The three hiring rules California employers should review are fair chance screening, expunged convictions, and Form I-9 checks. Small hiring teams in California can reach the five-employee mark without noticing. One day you're a founder who reads every application yourself, and the next you have a recruiter, two managers, and a standing job post. The extra headcount also brings extra legal obligations, and some of them start at a size that's easy to miss.
Key takeaways
- Check your headcount against the five-employee threshold, and check local ordinances for the city where you hire.
- Review any dismissed conviction under Penal Code § 1203.4 with counsel before it affects a hiring decision.
- Confirm that your screening vendor applies the seven-year reporting limit, which California does not relax for high salaries.
- Assign one person to own the Form I-9 and schedule it as a standard onboarding step.
This post covers three hiring rules that matter to California employers as soon as you're screening applicants, writing interview questions, and making offers. It isn't legal advice. Employment law changes, local ordinances vary, and the details of your situation matter. Use this as a map of what to ask your employment counsel about, not as a substitute for them.
The rules at a glance
| Rule | Source | What the source says |
|---|---|---|
| Fair chance screening | GoodHire | Government Code § 12952 applies to employers with five or more employees |
| Conviction reporting | GoodHire | Convictions may not be reported more than seven years after disposition, release, or parole (Civil Code § 1786.18(a)(7)) |
| Expunged convictions | GoodHire | Under Penal Code § 1203.4, an eligible conviction may be dismissed (expunged) |
| Form I-9 | Checkr | Employers must require employees to complete Form I-9 |
Why five employees is the line to watch
The statewide Fair Chance Act, which governs how you consider criminal history in hiring, applies to employers with five or more employees, according to GoodHire's overview of California background checks. That single threshold is why this post is written for teams that have just crossed it.
Headcount isn't the only thing to track, though. Local ordinances can add obligations that depend on where you operate. A company with four people in one city may face different requirements than a company with four people in another. When you count employees, check the exact wording of the statute or ordinance, because definitions can differ.
Illustrative example: a fifth hire
Imagine a company with 4 employees that hires a fifth person. At 5 employees, the statewide Fair Chance Act threshold applies. The company also checks whether a local ordinance covers the role's city and confirms that its screening vendor follows the seven-year reporting limit.
The rules below are the ones that most often show up in the everyday work of a small hiring team: what goes in the job post, what you ask in interviews, and what you collect before a person starts.
Rule 1: Fair chance screening for criminal history
The California Fair Chance Act, Government Code § 12952, limits how employers can use criminal history in hiring, and it applies once you have five or more employees. According to GoodHire, the state's implementing regulations, found at 2 CCR § 11017.1, were expanded effective October 1, 2023, to broaden these obligations. If you last reviewed your hiring process before that date, it's worth reviewing it again.
The statute doesn't operate alone. Some California localities have their own fair chance ordinances, and those can add duties on top of the state rules. GoodHire gives two examples: the Los Angeles County Fair Chance Ordinance, effective September 3, 2024, and the San Francisco Fair Chance Ordinance. The practical point is that covered employers must comply with both the statewide Fair Chance Act and any applicable local ordinance. Where you operate determines which local rules you need to check.
The seven-year reporting limit
One specific rule catches many employers off guard. GoodHire explains that under Civil Code § 1786.18(a)(7), convictions may not be reported more than seven years after the date of disposition, release, or parole. The source adds that, unlike the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, California provides no salary-based exception.
GoodHire puts it directly: an applicant's expected salary, including $75,000 or higher, does not lift California's seven-year limit. If you're hiring for a senior role and assume the usual federal exception applies, you may be wrong.
This matters most when you use a background screening provider. The limit affects what a consumer report can include, so your vendor's reports and your internal process both need to respect it. Ask your provider how it handles the seven-year limit, and confirm that its reports follow California rules rather than generic national defaults.
What this means for job posts
Job postings are one place where fair chance obligations can begin. A post that says "must pass a background check" or "no felony convictions" may create problems before anyone applies. Describe the job and its requirements. If a background check is part of the process, say so in general terms and avoid language that suggests a blanket exclusion.
Keep the wording of your post aligned with how you will actually evaluate applicants. If you know that criminal history will be considered only after a particular stage, your post shouldn't suggest otherwise. Ask your counsel to review any standard job text, including the phrases you reuse across job boards and staffing partner listings.
What this means for interviews
Interviewers can be the people who create problems, not because they mean to, but because they ask informal questions. Train everyone on the panel. A casual "Have you ever been arrested?" in a first conversation can derail a fair process, even if no one intended harm.
Build a short written script for the points in the process where criminal history might come up. Use the same process for every applicant for a given role. Keep notes on what was asked and why, and store them with the rest of the applicant file. Consistency is easier to defend than improvisation, and it's kinder to applicants too. See Interview Scorecard Example for Consistent Hiring Teams.
What this means for offers
Offers are where timing becomes critical. Many fair chance processes depend on sequence: when you ask, when you check, and when you decide. Work with your counsel to map your sequence, and put it in writing so every hiring manager follows the same steps.
If a background check leads you to consider rejecting an applicant, the process is more than a single decision. Keep records of what you reviewed, how you assessed it, and any communications with the applicant. See Hiring Decision Debrief: Notes to a Recorded Decision. Follow whatever notice and response steps apply under your state and local rules.
Rule 2: Expunged convictions
The second rule is about convictions that have been dismissed. GoodHire notes that under Penal Code § 1203.4, an eligible conviction may be dismissed, which is often described as expungement. The details of eligibility, the effect of dismissal, and what an employer may ask or consider require careful review with counsel.
The general lesson is that a record of a conviction isn't always the end of the story. A person may have completed a sentence or probation and later obtained a dismissal. Your hiring process should not treat every past case as if nothing has changed. Build a step that asks applicants to disclose what's accurate and relevant, and that gives them a fair chance to explain.
For a small team, the risk comes from informal judgment. A hiring manager who recognizes a name, searches public records, or relies on a rumor may end up treating a dismissed matter as active. Set a rule that decisions are based on documented, appropriate information, collected through your approved process.
Because the rules around expungement interact with the fair chance framework and the seven-year reporting limit, treat them as one topic for review. Ask counsel to explain how these pieces fit together for the specific roles you hire for. For more on timing, see Conviction timing rules for 3 jurisdictions.
Rule 3: Verify work eligibility with Form I-9
Checkr's guidance on employment verification states the core requirement: to comply with the law, employers must require employees to complete Form I-9. The form is how you document that a new hire is authorized to work in the United States.
Many small teams treat the I-9 as paperwork that can wait until a manager gets around to it. That's a mistake. The I-9 is part of onboarding, and it should be scheduled as a standard step, not left to chance. Assign one person to own it, and create a checklist that shows when the form is due and what documents are needed.
Be careful about the inverse problem as well. Asking for specific documents, or asking for more documents than the form requires, can create its own compliance issues. Train the person who handles onboarding to request the documents the form allows and to avoid making choices about which documents an applicant should provide.
Where the I-9 fits in your offer process
Some teams send the offer letter, the onboarding packet, and the I-9 instructions together. Others handle the form at the first day in the office.
Think about your background check timing too. A background screen and an I-9 are different processes with different purposes. Don't mix them together in one step, and don't let one shape the other. Keep your onboarding checklist in clear sequence so a new hire is never asked for information out of order.
Records and retention
Keep completed I-9 forms in a secure location, separate from general personnel files where possible. Set a retention schedule and follow it. Limit access to the people who need it, and make sure your records remain consistent with what you ask every new hire to provide.
Definitions can change the answer
Size thresholds and definitions are easy to skim past, and they can change the result. A useful example comes from another state. Washington's statute, RCW 49.60.040, states that "Employee" does not include any individual employed by his or her parents, spouse, or child, or in the domestic service of any person. The same section also says that the definitions in that section apply throughout the chapter unless the context clearly requires otherwise.
That example is from Washington, not California, and it doesn't tell you how California law defines employee. It does show a pattern you should watch for. A statute may exclude certain relationships or types of work from the word "employee," and a rule that applies to employees may not apply to everyone you pay. Before you count heads for a threshold, read the definitions in the specific law. Check how the statute defines employees, whether it includes independent contractors, and whether it counts workers in other locations.
For California, this means checking the definitions in the Fair Chance Act and any local ordinance that applies to you. Don't assume a number from a blog post, including this one, is the final word for your headcount.
A simple checklist for small teams
Here is a practical way to turn these rules into daily habits. Adjust it with your counsel.
Before posting a job
- Review the job post wording for language about criminal history or background checks.
- Confirm which local fair chance ordinances apply to the location of the role.
- Make sure requirements describe the job, not a blanket exclusion.
During interviews
- Use a written script for any discussion of criminal history.
- Train every interviewer, including people who only join for a single round.
- Ask the same core questions of every applicant for the same role.
- Document what was asked and when.
At the offer stage
- Map the sequence of offer, background check, and any follow-up steps in writing.
- Confirm that your background screening vendor applies the seven-year reporting limit and any other California rules.
- Keep records of decisions and communications with applicants.
During onboarding
- Assign one person to own the Form I-9.
- Schedule the I-9 as a standard onboarding step.
- Request documents consistently and avoid asking for more than the form requires.
- Store completed forms securely and follow your retention schedule.
Ongoing
- Recheck your process after changes in state law, local ordinances, or your headcount.
- Review expungement questions with counsel before they appear in any form or script.
- Re-read the definitions in each statute when your team's structure changes.
Common mistakes to avoid
Most problems in small hiring teams come from habits, not bad intent. A few patterns show up again and again.
The first is the copied job post. Teams reuse old wording from older roles, job boards, or other companies, and those phrases often include requirements that don't fit California's rules. Review the wording once, then review it again when you add a new location or role type.
The second is the casual interview question. A manager who wants to be friendly may ask about an applicant's past without realizing the implications. A short, clear script solves much of this.
The third is the assumption about salary. Some teams believe that a high-paying role changes the analysis. Don't build a process around a rule that doesn't exist.
The fourth is treating the I-9 as an afterthought. A missing or incomplete form can create avoidable risk. Give it an owner, a deadline, and a place in the onboarding sequence.
The fifth is relying on memory. A hiring decision that can't be explained with records is hard to defend. Write down what you reviewed, when you reviewed it, and why you decided what you did.
When to call a lawyer
You don't need a lawyer for every hire. Bring a clear description of your process: the job post, the interview script, your screening vendor, your offer sequence, and your onboarding checklist. A short review can catch problems before they become disputes.
Prepare questions in advance. Ask how the Fair Chance Act applies at your headcount, which local ordinances you need to follow, how the seven-year reporting limit affects your vendor's reports, how expungement should factor into your process, and how to structure the I-9 step. Get the answers in writing where possible.
Your next step today
Open your current job post and interview script, and mark every line that mentions criminal history or background checks. Then compare each marked line with the checklist above and fix any wording that doesn't match how you actually evaluate applicants.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Fair Chance Act apply to a small employer?
It applies to employers with five or more employees, according to GoodHire. Local ordinances can add duties, so check the rules where you hire.
Does a high salary change the seven-year limit?
No. GoodHire says an applicant's expected salary, including $75,000 or higher, does not lift California's seven-year limit.
What should you do about an expunged conviction?
Review any dismissed conviction with counsel before it affects a hiring decision. Penal Code § 1203.4 allows an eligible conviction to be dismissed, which is often called expungement.
Final thoughts
The three rules in this post share a theme. Each one asks you to slow down at a specific point in the hiring process and to make a deliberate choice. The fair chance framework asks you to think about when and how criminal history enters the decision. The expungement rule asks you to remember that a past record may not describe the present. The I-9 asks you to verify work eligibility in a consistent, documented way.
Small teams can handle these obligations without a large compliance department. Write down your process, train the people who run it, check it against current law, and review it when your team changes. Your applicants will notice the difference, and so will anyone who later asks how your decisions were made.
This post is general information, not legal advice. Confirm the details that apply to your business with qualified counsel before you rely on them.