Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

3 checks before disqualifying a disabled veteran applicant

Do not disqualify a disabled veteran applicant until three checks are complete: whether the disability meets the ADA definition, whether the applicant can perform the essential functions with or without reasonable accommodation, and whether the veteran preference claim is supported by valid documentation.

Sharp takeaways

  • A disability under the ADA is a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Screen on that test, not on a label.
  • An applicant must be qualified for the essential functions, with or without reasonable accommodation, to be protected by the ADA.
  • Accommodation documentation can cover the disability and the need for accommodation. It does not have to be a full medical file.
  • Broad requests for complete medical records will rarely, if ever, meet the documentation test.
  • The ADA leaves your right to hire the best qualified applicant intact.

Does the applicant's disability meet the ADA definition?

The first check decides whether the ADA applies to this applicant at all. The EEOC's guidance for employers states: "Under the ADA, a person has a disability if he has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity." ( EEOC, The ADA: Your Responsibilities as an Employer)

That sentence contains two questions. The first asks whether the applicant has a physical or mental impairment. The second asks whether that impairment substantially limits a major life activity. You need an answer to both. A diagnosis name does not settle the second question, and neither does a checked box on an application. The applicant's statement tells you what condition they report, but it does not by itself show how that condition limits daily life.

Keep the disability question separate from the veteran question. Veteran preference and disability status are different claims, supported by different evidence. A valid preference certification does not establish a disability, and a disability disclosure does not establish preference. When an applicant raises both, record each question on its own line in the file and decide each on its own evidence.

Ask about effect, not diagnosis. Questions about which activities the impairment affects, and how much, produce information you can use. The definition asks about limitation, so your questions should too. Then write a plain file note: what the applicant said, which part of the definition the statement addresses, and what information, if any, supports it. A note reading "impairment stated, limitation not yet described" tells the next reviewer exactly where the file stands. A note reading "disabled veteran" tells them nothing they can act on.

Can the applicant perform the essential functions?

The second check applies only after the first is met. The EEOC's guidance says: "An individual with a disability must also be qualified to perform the essential functions of the job with or without reasonable accommodation, in order to be protected by the ADA." ( EEOC, The ADA: Your Responsibilities as an Employer)

The phrase "with or without reasonable accommodation" is the part reviewers most often miss. The question is not whether the applicant can do every task unaided on the day of screening. It is whether the essential functions can be performed with or without a reasonable accommodation. An applicant who needs a modification to perform a core duty can still be qualified.

Work through the job in a fixed order, and record each step:

StepWhat to recordBasis in the EEOC text
Identify essential functions The core duties of the position, separated from marginal tasks"essential functions of the job"
Test unaided performance Whether the applicant can perform each essential function as described"with or without reasonable accommodation"
Test with accommodation The specific accommodation that would make each function possible"with or without reasonable accommodation"

Start from the posting and the actual duties, not from a general impression of the disability. For each essential function, the file should name the function and either confirm the applicant can perform it or name the accommodation that would allow it. A rejection that cites a general concern without naming an essential function is hard to justify, and it leaves no record of how the decision was reached.

Which one should you pick?

When an applicant with a disability asks for accommodation support, you face a choice about how much information to request. The two options are a narrow request limited to the disability and the need for accommodation, or a request for the applicant's complete medical records. The Job Accommodation Network describes the first option this way: "This may include documentation of the individual's disability and need for accommodation." It also states that "Broad requests for complete medical records will rarely, if ever, meet this test." ( JAN, Accommodation Process)

MeasureNarrow documentation request Complete medical records request
What it coversDisability and need for accommodationComplete medical records
Wording in the JAN guidance"documentation of the individual's disability and need for accommodation""Broad requests for complete medical records"
Likely to meet the testCan meet the test, because it is limited to the stated purposeWill rarely, if ever, meet the test

Apply the comparison to your own decision using these rules:

If you are tempted to request an applicant's complete medical history, pick a narrower question instead because documentation of the disability and need for accommodation is the purpose JAN identifies.

What accommodation documentation you may request

In describing the accommodation process, the Job Accommodation Network says: "This may include documentation of the individual's disability and need for accommodation." ( JAN, Accommodation Process)

That sentence identifies two things documentation can establish. The first is that the applicant has a disability. The second is that the applicant needs an accommodation because of it. Anything you request should serve one of those two purposes. If the file already shows the impairment, the open question is the limitation it creates and the accommodation that addresses it.

A useful request names what you need. Ask a provider, or the applicant, to describe the limitation in functional terms, to state which accommodation addresses it, and to say whether the need is ongoing or temporary. These questions map directly onto the two purposes in the JAN sentence. They also give the reviewer something concrete to evaluate, rather than a stack of paper that must be interpreted.

Documentation requests also need a deadline and a clear explanation of what happens if the applicant does not respond. Write the request so the applicant understands what is needed and why. Then record the date you sent it and the date the response arrived. Those dates matter if the hiring decision is later questioned.

Remember that documentation is a means to answer the accommodation question, not a route to the applicant's whole health history. The narrower your request, the easier it is to show that the information you reviewed was relevant to the decision.

Why broad medical records requests fail the test

The Job Accommodation Network states: "Broad requests for complete medical records will rarely, if ever, meet this test." ( JAN, Accommodation Process) The test referred to is the one in the preceding sentence: documentation of the individual's disability and need for accommodation.

A complete medical record contains diagnoses, treatments, visits, and notes that are unrelated to the job or the accommodation being requested. Reviewing that material does not answer either question the test poses. It does expose the applicant's unrelated history to people who have no need for it, which raises privacy concerns and gives the file information that can later complicate a decision.

Instead, send a targeted request that names the specific limitation and the accommodation at issue. If the response is incomplete, ask a narrower follow-up about the same point, not for the entire file. The goal is to obtain the missing fact that answers the test, nothing more.

If an applicant volunteers broader records on their own, read only the portions that address the disability and the need for accommodation. Note in the file which material you relied on and which you set aside. That note shows the decision rested on the information the test calls for, and it protects both the applicant and your organization.

Does the service period qualify for preference?

The OPM guidance sets a specific rule for certain periods of service: "Therefore, these man-day tours are qualifying for preference if the individual was awarded the SWASM or served during the period 8/2/90 to 1/2/92." ( OPM, Vet Guide for HR Professionals)

The sentence sets out two routes. The second is service during the period from 8/2/90 to 1/2/92. The routes are joined by "or," so the sentence treats either one as enough. It does not require both.

The dates are the part you can check directly against a file. The table lists them as the quote states them.

ElementValue stated in the OPM quote
Start of qualifying period8/2/90
End of qualifying period1/2/92
Route oneAwarded the SWASM
Route two Served during the period

When an applicant claims preference based on service in this window, compare the dates on the applicant's service paperwork with the period. Record which route, if either, the file supports. The quote uses the phrase "these man-day tours," and the excerpt does not define that term, so do not apply it to a file on your own reading. Open the full OPM page and read the paragraphs before this sentence. The word "Therefore" signals that the rule follows from reasoning given earlier.

A file whose dates fall outside this window has not failed every route to preference. The quote addresses these two routes only. Your next step is to check the rest of the guidance and the governing statute, not to reject the claim on dates alone.

How to verify preference eligibility

The OPM guidance places the verification duty on the agency: "Agencies must verify the individual meets the definition of 'preference eligible' under 5 U.S.C." ( OPM, Vet Guide for HR Professionals)

The excerpt ends at the citation, so the definition itself lives in the statute rather than on this page. Read the full provision before relying on a paraphrase. The word "must" makes verification mandatory. An applicant's statement that they are a veteran does not replace that step, and neither does a hiring manager's assumption that a claim is valid.

A workable sequence has three parts. First, identify which preference the applicant claims and the service it rests on. Second, compare the paperwork against the definition, using the date window and the certification requirements covered in the sections that follow. Third, record the result in the file, with the date you reviewed it and the document you relied on.

Keep the veteran question separate from the disability question, as the earlier checks did. A preference determination says nothing about whether a disability meets the ADA definition.

Treat this guidance as a reference, and confirm the rules that apply to your employer before you act on them.

What a valid certification letter must show

The OPM guidance describes the certification letter this way: "The certification letter should be on letterhead of the appropriate military branch of the service and contain (1) the military service dates including the expected discharge or release date; and (2) the character of service." ( OPM, Vet Guide for HR Professionals)

The sentence says "should," not "must." Treat its contents as the expected standard for the letter, and check the full guidance for how strictly it is applied. The table breaks the sentence into its parts.

Part of the sentenceWhat it asks for Numbered in the quote
LetterheadLetterhead of the appropriate military branch of the serviceNo
Item (1) Military service dates, including the expected discharge or release dateYes, item 1
Item (2)Character of serviceYes, item 2

The numbered requirements total 2. When a letter lacks one of them, ask for that specific element rather than rejecting the letter outright. A letter that shows service dates but no expected discharge or release date has a visible gap, and you can name it in your request. Keep the letter in the applicant's file with the date you received it, so the record shows what the agency relied on.

What to request when a certification has expired

Expiration is a trigger for a request, not a finding. The sentence places the duty on the agency to ask for other documentation, and it does not say the claim fails. The test is whether the documentation demonstrates preference eligibility.

SituationWhat the agency must do Example in the quote
Certification is currentVerify the applicant meets the preference eligible definitionNone given in this sentence
Certification has expiredRequest other documentation that demonstrates preference eligibilityA copy of the DD form 214

Make the request in writing. Name the document you need, explain why, and give a response date. Ask for the document that demonstrates eligibility, not the applicant's whole service file, which matches the narrow approach used for disability documentation earlier in this post. Record the date you sent the request and the date the response arrived.

Who decides a preference claim

The OPM guidance assigns responsibility for these decisions: "Agencies are responsible for adjudicating all preference claims except claims for preference based on common-law marriage, which should be sent to the Office of Personnel Management (OPM), Office of the General Counsel, 1900 E." ( OPM, Vet Guide for HR Professionals)

"Adjudicating" means deciding the claim. The table shows the two categories the sentence sets out.

Type of claimWho adjudicates it
All preference claims, except the type belowThe agency
Claims for preference based on common-law marriageOPM, Office of the General Counsel

For most claims, the agency's own adjudicating function makes the decision. A hiring manager should route the file to that function rather than deciding the claim alone. Claims based on common-law marriage go to OPM and should not be decided locally.

The excerpt gives the OPM address only as "1900 E.", which is incomplete. Check the full address on the OPM page before sending anything.

Next step today

Open your open requisitions and, for each essential function, write one line naming either the applicant's ability to perform it or the accommodation that would allow it.

Related guides: Applicant data requests: 4 privacy office guides · Applicant drug testing: 6 mistakes to fix before hiring · 3 duties when a job applicant asks for interview accommodation.

Questions readers ask

Can I reject an applicant with a disability because they cannot perform every task without help? Not on that basis alone. The EEOC states that the applicant must be qualified for the essential functions "with or without reasonable accommodation." The test concerns essential functions, not every task performed unaided. ( EEOC, The ADA: Your Responsibilities as an Employer)

No. The EEOC says: "The ADA does not interfere with your right to hire the best qualified applicant." ( EEOC, The ADA: Your Responsibilities as an Employer)

Can I request an applicant's complete medical records to confirm a disability? The Job Accommodation Network says broad requests for complete medical records "will rarely, if ever, meet this test." Ask instead for documentation of the disability and the need for accommodation. ( JAN, Accommodation Process)

What documentation can I ask for? The JAN page says the documentation "may include documentation of the individual's disability and need for accommodation." The word "may" means the excerpt gives no closed list, so keep each request tied to those two purposes. ( JAN, Accommodation Process)

My applicant's preference certification has expired. Should I reject the claim? Not on expiration alone. The OPM guidance says that when a certification has expired, the agency must request other documentation, such as a copy of the DD form 214. ( OPM, Vet Guide for HR Professionals)

Does a certification letter have to show a discharge date? The OPM guidance says the letter should contain the military service dates, including the expected discharge or release date, and the character of service. It uses "should," so check the full guidance for how strictly it is applied. ( OPM, Vet Guide for HR Professionals)

Who decides a claim based on common-law marriage? The OPM guidance says these claims should be sent to OPM's Office of the General Counsel, not decided by the agency. ( OPM, Vet Guide for HR Professionals)

Not legal or tax counsel.

Sources