Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Discrimination complaint files: 3 records to keep

Keep the dated complaint, a log of resolution contacts, and final decisions with proof of delivery in a discrimination complaint file. Before a complaint, the file holds the usual hiring, performance, and pay records. After one, the same file may be read by a state agency, an administrative law judge, a lawyer, or a court, and each of them will read it closely and in order. A recruiter may be the first person to see a complaint, and a hiring manager may be the person it names. Both are part of the file.

This post covers three records that belong in that file and explains what each one shows. It uses two state statutes and a Wisconsin statute annotation as examples. The last section explains how to check the rules where you work.

Most files fail for a simple reason. Nobody can say, in order, what was received, what was said, and what was decided. The three records below fix that problem. None of them requires special software or a legal background. They require the discipline to write things down on the day they happen, and to keep each document where the next person will look for it.

What is the first record to keep?

The first record is the complaint itself, kept with a filing date you can show. Keep the copy you received exactly as it arrived, and do not write on it. If you need to add a note, put the note on a separate page with the date, your name, and the reason for the note.

The date matters because everything else in the file is measured against it. The filing date and the date your company first heard about the complaint are not always the same, and the gap can be large. Write down when and how you received your copy, who sent it, and which envelope or email it came in. Keep the envelope, the mail record, or the original message, because those are what show delivery.

Add a timeline on the first page of the file. Write the date the complaint arrived, the date the company first learned of it, and the staff member who received it. Each later entry goes beneath those lines, in order. A timeline that stays current is the fastest way to answer the first question anyone will ask, which is what happened and when.

Florida's statute shows why an official date is useful. The statute reads: "On the same day the complaint is filed with the commission, the commission shall clearly stamp on the face of the complaint the date the complaint was filed with the commission." ( Florida Statutes, Chapter 760, Section 11) That stamp gives everyone the same starting point. Your file should have a starting point that is just as clear.

Your copy may not carry that stamp. Employers often receive a notice, a mailed packet, or a copy passed along by the applicant or employee, and none of those is the agency's stamped original. When that happens, do not work out the filing date from the copy you have. Note what your copy is, where it came from, and when it arrived. If the agency later sends a stamped copy, file it beside your original, record the date it arrived, and keep both. Two versions with clear notes are far easier to explain than one version that someone has replaced.

Keep the allegations in the complainant's own words, and keep your company's response in a separate document with its own date. If the complaint is amended later, keep each version, and write the date each one arrived next to it. A reviewer who sees three versions with three clear dates can follow what changed. A reviewer who sees one version with no history has to guess.

What is the second record to keep?

The second record is a dated log of every attempt to settle or correct the complaint. The log should include calls, meetings, emails, offers, proposals, and replies, whether they came from the agency, the complainant, a lawyer, or your own staff.

Florida's statute describes why these contacts matter. Once a complaint is within the commission's jurisdiction, the commission must "attempt to eliminate or correct the alleged discrimination by informal methods of conference, conciliation, and persuasion." ( Florida Statutes, Chapter 760, Section 11) That sentence describes what the commission does. It does not list what an employer must do in those talks, so do not read it as a checklist of duties. What it does show is that informal steps are part of the process, and that a reviewer may look at how each side handled them.

For each contact, write down:

  • the date, the time, and the way the contact happened;
  • who took part, and what role each person had;
  • what was offered, asked for, or refused;
  • a short summary written on the same day;
  • any document exchanged, kept in the order it was sent.

Write the summary while the conversation is fresh. A note from the same day carries more weight than a reconstruction written months later, because a reviewer can usually tell the difference. The notes should be factual. Record what was said and what was decided, and leave out guesses about the person's motives or comments about their character. A reviewer may read these notes years from now, and a plain, fair note will serve your company better than a sharp one.

Internal messages belong in the log too. If a hiring manager discusses the complaint with a recruiter or a colleague, that message is part of what the company knew and when it knew it. Write those messages with that later reader in mind. Keep them in the complaint file rather than in personal folders or chat histories that no one else can reach. Do not delete or edit them, and ask counsel before you clear anything from the file.

Keep decisions about the person for ordinary reasons, such as scheduling, pay, or assignments, in their normal records. Mark in the log which of those decisions were made after the complaint was filed, so a reviewer can see the order of events without digging through the whole personnel record. The log is the bridge between the two. It shows what the company did about the complaint and what it did about the person at the same time.

Offers deserve extra care. Write down exactly what was proposed, in what words, and whether it was accepted, declined, or left open. If a proposal was made orally, follow up in writing the same day and ask the other side to confirm it. A written confirmation that goes unanswered still shows a reviewer what was on the table, and that is often the most useful thing a log can show.

What should stay out of the file?

Keep out personal opinions, speculation, and rumors, because a reviewer may read them as evidence even when they are not. A complaint tends to produce a lot of talk. Someone will say what they think the applicant or employee was really doing, or who they believe filed the complaint. Those comments may feel important at the time, but they add nothing a reviewer can check. If a comment bears on the matter, record the facts behind it, with a date and a source, and leave the opinion out.

Labels belong out too. Words such as "difficult" or "not a team player" appear in many personnel records, and in a complaint file they can look like a reaction to the complaint itself. Describe the conduct you observed, when you observed it, and who else was present. If you cannot describe it that way, it probably does not belong in the file yet.

Keep the file limited to what relates to the complaint and to the decisions made about it. Personal medical details, family information, and unrelated history should stay out unless a specific document requires them, and counsel should handle any such document. A tidy file is easier to defend, and easier to hand to an agency without exposing things that were never part of the question.

What is the third record to keep?

The third record is each final decision, with proof of how it was delivered to you. Keep every order, finding, or decision an agency or judge issues, and keep a record of how each one was delivered to its recipients.

Minnesota's statute shows how this works. The statute reads: "The administrative law judge shall cause the findings of fact, conclusions of law, and order to be served on the respondent personally, on the charging party by registered or certified mail, and shall furnish copies to the attorney general and the commissioner." ( Minnesota Statutes, Section 363A.29) If a Minnesota proceeding names your company as respondent, the personal-service line applies to that proceeding. Other states set their own service rules, so check the rules where you work.

Proof of delivery is part of the decision. A signed confirmation of personal service, a certified mail return card, a delivery confirmation, or an email record each shows when a document arrived. Keep it stapled to the order or stored in the same folder, with the received date written beside it. The date you received an order is the date you will refer to when you decide what to do next, so do not rely on memory or on a date printed on a cover letter alone.

Keep the decision in the form it arrived, and keep any working copy you mark up separate from it. If you disagree with a decision, write your response as its own document, give it its own date, and file it after the order it answers. Do not write your disagreement in the margins of the original. A clean original with a separate, dated response is much easier for anyone to read later.

When a decision arrives, do three things on the same day. Record the received date in the index. Send a copy to whoever is responsible for the response, and to counsel. Note the next step and the person who owns it. The point is not speed for its own sake. The record should show that the decision reached the company and went to someone who could act on it.

Penalties are part of the same story. The Minnesota statute lists what the judge takes into account when setting a civil penalty. The judge considers "the seriousness and extent of the violation, the public harm occasioned by the violation, whether the violation was intentional, and the financial resources of the respondent." ( Minnesota Statutes, Section 363A.29) Not every state uses the same factors, and this list belongs to one state. Still, it shows why the file matters. Whether a violation was intentional is a question a judge has to answer from evidence, and the evidence is what the file contains: who decided what, on which date, and what the company knew at each step. A file that shows those steps clearly lets a decision-maker see the facts, rather than relying on a summary written after the fact.

Who can read the file?

Whether outsiders can read the file depends on your state's public records rules, and the Wisconsin annotation here covers only one part of that picture. Wisconsin's statute, section 111.395, has an annotation about access before a hearing. The annotation says that using a blanket rule to stop people from inspecting or copying public papers and records, before an adjudicatory hearing takes place, would be in violation of a statute it cites. That is useful background, but it is an annotation about public records. It does not give an employer a procedure for its own files.

In practice, do not assume the complaint file is private because it concerns a person's job. Do not assume it is public because a government agency is involved, either. Keep the file in a restricted place, where only people with a need can reach it. Before you limit access to anything an agency may ask for, check with counsel that the limit fits your state's rules.

Requests will come from more than one direction. An agency may ask for the file. The complainant may ask for copies of documents about themselves. A lawyer may send a subpoena or a records request. Log each one: who asked, the date, what was requested, what you provided, and who approved the release. If a release is later questioned, that log shows what was shared, when, and on whose decision. Without it, you are left trying to rebuild the answer from email.

Keep the complaint file separate from the applicant's or employee's ordinary personnel file. Cross-reference the two in the index rather than copying documents between them. Copies scatter, and a copy that is later changed may be mistaken for the original. One home for each document, with a pointer from the index, is easier to control.

How do I check the rules where I work?

Look up your state's discrimination statute and the complaint procedure its agency publishes. Then answer five questions, and link each answer to its source. First, does the agency stamp the filing date on the complaint? Second, does it attempt informal resolution, and what does it expect from the parties? Third, how are final orders served? Fourth, what penalty factors does the statute list, if any? Fifth, who can read the file, and at what stage of the process?

Write the answers into a short checklist for your state, with the link and a note of when you looked it up. Agency pages change, and a checklist without a lookup date can look more current than it is. Review the checklist when a new complaint arrives, because the rules you wrote down last year may have moved.

The state references in this post come from three states, and each covers different steps. Florida's text covers the filing stamp and the informal process. Minnesota's text covers service of decisions and penalty factors. Wisconsin's annotation covers public access before a hearing. None of them is a complete set of rules, and none of them is the rule in another state. Use them as a model for what to look for, and read the actual statute for each place you work.

A useful way to keep all of this together is an index on the first page of the file. List each document by date, with its source, its delivery method, and who has access to it. Add a line each time something arrives, including requests and internal messages. The index turns a pile of records into a timeline that anyone reviewing the file can follow.

Different people own different parts of this file. The recruiter usually holds the applicant-facing records, and the hiring manager holds the notes on decisions about the person. Human resources or the people team usually holds the log and the index, and counsel reviews anything sent outside the company. Write those roles on the first page of the file. When an agency asks a question, everyone knows who answers it, and no one sends a document from a personal account that the rest of the team cannot see.

A file with these three records in order is far easier to explain than one where the pieces are scattered across inboxes. Have counsel review the index before an agency asks for the file, so that the first time anyone sees the whole record, it is already in order.

General information, not legal or tax advice.

Sources