Before writing a hiring screen, define "drug," "illegal use of drugs," and the exclusion for supervised or otherwise authorized use. The federal starting point is the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, specifically sections 501 and 505, which the EEOC publishes in full. Three phrases in that text decide what a drug-use question can mean: "drug," "illegal use of drugs," and the exclusion inside the second definition for supervised use.
Drug-use questions often come from an older form, or from memory, and nobody checks them against the text. "Do you use drugs?" feels clear to the person who wrote it. An applicant reading it has to guess which substances are meant, whether medicines count, and whether the question concerns the past or the present. The federal text settles some of those points and leaves others to the employer. This post walks through the choices you still have to make.
The EEOC page also notes that "Section 505 contains provisions governing remedies and attorney's fees under Section 501." That sentence is a reminder to read the definitions as written. Conduct language and remedy language sit in different parts of the same law, so a screen should be checked against the exact wording rather than a paraphrase of it.
This post is for recruiters and hiring managers who ask applicants about drug use or write screening questions for a role. It covers only the federal terms. It is not a substitute for advice from your employment counsel, who should see the final wording before it goes live.
What does "drug" mean in the federal text?
The federal text defines "drug" as a controlled substance, not as any pill or product a person might take. The EEOC's copy says the term "drug" means "a controlled substance, as defined in schedules I through V of section 202 of the Controlled Substances Act." That is narrower than the everyday word, which many people use for any medicine, supplement, or substance they swallow or apply.
Use the defined word on purpose. If the question says "drugs" and nothing more, each applicant fills in a different meaning, and the answers cannot be compared. A one-line definition at the top of the question solves much of this. For example: "In this question, 'drug' means a controlled substance as defined under federal law." That line tells the applicant which category you mean and gives your team the same reference when they review the answers.
If you also care about alcohol, ask about it in its own question. Folding alcohol into "drug" makes both questions harder to read. The quoted definition does not mention alcohol at all, so nothing in it tells a reader whether alcohol is covered. Write the question so there is no doubt.
What does "illegal use of drugs" mean?
This phrase is narrower than "drug use" because it turns on legal status. The EEOC text says the term means "the use of drugs, the possession or distribution of which is unlawful under the Controlled Substances Act." It is not a test of whether an employer approves of an applicant's habits.
That distinction changes how you write the question. A screen that asks only whether an applicant uses drugs does not say whether you mean unlawful use, use outside work, or use at any time. The definition will not pick among those for you. Decide which one matters for the role, and name it. You might ask about use of a controlled substance during work hours, or about use that would be unlawful to possess or distribute, and then say which of the two you mean.
Settle the time period as well. The definition does not say whether a question should reach current use, past use, or both. Write that choice into the screen and keep the same frame for every applicant applying to the same role. Comparing one applicant's answer to one version of the question against another applicant's answer to a different version tells you nothing useful.
Does the federal text exclude lawful prescription use?
Yes, for medicine taken under supervision. The definition of "illegal use of drugs" says the term "does not include the use of a drug taken under supervision by a licensed health care professional, or other uses authorized by the Controlled Substances Act."
This exclusion is the easiest part to get wrong. A question such as "Are you taking any medication?" is not a question about illegal use. An applicant who answers yes may be describing a lawful prescription, which means the hiring team now holds information the definition never asked for and must sort it out after the fact.
If a medication question serves a real purpose for the role, write it so it does not suggest that a prescription is illegal use. Do not treat a yes answer as a finding. The safer path is to keep the drug-use question limited to illegal use as defined, and to handle any medication question separately, with counsel reviewing it.
How do I write a screening question with these terms?
Start with the defined term, then the activity you care about, then the time period, then the question itself. Match the defined term and the activity to the federal text; write in the time period as a separate drafting choice. If a key term in your question does not appear in the definitions, either define it or remove it.
The approach works because each term has a fixed meaning. Check your draft against the table, which points back to the definitions above:
| Term | Definition to check | Drafting check |
|---|---|---|
| drug | See the controlled-substance definition above. | Does the opening definition identify the substance category? |
| illegal use of drugs | See the possession-or-distribution wording above. | Does the question identify the relevant activity and time period? |
| supervised-use exclusion | See the full exclusion above, including other authorized uses. | Does the question preserve the exclusion? |
Once the draft is filled in, read it aloud as an applicant would. Ask whether the applicant could answer without guessing, and whether a truthful answer about a lawful medicine would be read as a yes. A workable version might read: "Do you currently use any controlled substance whose possession or distribution is unlawful under the Controlled Substances Act? Exclude use under supervision by a licensed health care professional and other uses authorized by that Act." Have counsel review this wording for the role before using it.
Why is "Do you use drugs?" a weak question?
It asks the applicant to solve three problems the writer has not solved. The applicant must work out which substances count, whether medicines are included, and what period is meant. Each guess is a place where applicants answer the same question and mean different things, which makes the answers hard to compare.
The question also invites an answer that is too broad. An applicant taking a supervised medicine may say yes out of caution. An applicant using a controlled substance in a narrow way may say no, reading the question as being about everyday life. Neither answer says much about the role.
A stronger question names the term, the activity, and the period, in that order. It gives the applicant enough to answer accurately, and it gives your team a fixed reference when answers are compared later. The extra words are not padding. They are what make the question usable.
How do the three terms work together?
The three terms work as a set. The first says which kind of substance is in scope. The second says the concern is legal status, not personal approval. The third says what sits outside the concern, which is often the most important line in the screen.
Review a draft in that order. First check that the substance word matches the definition of "drug." Then check the activity against the possession-or-distribution wording. Last, check the question against the full exclusion. If a draft fails a check, the fix is usually a single rewritten sentence, not a new policy.
The order also helps when the screen goes to someone outside your team, such as counsel or a hiring manager who missed the first meeting. They can follow the three checks without the background behind each choice, and they can point to the exact line that needs work.
Should a screen ask about past drug use?
That depends on the role and on what you need to know, and the definitions do not settle it. The text explains what counts as illegal use and what it excludes. It does not say whether a question about past use is useful for a particular job.
Start from what the job requires. A question tied to a specific duty is easier to explain to an applicant and to your own team than a broad question about someone's history. If you cannot name the duty the question serves, drop the question or narrow it before it goes into use.
Write down why you ask. A short note in the job file can record which duty the question serves, which definition it uses, and who approved it. That note makes later review simpler and helps the next person understand the choice without rebuilding it from memory.
What do I do when an applicant mentions a medication?
Treat the mention as information, not as an admission. Check it against the exclusion described above. An applicant who names such a medicine has not, on that fact alone, disclosed illegal use.
Do not press for medical details during the screen. The question you wrote asked about illegal use, and the answer concerned a lawful medicine. Questions about diagnosis go beyond the screen you designed. Ask counsel what follow-up, if any, is allowed before anyone on the team asks one.
Keep your notes factual. Record what was asked, what was said, and who heard it. Leave out opinions or guesses about the applicant's health. A plain record gives a reviewer something concrete to check. For related recordkeeping, see medical facts in a hiring report.
What changes at the state level?
This post covers only the federal terms. States can set their own rules, and some of those rules differ from the federal definitions in ways that matter for a screen. Minnesota is a useful example of why the federal text is only a starting point.
Minnesota's employment statute addresses substance use disorder directly. Section 181.938 says an employer does not violate subdivision 2 by refusing to hire an applicant or disciplining or discharging an employee who refuses or fails to comply with the conditions of a substance use disorder treatment or aftercare program ( Minnesota Legislature, Office of the Revisor of Statutes). The treatment or aftercare program is central to that provision. Read it as a program-related provision rather than a general rule about substance use disorder.
It also provides that "cannabis flower, cannabis products, lower-potency hemp edibles, and hemp-derived consumer products are lawful consumable products for the purpose of Minnesota law, regardless of whether federal or other state law considers cannabis use, possession, impairment, sale, or transfer to be unlawful." Check that Minnesota provision separately when reviewing the screen.
Before you finalize a screen, check the rules for the place where the role is based, and for any other place applicants are likely to live or apply from. Ask counsel to confirm which rules apply. Do not assume that one location's rule applies everywhere, and do not assume the federal wording covers every question a state might regulate.
Who should review the final screen?
Have the screen reviewed by your employment counsel and by at least one person who will ask the questions, because each reader notices different problems. Send them the definitions, the exact question text, and the reason for each question. Ask them to read the question as an applicant would, and to mark every word that is not defined in the screen.
Then rewrite each marked word or delete it. Keep a dated copy of the approved version, so you can show which wording was used for each role and when it was approved. If the wording changes later, record the change and the reason for it in the same file.
Review the screen again whenever the role's duties change or the team asks for a new question. A question that made sense for one job may not fit a different one, even when the job titles look the same. Counsel's review is the check that catches what the people inside the process have stopped noticing.
How do I keep the screen consistent across applicants?
Ask the same question, with the same definitions, to every applicant for the same role. Consistency makes the answers comparable, and it protects the hiring process from the appearance that different applicants were asked different things. Write the standard wording into the job file so that anyone who conducts a screen uses it.
Train the people who conduct screens on the three terms. A short walkthrough is enough: what "drug" means in the screen, what "illegal use of drugs" covers, and what the supervised-use exclusion removes. Ask them to read the approved question aloud before their first screen, so the wording is familiar and they do not improvise a version of their own.
Do not add follow-up questions that the approved screen does not include. An improvised question can move a screen away from its definitions, even when added with good intent. If a follow-up seems necessary, send it back through the review steps above before anyone asks it.
Finally, keep the approved screen somewhere the team can find it. A screen that lives in one person's inbox tends to be copied, edited, and forgotten. A single approved version in a shared location gives the next recruiter a clear starting point and makes the next review faster.
Related guides: Age discrimination: 8 hiring and benefits rules · Applicant drug testing: 6 mistakes to fix before hiring · California fair chance hiring: 3 rules to check.