Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Screening criteria: 3 groups to set before hiring

Before screening applicants, agree on three groups of criteria: must-haves, nice-to-haves, and disqualifiers. Someone reads the applications, a few look promising, and the rest get set aside on a feeling. That approach works until it doesn't. The problem is rarely effort. It is that nobody wrote down what the job requires before the first application arrived, so each reviewer quietly builds a standard of their own and applies it differently.

This post covers a fix that takes little time to set up. Agree on the groups with everyone reviewing applications for the opening. Each group does a different job, and together they give you one yardstick to hold every applicant against.

What are the three criteria groups?

Must-haves are the requirements an applicant has to meet to move forward. Nice-to-haves are things that make an applicant stronger but are not required. Disqualifiers are the conditions that rule an applicant out, no matter how strong they look on other points.

The split is not a new idea. Workable's support guide for its agent describes the same three categories when it builds criteria from a job description, and it says the tool produces up to 14 criteria sorted into must-haves, nice-to-haves, and disqualifiers. Workable's guide You don't need special software to use the idea. A shared document with three headings does the same job. Software only helps if you were going to write the list anyway.

Why set the groups before you screen?

Set them before you screen because a list written after you have seen the applications tends to describe the people you already like. If you read a stack of applications and then decide what matters, the criteria bend toward whoever caught your eye first. Writing the groups first means the standard is fixed before anyone's name is attached to it.

It also saves time. A reviewer who knows the groups can move through a pile of applications quickly, because each one is a set of plain checks rather than a fresh debate about what the job needs. The debate happens once, at the start, with everyone in the room.

This also protects the people you are reviewing. Indeed's employer guide frames its interview checklist as a way to support a fair screening process and to evaluate applicants better. Indeed's employer guide A fair process is hard to claim when the criteria were chosen after the fact.

Consider who will compare notes across reviewers. A large company has a recruiting team that can compare notes across reviewers. A small firm often has one owner, one hiring manager, and maybe a bookkeeper who helps out. Those people may hire only occasionally. LinkedIn's hiring guidance includes material aimed at non-recruiters who hire occasionally but still need to make the right hire fast. LinkedIn's recruiting tactics That describes most readers of this post, and it is why a short, written set of groups is worth the time.

What belongs in the must-haves group?

The must-haves group holds the requirements an applicant has to meet to reach the next step. Keep it short. Include only what the job cannot work without on the first day, such as a license the role legally requires, a skill the team uses every day, or a working schedule the position depends on.

Good must-haves describe what a person can do or has done, not how they come across. "Can prepare invoices in our accounting software" is useful. "Strong communicator" is hard to check from an application, and it means different things to different reviewers. Write each must-have so that two people reading the same application would reach the same answer.

Test each item by asking what happens if a strong applicant lacks it. If the answer is "we would train them in a week," the item belongs in the nice-to-haves group. If the answer is "the role cannot start," it is a must-have. A list can have too many must-haves when hiring managers want to guard against risk. Each extra must-have shrinks your pool, and it can keep out people who would have done well with a short onboarding period.

A small firm should be able to fit its must-haves on one screen. If the list runs longer than that, you probably have preferences dressed up as requirements. Go back through the list and move the preferences into the nice-to-haves group, where they can still count without blocking anyone.

What belongs in the nice-to-haves group?

The nice-to-haves group holds the skills and experience that would make an applicant stronger but that you could live without. This group is where you record the things you would like to see, and you use it to rank applicants who already meet the must-haves.

Good nice-to-haves help you choose between two qualified people. Experience with a particular tool, prior work in a similar market, or a second language spoken with customers are typical examples. Give each one a plain description so you can check it the same way for everyone.

Be careful about how much weight this group carries. It is tempting to let a long nice-to-have list decide the outcome, especially when two applicants look equal on the must-haves. Decide in advance how much a nice-to-have is worth. For example, you might decide that an applicant who meets more of the nice-to-haves ranks above one who meets fewer, and that a tie goes to the applicant with the most relevant recent work. Write that ranking rule down with the list, so the choice is not made in the moment, when you are tired and one applicant is easy to like.

Treat the tool's maximum as a ceiling, not a goal. Workable's guide For a small firm, most openings need far fewer. A long list usually means the job has not been thought through.

What belongs in the disqualifiers group?

The disqualifiers group holds the conditions that rule an applicant out, no matter what else they offer. Use this group sparingly, and write each entry so it can be checked without guessing. A disqualifier should be a fact that either applies or does not. Examples include a required certification the applicant does not hold, or a notice period that clashes with a start date you cannot move.

Some disqualifiers come from legal requirements, and those should be checked with someone qualified once drafted. Ask an employment adviser or your accountant to review the full group once it is drafted. A short review now costs far less than a dispute later.

Be especially careful with anything that touches personal characteristics. Nothing in this group should be about age, family status, religion, or any other trait that has nothing to do with doing the job. An informal comment about those factors can end up in a complaint. If a factor is not tied to the work itself, it should not be a disqualifier, and it should not shape your decision.

Record the reason each time you use a disqualifier. A short note such as "no valid work authorization for this role" gives you something concrete to point to if an applicant asks why they were not moved forward. Without a note, the decision rests on memory, and memory is not a record anyone can check.

How many criteria should each group hold?

Keep the total small. A short must-have list, a handful of nice-to-haves, and a brief disqualifier list cover most openings. Treat that as a rough guide and adjust it for the role. A list that a reviewer can hold in mind is more useful than a long one nobody reads twice.

A useful check is to read the list aloud to someone who has not seen the job before. If they can tell you what the hire will do and what a good first month looks like, the list is probably the right size. If the list describes a different job than the one you posted, cut it back.

What does a finished list look like?

A finished list for a small-office bookkeeper role has a short must-have group, a few nice-to-haves, and a start-date disqualifier, and each item is written as a plain test. The example below is illustrative, so swap in the terms that fit your own opening.

Must-haves: has kept books for a business using accounting software, can reconcile a bank account without help, and can work on the days the role requires.

Nice-to-haves: has used the payroll tool the firm already runs, has worked for a business in the same trade, and has prepared reports for an outside accountant.

Disqualifiers: cannot start by the date the firm has set for the role.

Notice that each item can be checked from an application or a short call. Nothing on the list describes a personality trait. The nice-to-haves rank applicants who already pass the must-haves, and the disqualifier is factual. Reading the list this way keeps the screen quick, because a reviewer can work through the applications without reopening the job description every time.

How do you write a criterion you can check?

Write each criterion as something a reviewer can confirm from the application or a short conversation. Start with an action or a fact, and avoid adjectives that cannot be measured. "Has managed a team of people on a daily basis" can be checked. "Leadership ability" cannot.

Give each criterion a one-line definition that says what counts and what does not. For example, a must-have for payroll experience could say that running payroll for an employer counts, while a course on payroll software does not. The definition is what makes two reviewers reach the same answer. Without it, each person fills the gap with their own idea of what the words mean.

Finally, read each criterion as an applicant would. If a capable person with an unusual career path could not show that they meet it, rewrite the criterion so it describes the skill rather than the route someone took to learn it. This keeps your list focused on the work and stops it from favoring people who followed one particular path.

What do you do when an applicant misses one must-have?

A missed must-have ends the applicant's place in the process; apply that rule to everyone. Some missed must-haves are fatal, such as a license the role legally requires.

Before the interview, record the gap against the written requirement. Name the missing skill or qualification and note how you checked it. That turns a judgment call into a documented decision, and it lets you compare the applicant fairly with the others who meet every must-have outright.

If an applicant is strong on the nice-to-haves but misses a must-have, do not quietly relax the must-have for them. Either the requirement is real, or it was never a must-have. If you find that you keep bending the rule for the applicants you like, the list needs to be rewritten, and that rewrite should happen with the other people who agreed to the groups, not in the middle of a single search.

How do you keep screening fair across applicants?

Apply the same groups to every applicant for the same opening, in the same order, and record the result for each one. Consistency is the main protection a small firm has. When every application is checked against the same written list, you can explain any decision by pointing to the list.

Indeed's employer guide offers 11 tips for building an interview checklist. Indeed's employer guide For interviews, decide the questions in advance and ask the same core questions of everyone. See the guide to using the same interview questions in a fixed order.

Keep your notes focused on the criteria. If a note mentions something unrelated to the job, such as an applicant's family or where they grew up, leave it out of the decision. A reviewer reading your notes later should be able to see exactly which criteria were checked and what the answers were, and nothing else.

Finally, avoid changing the process halfway through a search. If a late applicant arrives with an unusual background, the right move is to check them against the same groups, not to add a new criterion that fits them. Changes to the groups can be made between openings, after the team has discussed them, and then applied to the next search.

Who should agree on the groups?

Two or three people should agree on the groups before screening starts. Those people are usually the person who will make the hire, someone who knows what the job involves day to day, and whoever is responsible for the firm's hiring practices. In a very small firm, that may be the owner plus one team member. The aim is a list that the people who will work with the hire can defend.

Agreement matters because disagreements tend to surface at the worst possible moment. If the hiring manager and the owner want different skills, it is far better to find that out before the applications arrive than during the final interview round. A short meeting, with the list on screen, can settle most of these differences in less time than one interview takes.

Write down who agreed and when. You do not need a formal sign-off process. A dated note at the top of the document is enough to show which version of the groups was used for a given search.

How do you use the groups during interviews?

Use the same groups to plan each interview. Every must-have should be checked at least once, either in the application, in a phone screen, or in the interview itself. Nice-to-haves can come up in conversation and help you rank the finalists. Disqualifiers should be confirmed early, because there is no point scheduling a long interview with someone you cannot hire.

After each interview, write a short note against the groups. Record which must-haves were confirmed, which nice-to-haves came up, and whether any disqualifier applied. Notes made right after the conversation are more accurate than notes made days later, when the applicants have started to blur together.

When you compare finalists, put the notes side by side and look at the must-haves first, then the nice-to-haves, then the disqualifier notes. This order keeps the strongest personality in the room from deciding the outcome before the criteria have been weighed. Use an interview scorecard to organize those checks.

What should you do after the hire?

Keep the groups and review them once the new person has been in the role for a while. Note which must-haves turned out to be needed and which were not, and which nice-to-haves really made a difference on the job. This small habit improves the next opening, because you are no longer starting from a blank page.

Store the revised groups where the next hiring manager can find them. If screening lists are lost when the person who wrote them leaves, every new opening starts from zero. A shared folder with a file for each role type is enough to prevent that.

Sources