Delaware public employers outside the exceptions must wait until after the first interview to ask otherwise qualified applicants about criminal or credit history. Delaware General Assembly sets this timing rule.
Key takeaways
- Check application forms and interview scripts for record and credit questions before the first interview, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h).
- Confirm that the applicant is otherwise qualified before a later inquiry, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h)(2).
- Document whether a criminal history disqualification is job related for the position and consistent with business necessity, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h)(3).
- Check the listed exceptions, including police forces, the Department of Correction, and positions where statute requires or expressly permits the check, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h)(4).
Who the Delaware rule covers
The quoted text, according to Delaware General Assembly, addresses a public employer and an applicant for employment. That wording sets the scope of this article. A placement firm or recruiter should confirm which employer runs the screen and makes the hiring decision before drafting any question about records or credit.
A short written note on the employer's status, made before the first conversation, names the public employer, the position, and the person who decides. That note keeps each question tied to the party the text addresses.
Recruiters who handle both public and private roles should keep separate intake notes for each type. That separation prevents a public-employer checklist from being applied to work it does not cover.
Use these four checks when reviewing a public role's screening process.
| Screening check | Rule |
|---|---|
| Early questions | A public employer may not inquire into or consider criminal record, criminal history, credit history, or credit score through the first interview, according to Delaware General Assembly. |
| Later inquiry | The applicant must be otherwise qualified, and the first interview must be complete, according to Delaware General Assembly. |
| Criminal history disqualification | The exclusion must be job related for the position and consistent with business necessity, according to Delaware General Assembly. |
| Exceptions | Check the listed bodies and positions where federal or state statute requires or expressly permits consideration of criminal history, according to Delaware General Assembly. |
No record or credit questions through the first interview
According to Delaware General Assembly, subsection (h)(1) reads: "It shall be an unlawful employment practice for any public employer to inquire into or consider the criminal record, criminal history, credit history, or credit score of an applicant for employment during the initial application process, up to and including the first interview." The window covers the initial application process and runs through the first interview. Both boundaries sit in one sentence, so a single review can test both of them.
Four items fall under that window: criminal record, criminal history, credit history, and credit score. The list sets the scope of the early-stage check. A practical review reads each application form, phone screen script, and interview guide for any question touching those four items. Any match should be removed from the early stage or moved to the stage that follows the first interview. The review should cover written forms and spoken questions alike.
Notes count as well. The text uses the words "inquire into or consider," so a shortlist note that mentions a credit score during the early stage falls within the wording of the subsection, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h). Shortlist notes are easy to overlook, so they deserve the same scan as the forms. A quick check of those notes before the list leaves the desk is a useful habit.
Phone screens and casual conversations call for the same discipline, because the window is tied to the stage of the process. A question about a record in an informal chat before the first interview sits inside the same window as a question on a form. A recruiter who raises a record during that chat has raised the same question the text addresses. Phone scripts can keep the early conversation on the job itself.
A shared script for several agencies can keep the same boundary in every intake. A line that says record and credit questions wait until after the first interview can open the script. Each agency copy should carry that line, so the timing does not depend on who runs the call. Placing the boundary first means it is read before any question is asked.
Illustrative example: reviewing application forms
Suppose a recruiter reviews 10 application forms for a public role outside the exceptions. Each form asks about criminal history before the first interview. The recruiter removes that question from all 10 forms and places it in the later screening script, with a check that the applicant is otherwise qualified. The revised forms contain 0 criminal history questions.
When the inquiry may start
Subsection (h)(2) gives the later window: "If an applicant is otherwise qualified, a public employer may inquire into or consider an applicant’s criminal record, criminal history, credit history or credit score after the completion of the first interview," according to Delaware General Assembly. The sentence sets one condition and one point in time. Both must be met before the inquiry is permitted.
The condition is that the applicant is otherwise qualified. For a practical qualification check, use the job requirements the employer already uses. A written definition for each role gives the recruiter one reference point. A definition tied to the posted requirements is a practical step.
A recruiter can record that view in writing before a later inquiry begins. A written view lets the file show what was decided and when. The note should name the role, the requirement, and the person who wrote it. Each role may need its own note, since the requirements differ.
A federal source offers a different definition for a different purpose. The federal fact sheet describes a qualified employee or applicant with a disability as "an individual who, with or without reasonable accommodation, can perform the essential functions of the job in question," according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. That definition is written for disability cases, so it should not be used as the Delaware test for records.
A recruiter who works across states should check each rule separately. For related reading, see conviction timing rules. A file note can name the time the first interview ends, so the start of the later window is recorded.
Disqualifying on criminal history
Subsection (h)(3) states: "A public employer may disqualify an applicant from employment based on criminal history where the exclusion is job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity," according to Delaware General Assembly. The sentence applies to criminal history. It sets the standard for any exclusion built on that history.
The sentence sets two tests, and a recruiter can document each one on its own line. The first test asks whether the exclusion is job related for the position in question. The second test asks whether the exclusion is consistent with business necessity. Separate lines show that each test was considered, rather than one reason standing in for both.
In editorial practice, a job-related reason can be written in terms of the duties of the position, not in terms of a general concern about past records. For example, a note for a role that handles cash could name the cash duties and explain how a particular record bears on them. That example is an illustration, not a rule taken from the quoted text.
A recruiter should check any credit-based screen against the full text before relying on it. Keep the timing review separate from the written reason for a disqualification.
For related reading, see criminal record requests. A disqualification decision kept in its own record lets the job-related reason be read on its own.
Exceptions to the rule
Subsection (h)(4) lists exceptions, according to Delaware General Assembly, and it begins by stating that the subsection does not apply to any state, county or municipal police force, the Department of Correction, the Department of Justice, the Office of Defense Services, the courts, or any position where federal or state statute requires or expressly permits the consideration of an applicant’s criminal history.
Before using an exception, identify the exact position and the statute that governs it. The last category depends on a statute that requires or expressly permits the consideration of criminal history, so the statute reference belongs in the file. A general sense that a role feels sensitive does not match that wording.
The quoted list names particular bodies and positions, so a recruiter should not extend it by analogy to other agencies. A position that resembles a listed body is not the same as a listed body. A written note can say which listed body the role belongs to, or which statute covers it.
The exceptions are a reason to check the position before the screen, not a reason to drop the timing rule for every role. A role outside the list keeps the window through the first interview. That keeps the timing rule in place for ordinary positions.
A quick written check for each position can record whether an exception applies or whether the timing rule governs. Each check can carry the position title, the listed body or statute, and the date it was made. A check kept this way gives a reviewer one page to read for each position.
What to keep on file
A separate subsection, numbered (1) in the quoted text, states, according to Delaware General Assembly: "Fail or refuse to hire or to discharge any individual or otherwise to discriminate against any individual with respect to compensation, terms, conditions, or privileges of employment because of such individual’s race, marital status, genetic information, color, age, religion, sex (including pregnancy), sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, military status, or housing status."
On the screening checklist, military status and housing status should sit next to the other listed traits. Listing them together keeps the checklist aligned with the quoted list. A checklist that leaves them out would not reflect the quoted list.
The listing also includes a victim provision, which the quoted text states as: "(2) Discharge or discipline an individual who is a victim of a crime or a representative of a victim because the individual participated in the preparation for or attended proceedings under § 9409(a) of Title 11." The provision sits in the same code as the other items in this article.
For the file, a record can hold the date of the first interview, the date any record or credit question was first asked, and the job-related reason for any disqualification. These three entries put the order of steps on paper. A reviewer can then read the sequence without guessing at it.
A recruiting records audit can check that the file follows this sequence. For related reading, see recruiting records audit. Today, review your script for a public role outside the exceptions and move any record or credit question to after the first interview, with a qualification check before the inquiry.
Questions
Can a Delaware public employer ask about credit history in the first interview?
No, unless an exception applies: credit history and credit score are covered through the first interview, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h). Review the application form alongside the interview script so the same question does not remain in an earlier stage.
When can the employer look at criminal history?
A public employer outside the exceptions may consider criminal history after the first interview is complete, if the applicant is otherwise qualified, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h)(2). Put the qualification note beside that timing record so a reviewer can follow the decision.
What must a criminal history disqualification rest on?
The exclusion must be job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h)(3). Document each reason separately as a practical file check.
Which employers are exempt from the subsection?
The exceptions cover state, county or municipal police forces, the Department of Correction, the Department of Justice, the Office of Defense Services, the courts, and positions where federal or state statute requires or expressly permits consideration of criminal history, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (h)(4). Check the exact body or position before using the exception.
Do the Delaware protected traits include military status and housing status?
Yes, the listed traits include military status and housing status, according to Delaware General Assembly on subsection (1). Keep both on the screening checklist with the other listed traits.
Does the code address a crime victim who attends proceedings?
Yes, it addresses discharge or discipline because a crime victim or a victim’s representative participated in preparation for or attended proceedings under § 9409(a) of Title 11, according to Delaware General Assembly. Read the provision as written when a case involves a victim.