A South Carolina discrimination complaint ends in one of three ways: it is resolved early, it is dismissed, or the Commission takes the respondent to circuit court in equity. The number HR teams must track is 30, because court action follows either a failed 30-day conciliation window after the Commission issues its determination or a finding that the respondent violated a conciliation agreement.
> Sharp takeaways > - The three outcomes are early resolution, dismissal, or an action in equity in circuit court. > - The 30-day conciliation clock starts when the Commission issues its determination, not when the complaint is filed. > - The investigator recommends only dismissal or a circuit court action, and only if the complaint was not resolved sooner. > - A dismissal order must be mailed to both the complainant and the respondent at their last known addresses. > - Court action can follow either a failed conciliation window or a finding that a signed agreement was breached.
The answer: a 30-day conciliation window before court
The thirty-day window is the part of the process most likely to shape what an employer does next. The South Carolina Code of Laws states the rule in plain terms: if, within thirty days after issuance of its determination, the Commission cannot secure a conciliation agreement acceptable to it, the Commission may bring an action in equity against the respondent in circuit court.
Three phrases in that sentence decide how the window works in practice. The clock starts at issuance of the determination, not at the date the complaint was first filed, so HR should record the determination's issuance date. The agreement must be acceptable to the Commission, which means the Commission judges the terms, not the employer alone. And the word "may" makes court action discretionary; the text does not require the Commission to sue when the window closes.
The window also matters after it closes without agreement. The same provision gives the Commission a second route to court: if it determines after investigation that the respondent violated the terms of a conciliation agreement, it may bring an action in equity against the respondent in circuit court. A signed agreement therefore does not end the exposure. An employer that signs terms during the window must treat them as enforceable obligations, because a finding of breach opens the same circuit court path that a missed window does.
For a hiring manager, the practical lesson is that a complaint about a new hire is not settled at the first letter. The determination starts a limited period in which the parties can try to reach terms, and the outcome depends on whether those terms satisfy the Commission. Keeping dated records of every determination, every proposed term, and every response will make it possible to show later what was offered and when.
Who investigates and what the investigator must recommend
Once a complaint is filed and not resolved early, an investigator handles the fact-finding. The code describes the investigator's end product in one sentence: "If not sooner resolved, the investigator shall upon completion of his investigation submit to the Commissioner a statement of the facts disclosed by his investigation and recommend either that the complaint be dismissed or that the Commission bring an action in equity in circuit court against the respondent." Read the code text
Read that sentence in order. The phrase "if not sooner resolved" places early resolution ahead of the investigator's report, so a complaint that settles before the investigation ends never reaches the recommendation stage. Where the complaint is not resolved early, the report has two required parts: a statement of the facts the investigation disclosed, and a recommendation.
The recommendation has exactly two options named in the text, dismissal or an equity action in circuit court. The statute does not list a third recommendation, such as a fine or a reprimand, so HR should not expect the investigator to propose one. A recommendation of court action is also distinct from a court filing; the text describes the investigator's recommendation to the Commissioner, and the decision that follows is a separate step.
The Commissioner receives the statement of facts together with the recommendation. That pairing shows the sequence: facts first, then a recommendation, then a decision. An employer that understands this order can read its own file the same way the Commissioner does, starting from what the investigation found and moving to what the investigator advised.
Dismissal and court action, side by side
The investigator's two recommendations lead to two very different results for a respondent. The table compares them on the measures the code states.
| Measure | Dismissal | Court action in equity |
|---|---|---|
| Recommended by the investigator | Dismissal of the complaint | Commission brings an action in equity in circuit court |
| Document or step that records it | Order of dismissal, mailed to both parties | Action against the respondent in circuit court |
| Timing stated in the code | After investigation, if not resolved sooner | May follow if no acceptable conciliation agreement within 30 days after determination |
| Who is named or affected | Complainant and respondent receive the order | Respondent is the party sued |
Dismissal closes the complaint through a written order. Court action moves the dispute into circuit court, and the thirty-day figure is what separates the two paths on the calendar. A respondent that negotiates within the window is working to keep the matter on the dismissal side of this table, or at least out of the circuit court route.
The court route has two entry points, not one. The first is a failed conciliation window of thirty days. The second is a post-investigation finding that the respondent violated the terms of a conciliation agreement. Dismissal has no equivalent second entry point in the quoted text, so an employer that wants a complaint closed should understand that a signed agreement keeps it open in a way a dismissal does not.
Mailing the dismissal order to both parties
When the Commissioner dismisses a complaint, the code requires a written order and a copy sent to each side: "If the order be of dismissal, the Commissioner shall mail a copy of the order to the complainant and to the respondent at their last known addresses." Read the code text
Three details in that sentence are practical. First, the duty to mail sits with the Commissioner, not with the respondent or the complainant, so an employer does not need to send the order itself to learn the outcome. Second, the copy goes to both parties, so an HR office and the employee named in the complaint should each expect the same document. Third, the standard is "last known addresses." The mailing goes wherever the Commissioner's records place each party, so a company that has moved offices, or an employee who has moved home, can miss an order if the file has not been updated.
The rule is tied to dismissal orders, which is the outcome most respondents hope for. An HR team can act on that by auditing the notice address on file for the company and confirming that the staff member who opens company mail can route a government envelope to HR the same day. Logging the date each order arrives also creates a record that the chronology from the conciliation window can be checked against.
The sentence sets a mailing rule and nothing more. It names no deadline for the respondent's reply and no form for the order's contents, so an employer should read the order itself for any response it calls for, rather than assuming the mailing rule carries those terms.
Where the code's history notes come from
The two sections quoted in this post each end with a history note that lists the acts that created or changed them. The two sections quoted in this post carry their own notes. One reads "HISTORY: 1962 Code SECTION 1-360.27; 1972 (57) 2651; 1973 (58) 698; 1979 Act No.", and the other reads "HISTORY: 1962 Code SECTION 1-360.28; 1972 (57) 2651; 1979 Act No." Read the code text
The notes are a record of how each section came to its present form, and the year leads each entry. The table below lists every entry, newest first.
| Note entry | Year | Section(s) it appears in |
|---|---|---|
| 1979 Act No. | 1979 | 1-360.27 and 1-360.28 |
| 1973 (58) 698 | 1973 | 1-360.27 |
| 1972 (57) 2651 | 1972 | 1-360.27 and 1-360.28 |
| 1962 Code SECTION | 1962 | 1-360.27 and 1-360.28 |
The 1973 entry appears only in section 1-360.27, which means that section was changed in one more year than section 1-360.28 in the quoted notes. For an HR team drafting a response, the practical point is to cite the section number and the text on the linked page. The history line tells a reader where the section came from, but the operative rule is the text itself.
Coordinating with other state and federal agencies
One clause in the code ties the commission's work to other bodies. It describes the work as carried on "in order to achieve the purposes of that act and with other Federal, State and local agencies and departments." Read the code text
That clause names three levels of government: federal, state, and local. For an HR team, this means a complaint about a hire may involve more than one government body, and the same facts can reach more than one desk. The clause gives the state commission a basis to work alongside those bodies, so an employer should not assume that a state file stays inside a state file.
The practical step is to keep one chronology for every agency. Use the same dates for the complaint, the investigation requests, the determination, and any conciliation proposals, and reuse the same statement of events in every response. A response that describes the same hire differently to two bodies creates a conflict that a single consistent record avoids. Keeping that record current also helps the team answer quickly when a second agency asks for the same information that the first one already received.
Dates and deadlines in one table
The quoted code text gives one count of days, the thirty-day conciliation window, along with several dates in the history notes. The table below collects those figures so HR can check each one against the code text before relying on it.
| Item | Figure from the quoted text | Where it appears |
|---|---|---|
| Conciliation window | 30 days after issuance of the determination | Subsection (7) |
| Section 1-360.27 history | 1962 Code; 1972 (57) 2651; 1973 (58) 698; 1979 Act No. | History note |
| Section 1-360.28 history | 1962 Code; 1972 (57) 2651; 1979 Act No. | History note |
Two cautions apply. The thirty days run from the issuance of the determination, not from the date the complaint was filed, so one missed date in the file can change the whole calendar. A useful habit is to record the determination date first and count forward from it.
The history entries are records of past changes to the code. They are not deadlines for an employer, and neither one sets a time limit that applies to a current complaint. The quoted entries also end at "Act No.," so the full act citation should be confirmed on the linked page rather than copied from this table.
Which path a complaint about a hire takes first
A complaint about a new hire does not take a separate route under South Carolina's code. The quoted provisions refer to "the respondent" and do not single out hiring decisions, so the same sequence applies to any complaint. The first decision point is whether the complaint is resolved early. The investigator's report comes "if not sooner resolved," which means early resolution comes before any report is issued ( investigator provision).
If the complaint is not resolved early, the investigator completes the investigation and submits a statement of facts with a recommendation of either dismissal or an equity action in circuit court. The Commissioner then acts on that report. A dismissal leads to a mailed order. The thirty-day conciliation window runs from the issuance of a determination, and court action becomes possible only after that window closes without an acceptable agreement, or after a finding that a conciliation agreement was violated ( conciliation provision).
For HR, the first task is to identify which stage the file has reached. A complaint still under investigation calls for a complete factual record. A complaint that has produced a determination calls for a calendar entry and a decision about whether to negotiate. Treating the file as already at the court stage, or as already closed, leads to errors in both directions.
Which one should you pick?
The quoted code does not let a respondent choose between dismissal and court action, because the investigator's recommendation and the Commission's decisions determine those outcomes. What an employer can choose is how to act during the period the code does provide. The option that best fits the quoted text is to pursue a conciliation agreement during the thirty-day window, provided the terms are ones the organization will keep.
| Option | What the quoted text supports | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Negotiate during the window | An agreement acceptable to the Commission can prevent a circuit court action after the window | Terms the Commission does not accept, and the window closes |
| Wait without an agreement | The investigator may recommend dismissal | The recommendation could be an equity action in circuit court |
| Sign, then fall short | None; a finding of breach opens the court route | Court action after a finding that the agreement was violated |
The recommended choice is to negotiate within the window, but only with terms the company can meet on schedule. The code gives the Commission a path to court whether a window lapses or an agreement is breached, so an agreement that is signed and then not honored is worse than no agreement at all. Because this is a reading of the text rather than legal advice, terms should be reviewed by counsel before they are offered.
Steps for HR after a complaint about a new hire
- Record the determination date. The thirty-day window begins at issuance of the determination, so log the issuance date stated in the determination and count forward from it, not from the date the notice arrives ( code text).
- Confirm the address on file. Dismissal orders go to the last known addresses, so make sure the company's notice address is current (code text).
- Preserve the hiring file. The investigator's statement of facts reflects what the investigation disclosed, so keep hiring records, interview notes, and relevant communications organized before the report is written ( code text).
- Draft only terms you can keep. A finding that an agreement was violated can open the court route, so every term should have an owner and a date ( code text).
- Check for other agencies. The code describes the Commission working with federal, state and local agencies, so keep one chronology that all of them can rely on ( code text).
- Read every order in full. The mailing sentence names no response deadline, so the order itself must be checked for any requirement it sets.
What a dismissal means for complainant and respondent
A dismissal ends the investigator's recommended path through a written order, and the code requires that the order reach both sides: "If the order be of dismissal, the Commissioner shall mail a copy of the order to the complainant and to the respondent at their last known addresses" ( code text).
For the complainant, the mailed copy is the official notice that the complaint was dismissed. The quoted text does not say how the complainant must respond or whether any further step is available, so the order itself is the only reliable source for those details.
For the respondent, the same copy confirms that the complaint was dismissed rather than sent toward a circuit court action. The dismissal does not mean the file can be discarded. The order, the investigation correspondence, and any conciliation proposals should be kept under the organization's own retention practice, since the quoted text says nothing about when records may be destroyed.
Because both parties receive the same document at their last known addresses, the record of the outcome is shared rather than held by only one side.
Related guides: Six stages a South Carolina commission complaint moves through · Discrimination complaint files: 3 records to keep · South Carolina employer discipline: 3 routes to know.
Reader questions
Does a missed conciliation window automatically mean a lawsuit? No. The code says the Commission "may" bring an action in equity in circuit court, so court action after the thirty days is discretionary ( code text).
When does the thirty-day clock start? It starts at issuance of the Commission's determination, not at the filing of the complaint (code text).
What can the investigator recommend? Only dismissal or an action in equity in circuit court, and only if the complaint was not resolved sooner ( code text).
Who receives a dismissal order? The complainant and the respondent, each at their last known address (code text).
Does signing an agreement end the exposure? Not necessarily. If the Commission determines after investigation that the respondent violated the agreement, it may bring an action in equity in circuit court ( code text).
Why do the history notes appear at the end of each section? They list the acts that created or changed the section, with the year first. The operative rule is the section's text, so cite that text rather than the history line ( code text).
Do agencies handle these complaints alone? The code says the work is carried on with other federal, state and local agencies and departments, so an employer should expect that more than one government body may be involved ( code text).