer is job content. Not job titles. Not pay grades. Not which floor the desk sits on. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says plainly that job content, not job titles or classifications, determines the equality of jobs. That one sentence is the spine of everything below. You can read it in full in the EEOC's guidance on compensation discrimination: Section 10, Compensation Discrimination.

This post walks through three job-content factors you can use when you compare two roles side by side. They are the factors an investigator will weigh if a charge lands. They are also the factors you should weigh before you set pay, because fixing a structure after a complaint costs far more than designing it well.

The three factors are: whether the job titles mislead, whether the two jobs share a common core of tasks, and whether department placement actually changes the work.

Key takeaways

  • Two jobs can sit in different departments and still be equal work.
  • A common core of tasks can make jobs equal even when one role does extra insubstantial duties.
  • Examine duties, skill, effort, and working conditions — not the label on the offer letter.
  • Fix pay disparities now, before a charge arrives. Oregon's rule shows one approach: wages may not be reduced to reach compliance.

Factor one: title and classification are not the test

The most common mistake in a pay comparison is starting from the title. You look at "Office Manager" and "Administrative Assistant" and conclude they are different jobs. An investigator will not stop there. Titles are a starting point for a conversation, not a finding.

The guidance says that jobs in different departments are not automatically unequal either. Department can matter in a specific case, but it is not determinative on its own. In other words: sit the two roles down, list what each person actually does, and compare the lists.

Consider how this plays out in practice. The guidance includes a case where a Hispanic administrative assistant alleges she earns less than the office manager, though in her view they perform similar work. A recommended approach is not to start from the titles. Pull both job descriptions, then check whether the day-to-day work matches.

Another case in the same guidance involves a college teacher who says she is paid less than a male teacher in the same school. Here the setting is identical — same school — and the pay still differs. That is exactly the shape of complaint that shows why titles and location cannot carry the analysis on their own.

A third case involves a person who manages insurance claims at an insurance brokerage firm. "Manages" in a title can sound senior. When you assess a role like this, check whether the managing tasks match the comparator's.

Before you post a salary, do this: write down the duties of each role as they exist today, not as the job description imagined them last year. Compare the lists. If the lists match closely, the different titles will not protect the pay gap.

Why job descriptions drift

Job descriptions rot. A role picks up a task here, drops one there, and the document on the shared drive no longer matches the work. When a complaint arrives, the document is the first exhibit. If it is stale, you will spend the next weeks reconstructing real duties from memory.

Refresh both descriptions the same week. Ask the managers to list tasks, not traits. Strip adjectives. Compare the two lists side by side. This habit helps you spot misalignments early.

The table: how the three factors read

Here is the three-factor test at a glance, built only from the guidance's own statements.

FactorWhat the guidance says it isWhat it is not
Job title and classificationNot determinative of equalityNot the deciding test
Department placement Not determinative; may be indicative in some casesNot an automatic difference in job content
Common core of tasks Jobs with the same common core are equal when extra duties are insubstantialNot defeated by a couple of small added tasks

Factor two: the common core of tasks

This is the factor hiring managers most often get wrong, because it sounds technical and it is not. The rule is short: when two jobs share a common core of tasks, they are equal — even if the comparators perform extra duties, as long as those extra duties are insubstantial. That sentence appears in the same EEOC guidance linked above.

Read it again slowly. Two jobs. Same core. One has extras. If the extras are small — insubstantial — the jobs remain equal for pay-comparison purposes.

So the practical question becomes: what makes an extra duty insubstantial? The guidance frames equality around the work itself. Think in terms of time, skill, and responsibility. Does the extra duty take a meaningful share of the week? Does it require training the other role never needed? Does it carry authority the other role does not have? If the answer to all three is no, you are probably looking at an insubstantial extra.

Here is where many hiring managers over-correct. They assume any listed difference ends the comparison. It does not. A coordinator who also waters plants on Fridays still shares the core with a peer who does not. The plant-watering does not change the job's content enough to justify a different pay band.

The opposite is also true. If the extra duty is a large share of time, or needs real skill, or carries real authority, the jobs have drifted apart. Then you are comparing two different jobs, and you should be ready to explain the difference in tasks.

Show it in writing. Build the comparison before anyone asks. One page for each role: core tasks, extra tasks, and a short note on why each extra is substantial or insubstantial. Keep the page dated. If a question ever comes, you hand over the page instead of starting an investigation in your own office.

How to apply "substantial" consistently

The line between substantial and insubstantial is a judgment call, and you will have to make it. Make it consistently. Apply the same standard across both roles in the pair, and across every pair in the pay structure. Inconsistency is what turns a defensible difference into a problem.

Write the standard down. Choose a rule you can explain in one sentence. Use that rule everywhere. When two roles sit close to the line, treat them as equal and pay accordingly — a conservative internal rule you can adopt.

Factor three: department is context, not proof

Put the two roles in different departments and the difference feels obvious. One sits in operations. One sits in finance. Your instinct says they are different jobs. The guidance says department is not determinative, though in some cases it may be indicative of a difference in job content.

That phrasing is careful. Department can hint at a real difference. It cannot prove one. The investigator still has to look at the work.

Use department the way you would use a smell in the kitchen — worth checking, not worth betting on. When the two roles live apart, walk through the core-tasks test from factor two anyway. If the work matches, the department split does not save the pay gap.

Department also tends to hide duplicated work. Two teams often run the same function under different names. A coordinator in one department may do the same job as an analyst in another, with different labels and different pay. That is the classic shape of an equal-pay problem, and the department line will not excuse it.

There is one more reason to check department placement early. Roles that are similar but split across teams are worth checking against each other's pay bands. If your bands were set team by team, check them across departments. When you compare two open roles today, compare across departments even if your structure did not.

Build the comparison before the offer

Before you post either salary, sit with both descriptions and run the three factors in order. Title and classification: not decisive. Department: noted, not decisive. Common core of tasks: the real test, with each extra duty sized up honestly.

If the roles land equal, set the pay together and make sure the ranges match. If the roles land unequal, write down why — in tasks, not adjectives. That note is your shield later.

Do the work now while the comparison is calm. After a charge arrives, every gap in your reasoning becomes expensive.

What happens after equality is established

Once two jobs are equal, the pay comparison has to hold up on its own. If the difference is not explained by job content, the pay gap needs an answer.

There is a related move worth knowing about, because it is the one employers reach for first. When you find a disparity, the instinct is to cut the higher salary down to match. Oregon's Bureau of Labor and Industries addresses that directly: a worker's wages may not be reduced in order to comply with the requirements of the pay equity law. You can read it on Oregon BOLI's equal pay page.

The same page raises a related question that hiring managers ask constantly: can you lower the salary of someone who turns out to be paid too high compared with others doing comparable work? Oregon's answer, in the words above, is no. If your situation sits under Oregon's law, that is the answer you work with. If it does not, ask your state labor department what applies where you are — that is the one question this post cannot settle for you.

Under Oregon's rule, the fix runs toward the low side: bring the low side up. Do it as a structural correction, not a one-off. Rebuild the bands so the equal roles sit together, then apply the new bands across every pair, not just the pair that triggered the review.

A checklist you can run this week

Print this. Run it on every pay decision before the offer goes out.

  • List duties, not titles. Write what each person does on an ordinary Tuesday.
  • Find the common core. Circle the tasks that appear in both lists.
  • Size the extras. For each task in one list only, judge time, skill, and authority.
  • Note the department, then set it aside. It is context. It is not the test.
  • Check consistency. Apply the same standard to every pair in the structure.
  • Write the reason. One short paragraph on why the roles are equal or unequal.
  • Date the page. Keep it with the job description.

If any line fails, stop before you post the salary. Fix the structure first.

FAQ

Does a different job title protect us? No. The guidance states that job content, not job titles or classifications, determines the equality of jobs. A title change without a work change does not move the analysis.

What if the roles sit in different departments? Department is not determinative. It may indicate a content difference in some cases, but the investigator still looks at the tasks. Compare the core first.

One role does three extra tasks. Does that end the comparison? Not automatically. Jobs with the same common core of tasks are equal even when the comparators perform extra duties, if those extras are insubstantial. Judge each extra on time, skill, and authority.

We found a gap. Can we cut the higher salary? Oregon's rule says a worker's wages may not be reduced to comply with pay equity requirements. Outside Oregon, confirm with your state labor department.

How current do our job descriptions need to be? Current enough to describe the work as it exists today. The description is the first thing anyone will read, so a stale one costs you weeks of reconstruction. Refresh both roles the same week.

What if two roles sit close to the line? Treat them as equal and pay them together. That is a conservative internal rule you can adopt, and it keeps your structure consistent across every pair.

Sources