Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Wisconsin exempt duty test: 20% and 40% limits

Why two percentages matter

A salaried job often gets its "exempt" label in a hurry. A recruiter copies a posting from last year, a hiring manager adds a few lines about what they need, and nobody checks whether the duties described really fit an exemption. At small Wisconsin firms, where one person may handle hiring, payroll, and operations all in the same week, that shortcut is common. It is also where problems start.

Wisconsin's administrative code gives you two numbers to watch. The first is 20 percent. The code describes an employee who does not devote more than 20 percent of their hours of work in the workweek to activities that are not directly and closely related to the exempt work. The second is 40 percent, which applies to an employee of a retail or service establishment under the same test.

This post explains what those numbers mean, how they fit the rest of the test, and what to do when you write job descriptions, set pay terms, or review roles that have changed over time. It is general information, not legal advice. When a role sits close to a line, read the current code and talk to an employment attorney before you finalize the classification.

Where the rule comes from

The chapter that holds these rules has a long history. The Legislature's page for the section includes a history note explaining that chapter Ind 74 as it existed on March 31, 1977 was repealed, and that a new chapter Ind 74 was created effective April 1, 1977. The same page notes that Chapter ILHR 274 was renumbered as chapter DWD 274. You can read the page for yourself at the Wisconsin Legislature's DWD 274.03 page.

Why should a hiring manager care about old chapter numbers? Because copied text travels. An HR packet or a job-description from a former employer may cite an older chapter or repeat language from an older version. If you see "Ind 74" or "ILHR 274" in a document, check the current text rather than trusting it.

The overtime connection

The chapter states that the employees it describes are exempt from the overtime pay requirements in the section it cites. That is why classification matters to your payroll and scheduling, not only to your org chart. When you call a role exempt, you are making a statement about overtime, and you should be able to back it up with the actual duties of the job.

Many small firms treat "salaried" and "exempt" as the same word. They are not. A salary arrangement tells an employee how they will be paid. The exemption asks what the employee spends their working time doing. Answer the duties question first. For the wider picture, see state overtime rules before the offer.

Start with primary duty

The chapter's duties category covers persons whose primary duty consists of administrative, executive or professional work. You can read that language in DWD 274.04(1). That phrase is the anchor for everything else in the test. An employee's primary duty is the main reason the job exists. It is not the title on the offer letter, and it is not a list of everything the person touches in a typical week.

Ask three plain questions about any salaried role:

  1. What is the main reason this position exists?
  2. Which tasks take up most of the person's working time?
  3. Does that main work fall within administrative, executive, or professional work as the chapter describes it?

If you cannot answer the first question in one sentence, the role is probably not defined clearly enough to classify. Fix the definition before you decide the pay terms.

Here is an example. A project coordinator at a small contractor whose main work is scheduling crews, tracking materials, and managing client communication has a different primary duty than someone whose main work is hands-on installation. The first role may fit the chapter's categories. The second may not, however impressive the title sounds. Whether a role fits is a question about facts, so describe the actual work rather than the work you hope the person will do.

The 20 percent limit

Here is the core of the rule. Under the code, an employee does not meet the description if they devote more than 20 percent of their hours of work in the workweek to activities that are not directly and closely related to the performance of the exempt work described in the chapter. You can check the wording on the Legislature's DWD 274.03 page.

Four points stand out.

First, the limit is about hours. It is not about a single task, a single meeting, or a few minutes here and there. It is the share of total working time that goes to unrelated work.

Second, the limit is measured in the workweek. The rule asks about each workweek's hours. A busy week counts toward the test, and one above the cap is a warning sign to fix in the job or the workload. A quiet week does not prove the role is compliant either. Look at a representative stretch of weeks, including at least one busy period, before you conclude anything.

Third, the test is about relatedness. Work that is directly and closely related to the exempt work does not count toward the cap, and work that is not related does. The question is not whether the employee is busy. It is how much of their time goes to work outside the exempt job.

Fourth, the cap is a ceiling, not a target. A hiring manager who writes "spend 20 percent of time on other duties" has misread the rule. The cap says the employee should not devote more than 20 percent of their workweek to unrelated work. Build the job around the exempt work, and keep the unrelated share small enough that it stays under the line in ordinary weeks.

Illustrative example: one workweek

Suppose a supervisor works 40 hours in a workweek and logs 8 hours of work that is not directly and closely related to the exempt duties. That is 20 percent of 40 hours, so the share sits exactly at the cap. One more hour of unrelated work pushes it above 20 percent. This is a made-up case to show the arithmetic, not a ruling on any real job.

The 40 percent limit for retail and service

The code sets a different figure for an employee of a retail or service establishment. Under the same test, the figure is 40 percent rather than 20 percent. The category of the establishment where the employee works decides which one you use, so check each job rather than the firm as a whole. You can confirm the exact wording on the DWD 274.03 page.

Before you rely on the higher figure, do two things. First, decide whether your business is a retail or service establishment as the code uses those terms. Do not assume it because you sell something or serve customers. Read the definitions in the chapter and test your business against them. Second, remember that the 40 percent figure attaches to the employee of that kind of establishment.

The chapter also defines terms used in the rule. For example, DWD 274.01(5) defines "mercantile" as "pertaining to merchants or trade," and says the word is synonymous with commercial. When your business description uses words like commercial or mercantile, check the definitions before drawing a conclusion from everyday meaning. The code controls.

The rule is measured against work that is "directly and closely related" to the exempt work described in the chapter. The chapter refers to specific subdivisions for that work, so read the full subsections before you classify a role. Work that serves the core exempt duties sits on one side of the line. Work that does not serve those duties sits on the other.

The following examples are questions to ask, not rulings. Each one depends on the facts of the job and on the full text of the code.

  • A supervisor who trains new staff, sets schedules, and reviews performance is doing work that may be closely tied to supervising. A supervisor who spends a regular part of each week handling unrelated clerical work for another department may need a closer look.
  • A bookkeeper who reconciles accounts, prepares reports, and advises on cash flow is doing work that may be related to the professional side of the job. Regularly answering the shop phone or processing walk-in orders may not be.
  • A marketing hire who plans campaigns and writes copy is doing work that may be related. Regularly packing orders for shipment may not be.

The point is to notice when a role has drifted, and to decide whether the drift is temporary or permanent. A short staffing gap can pull a supervisor into front-desk coverage for a few weeks. If that coverage becomes the normal routine, the role has changed, and the description should change with it.

Writing the job description

A good description does three things. It states the primary duty, it lists the main duties in order of the time they take, and it names the work the employer expects to keep outside the role. Your internal description should show that you planned for the limit. For the standard sections, see job description parts.

Some practical habits help:

  • Lead with the exempt work. Name the main responsibilities in the first paragraph, not the last.
  • Describe the work in the order it takes time. If most of the week goes to planning and supervising, say so first.
  • Avoid a long tail of "other duties as assigned" that could cover almost anything.
  • Be honest about the mix. If the job includes some hands-on work, describe it and note roughly how much of the week it takes.
  • Date the description and review it when the role, the team, or the manager changes.

A simple structure works well for most small-firm roles:

  • Primary purpose: one sentence that states why the job exists.
  • Core responsibilities: five to seven items, most important first.
  • Supporting responsibilities: items that serve the core work and are closely connected to it.
  • Work outside this role: tasks that should not become regular parts of the job, and who covers them.

That last section is the one most firms skip, and it is the most useful. Naming the work that is not part of the role gives you something to measure against later.

Settle the classification before pay terms

A common mistake is to set a salary first and then fit the duties around it. Another is to write a job that sounds exempt because the pay looks high. Settle the duties question first, then set the pay and document both. That order keeps the offer letter, the job description, and the actual work consistent. For a quick duty check before you write the offer, use the duty tests before a salaried offer page.

Check the offer letter against the description. If the offer calls the role exempt, but the posting describes mostly unrelated tasks, that mismatch is the first thing an employee, an auditor, or a state reviewer is likely to notice. A mismatch between paper and practice is hard to explain after the fact.

Tracking how time is spent

If a role already exists, check the actual mix instead of guessing. Guessing is one of the most common ways small firms end up with a classification problem. A simple method works well:

  1. List every regular task for the role.
  2. Sort each task into one of two groups: directly and closely related to the exempt work, or not.
  3. Ask the employee to keep a short log over several workweeks, including at least one busy week.
  4. Add up the hours in each workweek and calculate the share that went to unrelated work.
  5. Compare that share to the figure that applies to your business: 20 percent in general, or 40 percent for a retail or service establishment under the chapter.
  6. Record the dates, the results, and any changes you made in response.

Keep the log simple. A spreadsheet with a date, a task, an approximate hours figure, and a related or unrelated column is enough. Do not ask for minute-by-minute timekeeping, which is hard to do well and often inaccurate. Round-number estimates are a reasonable starting point. If the numbers come out close to the line, get advice before you decide anything.

Be careful about how you ask for the log. An employee who feels pressure to make the numbers look good may under-report unrelated work, which defeats the purpose. Explain that the numbers are for planning the role, and make it clear that an honest record is what you want.

If the numbers show unrelated work above the cap, you have three broad options. You can move the unrelated work to someone else. You can restructure the role so that related work becomes the main job. Or you can reclassify the position. The third option has consequences for pay and overtime, so talk with counsel before you choose it. Doing nothing is not an option, because the numbers will not improve on their own.

Common mistakes

Several errors show up again and again in small firms. Watching for them can save you a difficult conversation later.

  • Copying an old packet without checking the chapter. Old packets often reflect an older version of the rules or someone else's situation.
  • Writing the description for the ideal hire rather than the actual job. A posting that promises strategy and leadership, when the work is mostly daily operations, sets everyone up for disappointment.
  • Letting a role drift. A supervisor who starts covering the front desk during a staffing gap may keep doing it for a year without anyone noticing. Drift is one of the most common ways a sound classification goes wrong.
  • Using the 40 percent figure without checking the category. The higher figure applies only in the situation the code describes.
  • Treating the cap as a target. The limit is a ceiling. A role that sits right at the line has no margin for a busy month.
  • Relying on the title alone. A title is a label. The chapter looks at the work.

A quick checklist

Before you finalize a salaried role, ask yourself these questions:

  • Can you state the primary duty in one sentence?
  • Do the main duties in the description match that sentence?
  • Have you listed the unrelated work and named who covers it?
  • Have you measured the mix across more than one workweek, including a busy one?
  • Does the unrelated share fit under the 20 percent cap, or under the 40 percent figure if the business is a retail or service establishment under the chapter's definitions?
  • Do the posting, the offer letter, and the internal description tell the same story?
  • Did you cite the current chapter rather than an old packet?
  • If the answer is close, have you talked with counsel before you finalize the classification?

Closing

The two percentages are simple to remember and easy to misuse. Everything else depends on the primary duty and the facts of the actual job. If you write descriptions with those facts in mind, measure the role honestly, and check the current code when a case is close, you will avoid most of the trouble this rule can cause.

Start with the current text of DWD 274.03. When a role does not fit neatly on either side of the line, an employment attorney is the right person to call.

Related guides: Draft 8 noncompete legal terms for exempt job roles · EEOC ADA examples: 5 essential duty standards · Election-day time off: 4 state rules for offers.

Frequently asked questions

Does the 40 percent figure apply to every employer?

No. The 40 percent figure applies only to an employee of a retail or service establishment under the chapter's terms, and other roles fall under the 20 percent cap.

Does a busy week count toward the limit?

Yes. The limit is measured against hours in each workweek, so a busy week counts toward the test.

Sources