Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Test essential job functions before screening out applicants

Before you screen out an applicant over physical or mental duties, test only the essential functions of the job: the fundamental duties the person must perform alone or with a reasonable accommodation. The EEOC states that an employer cannot refuse to hire someone because a disability prevents them from performing duties that are not essential to the job.

What makes a function essential

Every screening decision built on physical or mental duties starts with one question: which duties are essential? The EEOC defines essential functions as "the fundamental job duties that you must be able to perform on your own or with the help of a reasonable accommodation" ( EEOC, Your Employment Rights as an Individual with a Disability).

Notice the two parts of that definition. The duties must be fundamental, which means they go to the core of the job rather than to tasks that merely appear on a list. The test is also about performance. The applicant must be able to perform the duty, either unaided or with a reasonable accommodation. If the applicant can do the fundamental work with an accommodation, the definition is met.

In practice, read the job description and sort each listed duty into one of two groups. The first group holds duties fundamental to the role: the reason the position exists, the work the employee would spend most of their time on, or work no one else on the team could take over without changing the job. The second group holds everything else, such as occasional tasks, backup duties, or tasks that could be reassigned without changing the job.

Write this sorting down before you interview anyone. A written record shows what you decided and why, and it keeps the criteria tied to the job rather than to your impression of an applicant on a given day. Ask the hiring manager to explain each essential duty in plain language so that every screener applies the same meaning.

Be careful with "essential" as a casual label. A duty that is important, frequent, or difficult is not automatically essential. The question is whether it is fundamental to the job as the employer actually structures it.

Non-essential duties cannot block a hire

The EEOC's guidance is just as direct on the other side of the line: "An employer cannot refuse to hire you because your disability prevents you from performing duties that are not essential to the job."

This protects applicants when a screener sees a limitation and rejects the applicant without asking whether the limited task matters. Suppose an applicant says they cannot perform an occasional task. Before you act on that answer, check which group the task sits in. If the task is marginal, the inability to perform it cannot be the reason you refuse to hire.

The rule governs the hiring decision itself. A gap in a non-essential duty cannot be the reason you turn someone away, but whether the applicant can perform the fundamental work still decides the outcome. An applicant who can perform every essential duty, with or without accommodation, should not be rejected because of a marginal one.

Screeners often slip under time pressure. A resume or interview note records "cannot do X," and the note quietly becomes the decision. Build a simple habit: for every limitation an applicant mentions, ask whether the duty appears in your essential group. If it does not, the limitation cannot justify a rejection.

Keep the distinction visible in your notes. Record the essential duties the applicant can perform and the ones they need an accommodation for. Record marginal duties separately, and do not let them drive the decision. A short form helps: one column for the function, one for whether it is essential, one for whether the applicant can perform it with or without accommodation, and one for how the note affected the decision. A file kept this way explains your reasoning clearly if the decision is later questioned.

Lifting and shelving limits for a mail clerk

The EEOC's technical assistance manual uses a mail clerk to show what a specific, measurable duty looks like. The manual states that the mail clerk "also must receive incoming boxes of supplies up to 50 pounds in weight, and place them on storage shelves up to 6 feet in height" ( EEOC, A Technical Assistance Manual on the Employment Provisions (Title I) of the Americans with Disabilities Act).

The example matters because it gives both a weight and a height. A vague phrase such as "must handle heavy supplies" invites guesswork. A stated limit lets you ask a precise question and measure the answer against a fixed standard. The table below turns those figures into screening questions.

Element in the EEOC exampleFigure How to use it in screening
Incoming boxes of suppliesUp to 50 pounds Ask whether the applicant can receive boxes at this weight, alone or with accommodation
Storage shelvesUp to 6 feet in height Ask whether the applicant can place items on shelves at this height

The manual frames these as duties the mail clerk must perform. They are concrete tasks tied to the work of the office. When you write a job description, look for this level of detail. If a duty has a real limit, such as a weight, a height, or a required reach, state that figure in the description so the essential function is defined before anyone applies.

Measurable limits also guard against assumptions. Without a stated figure, a screener may picture the most demanding version of a task and reject based on that picture. With a stated figure, the question has a defined answer, and the applicant can respond to what the job actually requires.

Essential and marginal functions side by side

The manual shows how an employer can separate duties into two groups. For a secretary's job, it explains that the employer considered the activities of the particular office and the availability of other staff. The employer "has identified functions 1-6 as essential, and functions 7-9 as marginal to this secretary's job."

The comparison below sets the two groups side by side using only the facts in that example.

MeasureEssential functionsMarginal functions
Function numbers in the example1 through 67 through 9
Number of functions63
Basis for the splitOffice activities and availability of other staffOffice activities and availability of other staff
Role in the screening decision Evaluate ability to perform, with or without accommodationCannot alone be the reason to refuse hire because of a disability

The split is not fixed in the abstract. The manual ties it to the specific office. Two employers with the same job title could reasonably sort duties differently if their offices run differently, if one has more support staff, or if the work is divided among others in another way. Your sorting should reflect your own workplace and your own staffing.

Once the groups are set, keep them stable through the process. If you change the sort after you have seen applicants, you risk fitting the criteria to the people you already reviewed. Finalize the groups before you post the job, and record the date and the people who approved them so the decision can be reviewed later.

Asking about all nine secretary functions

The same example addresses the interview itself. The manual states: "The interviewer may ask questions related to all 9 functions; however, an applicant with limited mobility should not be screened out because of inability to perform the last 3 functions due to her disability."

This sentence separates two actions that screeners often merge. Asking about a function is permitted. Using an inability to perform a function as the reason to screen out an applicant is a different decision. The manual allows questions about all nine functions, including the three marginal ones. What it does not allow is screening out an applicant over the last three functions because of a disability.

Build your interview guide around this separation. For each function, write the question you will ask and the criterion that will drive the decision. Ask the same questions of every applicant for the role, and record the answers in the same format so that a reviewer can compare applicants fairly.

When a function is marginal, the question still has a purpose. It helps you learn how the applicant works and what support they may need, and it gives them a chance to describe their experience. It should not act as a gate that decides the hire. Keep the interview record clear about which answers informed the decision and which did not.

Judging the first six functions

The manual's guidance on essential functions is brief: "S/he should be evaluated on ability to perform the first 6 functions, with or without accommodation." The phrase "with or without accommodation" ties this rule to the definition discussed earlier, which allows for a reasonable accommodation when the applicant needs one.

The table compares what the interviewer may ask with what the decision should rest on. The left column covers all nine functions, while the right column's basis for the decision covers only functions 1-6.

MeasureQuestions the interviewer may ask Basis for the screening decision
Functions coveredAll 9 functionsFunctions 1-6
Number of functions96
AccommodationQuestions may relate to all nine functionsAbility is judged with or without accommodation
Last three functions (7-9) Questions allowedCannot alone be the reason to screen out an applicant with limited mobility

Apply this by asking whether the applicant can perform each essential function with or without a reasonable accommodation. If the answer is yes for every essential function, the applicant has met the standard the manual describes. If an accommodation is needed, discuss what it would involve, because the question is whether the applicant can perform the fundamental work with it.

Make sure the decision record follows the same structure. List each essential function, the applicant's ability to perform it, and any accommodation discussed. Then list the marginal functions the interviewer asked about, noting that they did not determine the outcome. A reviewer reading that record can see that the decision rested on the fundamental duties.

What a state finds when there is no discrimination

Not every complaint ends with a finding against the employer. The Washington State Human Rights Commission describes one possible outcome: "If the WSHRC finds no discrimination (no reasonable cause), both parties are contacted with that finding" ( Washington State Human Rights Commission, Employment). Both the employer and the person who filed the complaint receive the result, so you will not learn of it second-hand.

For a recruiter or hiring manager, this outcome is worth understanding before a complaint arrives. A no-cause finding means the agency did not find reasonable cause. It does not say what happens next, so read any notice carefully and note its date. The records you kept during screening are the best evidence of what you decided and why.

A no-cause finding should not change how you screen. Use the same essential-function list, the same questions, and the same record for every applicant. The finding answers one complaint. It is not permission to loosen the process for future applicants.

What happens when a state finds reasonable cause

A reasonable-cause finding is a more serious step. The same commission describes its next move this way: "If the WSHRC finds that illegal discrimination has occurred (reasonable cause), we first try to bring about a voluntary agreement with the parties to resolve the issues." In this case the agency has concluded that illegal discrimination occurred, and its first step is an attempt at voluntary agreement.

The word "first" matters. It signals that resolution talks come before any other step the agency may take. The quote does not describe those later steps, so do not guess at them when you plan.

You can prepare for the resolution conversation now. Pull the screening file and identify the essential functions each applicant was evaluated on. Check whether the interviewer relied on any marginal duty when deciding. If your file shows that marginal duties did not decide the outcome, the file supports your account. If a non-essential duty drove the rejection, you need to face that before talks begin.

Choose who will speak for the employer carefully. The people who ran the interviews should be able to explain their notes, and the person with authority to settle should understand what the file shows. Route any request for documents through the person responsible for compliance rather than the hiring manager. Avoid committing to terms before you have read the complaint and the agency's finding. Send any response in writing so the record shows what was offered and what was not.

How a Minnesota hearing report takes effect

The Minnesota statute addresses the effect of a hearing report directly. Under Minnesota Statutes section 363A.29, "The report of the administrative law judge shall be binding on all parties to the proceeding and if appropriate shall be implemented by an order as provided for in subdivision 3" ( Minnesota Legislature, Sec. 363A.29).

Two phrases carry most of the meaning. "Binding" means the report applies to the employer and the complainant alike. "If appropriate shall be implemented by an order" means an order carries out the report when an order fits the case. The statute points to subdivision 3 for how that order works, but the quote does not include that subdivision, so read the full section on the official site before you plan around a specific order.

For an employer, the practical lesson is that a binding report is an obligation, not advice to weigh. Ask legal counsel how the report applies to your business, what any order requires, and whether the report is a final decision or an interim step in your case. Keep your decision file, because it will be read alongside the report. Mark which document controls at each stage so your team never mistakes an early notice for the final word.

Comparing the outcomes

You cannot choose which state process applies to a complaint. The state and its laws decide that. What you can choose is how you prepare for each possible result. A useful exercise is to write a one-page plan for each outcome before any complaint arrives. The table compares the three outcomes these sources describe.

OutcomeWhat the source says What it means for your response
Washington: no discrimination (no reasonable cause)Both parties are contacted with that finding Read the notice, file it with your screening records, and keep the process unchanged
Washington: reasonable cause The commission first tries to bring about a voluntary agreementPrepare for resolution talks with your decision record in hand
Minnesota: administrative law judge reportThe report binds both sides and may be carried out by an orderTreat the report as binding and plan to comply with any order

The Washington outcomes depend on the agency's finding. The Minnesota outcome depends on a hearing report. These sources cover only Washington and Minnesota, so a reader in another state should consult that state's own official rules.

If you must decide one thing now, decide to keep the screening record that separates essential from marginal duties. Every outcome above depends on that record.

Reviewing a complaint step by step

When a complaint arrives, start with the paperwork. Confirm which agency is involved and what stage the matter has reached. The quoted WSHRC text describes two outcomes. A no-cause finding contacts both parties with the result. A reasonable-cause finding starts with an attempt at voluntary agreement.

Next, compare the complaint with your file. Work through these steps in order:

  1. Pull the essential-function list written before interviews began.
  2. Check each interview note for any decision that rested on a marginal duty.
  3. Check whether accommodation was discussed for any essential function.
  4. Record the dates of the notices you received and the dates of your responses.

If the matter moves to a hearing in Minnesota and a report issues, the report binds the parties. That is why the review should finish before any hearing. Whatever record you assemble now is the record you will have later.

Do not alter the original screening notes after a complaint arrives. Writing new notes that try to reconstruct past reasoning can look like an afterthought. If something is missing, say so in a dated note that is clearly labeled as new. Share the assembled file with counsel early, so that any gaps are identified while there is still time to document them honestly.

Related guides: Screening criteria: 3 groups to set before hiring · Federal drug-use terms: 3 checks before screening · ADA checks: 5 reviews before tests and interviews.

Questions readers ask

What counts as an essential function?

The EEOC defines essential functions as the fundamental job duties that you must be able to perform on your own or with the help of a reasonable accommodation. The test is whether the applicant can perform those core duties, unaided or with accommodation.

Is a Minnesota hearing report binding?

Yes, according to the statute. The report of the administrative law judge binds the parties to the proceeding, and it may be carried out by an order when an order is appropriate.

Sources