In a Washington discrimination hearing, commission counsel presents the complaint, the complainant may bring independent counsel, and an administrative law judge takes part in deliberations. The call can feel alarming. Most people who receive it have never sat in a hearing, and they are not sure who is who in the room or what each person is supposed to do.
This post covers three roles you should know about: the lawyer who presents the case for the state commission, the person who filed the complaint and any lawyer they bring, and the administrative law judge. Knowing what each one does helps you understand what is expected of you, what you can ask, and what you should avoid.
This is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different. If you are named in a complaint or asked to testify, talk with a lawyer who handles employment matters before you respond. Where this post describes a rule, it comes from the Washington statute that sets out how these hearings work, RCW 49.60.250. Read that page yourself, because the statute may have changed since this was written, and because your situation may turn on details this post does not cover.
Why the hearing is different from an investigation
Many people first deal with a discrimination matter through an investigation. A staff member asks questions, collects documents, and writes up what they found. A hearing is a more formal step. It is where the case is argued in front of an administrative law judge, and where the people involved are expected to present their side in a structured way.
That shift matters for small teams. A manager who was comfortable answering an investigator's questions by phone may feel out of place in a hearing room with lawyers and a judge. Nothing about that is unusual. The best preparation is to understand the roles, so you are not surprised by them.
The state statute uses the phrase "human rights commission proceedings" when it talks about these matters, and the hearing is part of that process. Keep that in mind as you read the roles below. Each person has a defined job, and none of them is there simply to chat with you.
Role 1: Commission counsel presents the case
The first role belongs to the lawyer who represents the commission. The statute is direct about this job. It says that "the case in support of the complaint shall be presented at the hearing by counsel for the commission."
This matters for you in three ways.
First, commission counsel is not your lawyer. Their client is the commission, not your company and not you personally. If they contact you, it is reasonable to say that you are not sure what your role is and that you want to speak with your own counsel first. Asking that question is not hostile. It is a normal step that any careful person takes.
Second, commission counsel is not the complainant's personal lawyer either. The statute separates the two roles, which you will see in the next section. Do not assume that the commission's lawyer speaks for the person who filed the complaint, or that they are neutral about the outcome.
Third, commission counsel may want documents, dates, job descriptions, pay records, emails, or notes from interviews. If you are asked for records, do not guess at what they mean or hand over a summary that you wrote from memory. Ask what they are looking for and who is asking for it. Then bring those questions to your lawyer or to whoever handles legal matters at your company.
When you speak with commission counsel, keep your answers short and accurate. If you do not know something, say so. If you are not sure whether a fact is correct, say that too. A confident wrong answer causes more trouble than an honest "I'd need to check."
Role 2: The complainant and any independent counsel
The second role belongs to the person who filed the complaint. The statute gives that person a specific right. It says that "the complainant may retain independent counsel and submit testimony and be fully heard."
For a hiring manager, this has practical consequences. The person who filed the complaint may have a lawyer in the room who is working for them alone. That lawyer may ask questions, present evidence, and make arguments that differ from what commission counsel says. You should expect that the complainant's side will be presented in its own way, and you should not be surprised if it is more detailed or more personal than you expected.
It is also important to know what you should not do. Unless your lawyer has advised otherwise, avoid contacting the complainant about the case, and avoid discussing the complaint with other employees who may be witnesses. Even if you believe the complaint is wrong, pressure on the complainant or on other people involved can create new problems for your company. If the complainant is a current employee, keep your normal workplace practices in place and talk with your lawyer or HR before making any change that affects them.
This post does not cover your company's rights in a hearing. Your company should have its own lawyer, and that lawyer should be the first call.
Role 3: The administrative law judge
The third role belongs to the administrative law judge.
The statute points to RCW 34.12.037 for how an administrative law judge is assigned to human rights commission proceedings. So the judge is a formal part of the process, chosen under its own set of rules, and not a participant in the same way the lawyers are.
Speak to the judge respectfully, and follow their directions about when to speak, when to hand over documents, and how to answer questions. If you are unsure whether you are allowed to say something, it is acceptable to pause and ask your lawyer during a break, if the procedure allows that. Do not try to persuade the judge outside the hearing process.
Judges in hearings like this often ask careful, specific questions. They may want you to explain a decision step by step, identify who else was involved, or describe the documents you relied on. A short, clear answer is usually better than a long story. If you do not remember a detail, say you do not remember. Guessing to fill a gap is one of the most common ways that witnesses hurt their own credibility.
Where investigators fit: they cannot sit on the decision
One rule in the statute is easy to miss, and it matters if your team dealt with a commission investigator earlier. The statute says that "no member or employee of the commission who previously made the investigation or caused the notice to be issued shall participate in the hearing except as a witness, nor shall the member or employee participate in the deliberations of the administrative law judge in such case."
This is useful for you to know because it changes how you should think about the people you already met. The investigator who asked you questions in an earlier stage may be a witness later. Their role has shifted, and you should treat them as a witness, with the same care you would give any other person whose testimony matters.
If you are not sure who in the room is a witness, a lawyer, or the judge, ask before the hearing starts. A short question at the beginning avoids confusion later. Your own lawyer can help you get a clear picture of who is who and what each person is there to do.
What this means for a small team
Small hiring teams often have fewer people to share the load. A single recruiter or a two-person HR function may be asked to handle an entire discrimination matter, while also doing their normal work. That is a lot to ask, and it is worth planning for it early.
Start by naming one person who will be the contact for any legal matter. That person does not have to be a lawyer, but they should know who to call and should keep track of what has been requested. Make sure everyone on the team knows that messages about the complaint should go through that person, rather than being forwarded around informally.
Next, think about the records you already have. Discrimination cases often turn on documents, such as job postings, interview notes, emails, offer letters, performance reviews, and schedules. Leave existing records as they are, and let your lawyer decide what needs to be kept. If you think a record is incomplete or wrong, tell your lawyer rather than fixing it yourself. Changing a record after a complaint has been filed can look like an attempt to hide something, even when the change was meant to correct a mistake.
Then, look at how your team handles hiring decisions in general. A hearing is a poor time to discover that your process is inconsistent. Written criteria for hiring, a consistent way of taking notes, and clear reasons for each decision are good practice no matter what the outcome of a case may be. You do not need to change everything at once, but you can start with the steps that touch the decisions most often questioned. For related recordkeeping, see hiring decision debrief notes.
Finally, make sure the people on your team know what retaliation looks like in practice. Treat the complainant and any witnesses the same way you did before the complaint was filed. Avoid changing schedules, assignments, pay, or references because someone took part in a complaint. Your lawyer can tell you more about what counts as a problem in your state, but the basic rule of treating people fairly is easy to remember.
Related guides
- Interview Scorecard Example for Consistent Hiring Teams
- Conviction timing rules for 3 jurisdictions
- Salary history questions: 3 state rules to check
Questions to ask when you are contacted
When someone contacts you about a hearing, a short list of questions can help you stay in control of the conversation. You do not need to answer all of them on the first call.
Ask who they are and which role they hold. Are they commission counsel, the complainant's independent counsel, a staff member, or someone else? If you are not sure, the answer tells you how to proceed.
Ask whether you are being called as a witness, and what subjects they want to discuss. A witness is not the same as a person who is being accused, and the difference affects what you should prepare.
Ask what documents they want and whether you have been asked to provide them in writing. Keep a record of what you hand over and when. If you are asked to sign something, do not sign it until your lawyer has read it.
Ask about the hearing schedule, but do not assume any dates are fixed until you see them in writing. Dates can change, and you should confirm them through the proper channel.
Ask whether you need your own lawyer. In many cases the answer is yes, and it is better to get that advice early than to try to manage a hearing without it.
Finally, ask who else will be at the hearing. Knowing whether the judge, the complainant, the complainant's lawyer, and commission counsel are all present will help you prepare.
Preparing for your own testimony
If you are asked to testify, preparation is the most useful thing you can do. Start by reviewing the documents that relate to the decision in question. Write down a timeline of events, without adding opinions or guesses. Then talk through the timeline with your lawyer, so you know which parts are firm and which parts you are less sure about.
When you testify, listen to the full question before you answer. Pause before you speak. If a question has two parts, you can ask for it to be repeated or split. If a question asks you to agree with a statement about a fact you do not know, you can say that you do not know.
Keep your tone steady. Hearings can be tense, especially when the subject is a serious accusation about how someone was treated. You can be respectful toward the complainant without agreeing with every claim, and you can explain your reasons without raising your voice. Judges and lawyers notice when a witness stays calm and answers plainly.
Remember that your job as a witness is to describe what you saw, did, and knew. It is not to win the case for your company, and it is not to win an argument with the complainant or the complainant's lawyer. A witness who sticks to facts and admits limits is more believable than one who tries to cover every point.
Getting help
This post is a starting point, not a substitute for a lawyer who knows your case. If you run a small business or a staffing firm, it may make sense to find an employment lawyer who has handled Washington discrimination matters before. You can ask your industry association, your insurance provider, or a local bar referral service for names. Ask whether the lawyer has experience with hearings before a state human rights commission and whether they have represented employers in those hearings.
Bring the complaint, any letters you received, the documents you have gathered, and a short list of your questions to the first meeting. The more organized you are at the start, the less time the lawyer needs to spend getting oriented, and the more time they can spend on the questions that matter.
If your company has insurance that may cover legal defense for employment claims, check the policy early. Some policies require prompt notice of a claim, and waiting can cause problems. Ask your insurance contact or your lawyer what the policy says, rather than guessing.
The three roles, in short
Knowing these roles will not make a hearing comfortable, but it will make it clearer. When you understand who is who, you can focus on the things you control: honest answers, accurate records, a calm tone, and a lawyer you trust. For a small team that may be hearing about a discrimination case for the first time, that clarity is worth a lot.
For the statute these points come from, read RCW 49.60.250 and bring your questions to a lawyer who can apply it to your facts.