Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Undue hardship: why a 10% salary cap is not the test

Undue hardship has no federal 10% salary cap; employers must weigh accommodation costs, available resources and effects on operations. Recruiters and hiring managers who use a salary cap to close a request may be deciding on the wrong test, and they may expose their company to a claim the company could have avoided. This post explains what the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) asks, why a percentage of salary was never part of that test, and how to work through the decision so it holds up if someone reviews it later.

Is there a 10% salary cap on accommodation costs?

No. The federal test does not set a cap based on a share of the employee's pay. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) addresses this point directly in its technical assistance manual on the employment provisions of the ADA: "When enacting the ADA 'factors' for determining undue hardship, Congress rejected a proposed amendment that would have established an undue hardship if an accommodation exceeded 10% of an individual's salary."

The mistake is easy to make because a salary percentage looks objective. It produces a single number that anyone can calculate in a minute. But the number tells you very little about whether a particular accommodation would be a real burden on a particular employer. The ADA asks a harder question, and the answer depends on facts that a salary calculation leaves out.

What did Congress decide about a percentage-of-salary test?

The law looks at the employer's situation, not only at the employee's pay.

A percentage of salary ignores the employer almost entirely. Consider two companies that receive the same request for the same piece of equipment. For a small business with thin margins, the cost may be a serious strain. For a large company with a large budget, the same cost may be trivial. A salary-based cap would give both companies the same answer, even though the burden is very different. The ADA's factors exist so that the answer can reflect the difference.

A percentage also ignores the employee's role in the calculation. An accommodation that costs a modest amount may be essential for someone to do the job at all, while a larger expense for a convenience may be easy to justify. A fixed share of salary cannot tell those cases apart. Good decisions start from the purpose of the accommodation and the employer's real capacity to provide it.

A better set of questions starts with three things. What does the accommodation actually cost, including setup and upkeep? What can this particular employer realistically spend, and how was that figure reached? How would the accommodation change the daily work of the team? None of these questions can be answered with a salary ratio, and all three need facts gathered from the people who run the site.

What does undue hardship actually measure?

Undue hardship is a judgment about a specific accommodation for a specific employer. The employer weighs several factors together, and no single figure decides the outcome. The EEOC manual says factors 3 and 4 apply when a facility is part of a larger covered entity, to assess the financial resources actually available to the facility in light of that relationship; the accommodation's effect on operations also matters.

One factor the manual names directly is "the impact of the accommodation on the operation of the facility that is making the accommodation." This is where many hiring managers should spend their time. A cost figure alone does not show whether the accommodation disrupts the work, slows a team, or changes how a job is done. If an accommodation has a small price tag but forces a major change in how the shift runs, that disruption belongs in the analysis. If an accommodation costs more but barely changes anything in daily operations, the picture is different.

The practical lesson is to avoid reducing the question to one number. Write down the cost, the operational effect, and the resources available, then consider them together. A decision that looks reasonable on one line may look different once all of the factors appear on the page.

How do I weigh the cost against the employer's finances?

Start with an honest estimate of what the accommodation costs, then compare that figure with what the employer can realistically spend on it. The comparison is the heart of the analysis, and it should be made with actual numbers from the organization, not a rough feeling about whether the request seems expensive.

The EEOC manual includes an example that shows how this works in practice. It describes a case in which "the cost of an assistive device is $2000, and an employer believes that it can demonstrate that spending more than $1500 would be an undue hardship." In that case, the manual says, "the individual with a disability should be offered the option of paying the additional $500."

Three points follow from that example. First, the employer's line comes from its own circumstances, not from a fixed percentage. In the example, the line is set by what the employer can show it cannot reasonably spend, and the figures are offered for illustration only. Second, when the cost goes above the line, the answer is not always a flat refusal. Third, the employer needs to be able to demonstrate its position. A manager who says "that is too expensive" without support has not finished the analysis.

For a hiring manager, a useful record would include the total cost, the amount the employer believes it can justify spending, the reasoning behind that figure, and any options that would bring the cost within reach. If the employee offers to contribute toward the cost, note that offer and how it was handled. Keeping this record makes the decision easier to explain and easier to defend.

What if the company operates more than one location?

A company with several sites cannot simply point to the budget of the local office and call it a hardship. The EEOC manual says that when a facility is part of a larger covered entity, the broader organization's resources come into the picture.

The manual also explains how the analysis works when a company runs more than one location. It says that "factor 4. will be considered, along with factors 2. and 3., where a covered entity operates more than one facility, in order to assess the financial resources actually available to the facility making the accommodation, in light of the interrelationship between the facility and the covered entity."

The phrase "actually available" is the one to focus on. The question is not what the company could spend in theory, and it is not what a single site happens to have in its own account. The question is what resources genuinely flow to the site that would provide the accommodation, given how the site and the wider company are connected. A decision maker who ignores the broader organization may understate what is available. A decision maker who assumes the whole company's budget is available to one site may overstate it. Both mistakes come from skipping the step of checking how money and authority actually move through the organization.

If you manage a single location within a larger company, ask the people who understand the company's budgeting how costs are shared and approved. Their answer is more reliable than a guess based on the local budget line alone.

Does the type of workplace change the analysis?

Yes, in some cases. The EEOC manual notes that "factor 4. may include consideration of special types of employment operations, on a case-by-case basis, where providing a particular accommodation might be an undue hardship." The words that matter here are "case-by-case." The quoted language does not create a category of workplaces that automatically qualifies for an exception. It asks that the way work is organized be examined in each situation, and it leaves the judgment to the facts of that situation.

For recruiters and hiring managers, this means describing the work as it actually happens. If a job depends on a particular schedule, a shared piece of equipment, or a tightly sequenced process, those features may affect whether a given accommodation can be provided without real disruption. The description should come from people who know the work, and it should explain how the accommodation would change the process, not just whether it is inconvenient.

It also means you should not assume that a workplace is special because it feels special. A busy team, a tight deadline, or an unfamiliar request is not enough by itself. Explain what makes the operation different and how the accommodation would affect it. A specific, documented explanation holds up far better than a general sense that the work cannot be changed.

What should I do when the cost is above the employer's line?

Do not treat the answer as automatically final. A cost above the employer's justified limit is the starting point for a conversation, not the end of one.

Other steps are also worth considering. Ask whether a less expensive accommodation would meet the same need. Ask whether a phased approach, a loan of equipment, or a change in how the task is done would reduce the cost. Ask the employee what they actually need, because the request as first written is not always the only way to meet the need. These steps show good faith, and they often lead to an outcome that works for both sides.

Share the cost figures with the employee where you reasonably can. Many people who ask for an accommodation have already looked at prices, and they can often suggest a cheaper option or a different supplier. Treating them as a partner in the numbers tends to produce better answers than working the numbers alone.

If the employer still concludes that a particular accommodation would be an undue hardship, the decision should be explained clearly to the employee. The explanation should name the cost, the resources considered, and the operational effects that led to the decision. Vague refusals are hard to defend and tend to damage trust, even when the underlying conclusion is correct.

How should a hiring manager document the decision?

Write down the process, not only the outcome. A useful record shows the request as it was made, the options considered, the cost estimates for each option, the resources and operational effects weighed, and any offers made to the employee. It should also show who was involved in the decision and when it was made.

This record protects both the employer and the employee. It shows that the employer took the request seriously, looked at the real facts, and considered alternatives before reaching a conclusion. It also gives the employee a clear account of what happened, which reduces the chance of misunderstanding. If the decision is later reviewed, a complete record is far more persuasive than a memory of what seemed reasonable at the time.

Keep the record factual. Avoid language that describes the employee's disability in negative terms, and avoid speculating about the employee's future needs. Focus on the accommodation, the costs, and the operational facts. A plain, accurate account is easier to stand behind than an emotional or unclear one.

Engaging with the employee throughout the process is also part of good practice. Ask questions, listen to the answers, and follow up. A conversation that is documented as it happens is stronger evidence of good faith than a decision reached in isolation and explained afterward. For the broader process, see how to handle an accommodation request.

Timing matters too. A request that sits unanswered for weeks can become a problem in its own right, even if the eventual decision is sound. Set a realistic schedule at the start, tell the employee when to expect each step, and record any delays along with the reasons for them.

Where should I check the rule before deciding?

Start with the source. The EEOC manual is the federal guidance quoted in this post, and it is the place to confirm the language used here. Read the sections on undue hardship in full, because the short quotes here cannot capture every detail of the analysis.

Remember that federal law is not the only law that may apply. Minnesota's disability accommodation provision says failure to engage in the process to determine whether a reasonable accommodation exists may be an unfair discriminatory practice. A decision that meets the federal standard may still need to be checked against state requirements. If your company operates in more than one state, make sure the review covers each place where the decision will be applied.

Finally, bring in the people who can help you decide well. Human resources staff, employment counsel, and the managers who know the work can each contribute something the others cannot. A decision made with their input is more accurate, and it is easier to explain to the employee, to colleagues, and to anyone who later reviews the outcome.

Related guides: Handle 6 religious accommodation checks for small firms · Religious accommodation: 5 scheduling checks.

Sources