A new-hire checklist should cover four checkpoints: accommodation requests, Form I-9 Section 1, Section 2 review, and Colorado career progression disclosures.
Key takeaways
- Give each onboarding step a named owner.
- Move the Section 1 request out of the offer packet and into the acceptance step.
- Put the Section 2 review and deadline on the calendar.
- Tell new hires who handles accommodation requests and where to find progression requirements.
New-hire paperwork tends to arrive all at once. An offer goes out, the start date is a few days later, and in between someone asks which form goes where, whether a welcome packet can go out before the applicant has said yes, and what to do when a new hire mentions a need for a change at work. Recruiters and small-firm hiring managers often carry these questions without a written checklist, and that is how small steps get skipped. Small firms feel this more because one person often handles recruiting, HR and payroll at the same time.
This post covers four checkpoints that come up between the offer and the first day. Each one is based on an official federal or Colorado page, and each links to that page so you can read the full context before you act. The pages are the authority here, not this post.
What counts as an accommodation request during onboarding?
A request counts when a new hire tells you they need an adjustment or change at work for a reason related to a medical condition. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's guidance for small employers puts the test in one sentence: "The individual must let the employer know that s/he needs an adjustment or change at work for a reason related to a medical condition." ( EEOC guidance on small employers and reasonable accommodation)
That sentence matters during onboarding because the moment a need comes up is often unplanned. An applicant may mention it on a call about start dates. A new hire may raise it during a first-day tour of the office. It may come up while someone is filling out a welcome form that asks about desk setup or schedule. Each of those can be a request, even though none of them looks like a formal process.
The same guidance says the request does not have to be formal. An individual "may use 'plain English' and need not mention the ADA or use the phrase 'reasonable accommodation.'" ( EEOC guidance) So if a new hire says, in ordinary words, that they need to stand for part of the day because of a back problem, the employer has received a request, whether or not anyone used the official terms. A hiring manager who hears this on a phone call should not wait for the applicant to send a form.
The guidance also says requests "do not need to be in writing, though an employer may choose to write a memorandum or letter confirming the request." ( EEOC guidance) My suggestion is to write a short note after any such conversation. Record the date, who heard the request, and what change was asked for. Then pass it to whoever in your firm decides on accommodations, so the request does not sit in a recruiter's inbox.
Two practical points follow. First, a hiring manager should not promise an outcome on the spot. Route the request to the person who owns those decisions; use the accommodation request steps to plan the handoff. Second, the process should not end on the first day. A request can come from someone who has already started, so keep the channel open after onboarding is over. Make sure the new hire knows who to tell and how to reach that person.
When does a new hire have to finish Section 1 of Form I-9?
The employee must complete Section 1 no later than the employee's first day of employment. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services handbook for employers states that deadline directly, and it is the outer limit you should plan around. ( USCIS handbook, section 3.0)
The handbook also limits when you can ask for it: wait until the individual has accepted a job offer before requesting Section 1. ( USCIS handbook) That line matters for how offers are packaged. Some offer letters arrive with the I-9 attached, and a recruiter may think of the form as part of the offer. If your offer packet includes the form, move it to a step that happens after the applicant says yes.
A small firm can get this wrong without noticing. Suppose the first day falls right after a weekend and the applicant accepted the offer late the week before. The window is short, and the paperwork is easy to forget. Put the I-9 step on the checklist for the day the offer is accepted, not on the morning of the start date. Attach it to a named person, so that someone is responsible for sending the form at the right moment and for noticing if it has not come back.
Keep the rest of the onboarding paperwork on its own list. Use the onboarding document request limits when reviewing that list.
When does the employer complete Section 2 of Form I-9?
You may complete Section 2 after the applicant accepts the offer, but only once Section 1 has been returned and reviewed, and no later than three business days after the hire. The handbook states the window this way: "You may review the employee's document(s) and fully complete Section 2 at any time between the date the employee accepts the job offer and completes Section 1 to within three business days of the hire." ( USCIS handbook)
Read that sentence closely. The handbook ties the start of the window to the employee accepting the job offer, and it ties the end to three business days after the hire. In practice, Section 2 need not wait until the first day. Count the three business days from the hire, and write that date on the calendar when the hire is set.
Before you complete Section 2, check Section 1. The handbook says, "Before completing Section 2, you should review Section 1 to ensure the employee completed it properly." ( USCIS handbook) This is a review of whether the form was completed properly, not a second interview. If a field is blank or a box is marked in the wrong place, the time to find that out is before you move on, not three weeks later when someone looks at the file.
The order is the main lesson here. A common shortcut is to fill in Section 2 on the first morning, before Section 1 has come back. Waiting for the completed Section 1 costs little, and it keeps the steps in the right sequence.
Illustrative example: an offer-to-hire handoff
Here is how the sequence can look for a single hire. The offer goes out early in the week, and the applicant accepts later that week. The Section 1 request goes out the same afternoon, and the employee returns it before the first day. The hiring team reviews Section 1 when it arrives, asks the employee to fix any blank field, and then completes Section 2 within the handbook's deadline. Each step has a clear trigger, and nothing depends on someone remembering a date.
Can I ask a new hire to show documents to check their Section 1 answers?
No. The handbook states, "Employers may not ask for documentation to verify the information entered in Section 1." ( USCIS handbook) This is a pressure point in onboarding, because a recruiter who sees an unusual name, a date that looks off, or a missing address may want proof before filing.
The difference between two kinds of checking is the part that trips people up. Reviewing a form for proper completion and reviewing documents during Section 2 serve different purposes. A document check happens inside the Section 2 process, under those rules, not as a side request about the answers the employee wrote in Section 1.
If something on Section 1 is incomplete, go back to the employee and ask them to complete the missing part. That is a reasonable reading of the handbook's instruction to review Section 1 for proper completion, and it does not involve asking for proof of what the employee wrote. Avoid inventing a side process for checking Section 1 answers. A second form, a questionnaire, or a request for a copy of a personal record creates a new record for someone to track.
If you are unsure how an entry should look, the handbook page is the place to confirm the rule. Read the section, compare it with what your team is doing, and adjust the checklist to match. Do not rely on memory of what a previous employer did, and do not treat a colleague's habit as the rule.
Who can complete Section 1 for someone who needs help?
A representative, parent, or legal guardian can complete Section 1 for certain minors and for employees in special placement who need one. The handbook states it this way: "The certification must also be completed for certain minors and employees in special placement who require a representative, parent, or legal guardian to complete Section 1 for them." ( USCIS handbook)
Check how the handbook defines "special placement" before arranging help. Do not guess from the phrase. Read the full page for the definition, and for what the representative must do and record when they complete Section 1 on someone's behalf. A recruiter who relies on a loose reading could end up with a form completed by the wrong person, which is a problem to fix before the first day, not after.
A recruiter should notice early when an applicant's circumstances might fit one of those situations. If the role involves young workers, or if an applicant's circumstances raise the question, check the handbook before the first day and bring in whoever in your firm handles hiring policy. Waiting until the first morning to learn that a parent or guardian needs to be involved leaves very little time to sort it out.
Plan for the representative to be available on the same timeline as the new hire, and write the arrangement into the onboarding checklist as its own line.
What does Colorado require about career progression for a position?
The Colorado bill SB23-105 requires an employer with positions that have career progression to disclose the requirements for that progression to all eligible employees and make them available to those employees. The General Assembly's bill page for "Ensure Equal Pay For Equal Work" describes the requirement this way: "For positions with career progression, the act requires an employer to disclose and make available to all eligible employees the requirements for the career progression." ( Colorado General Assembly, SB23-105)
The quote is narrow in ways that matter. It applies to positions with career progression, not to every job. It covers the requirements for that progression, not the whole job description. And it speaks of eligible employees, so the group it reaches is the employees who are eligible for the progression, not every applicant who sees the posting.
Why does this turn up during onboarding? A new hire will often ask how they move up, and the answer tends to live in one manager's memory. If the progression requirements exist only in that memory, they are hard to disclose and hard to make available to anyone else. Writing them down is a practical way to make them easier to share.
For each role with a progression path, consider writing down three things: the levels, the requirements for moving from one level to the next, and where current employees can find that information. Keep the list with the role's posting or offer materials, so a recruiter can answer an applicant's question about advancement without guessing. This is especially useful at small firms, where the people who know the progression path may be few and busy.
Today, open your onboarding checklist and assign an owner to each checkpoint below. Mark the acceptance trigger, calendar the form review, and confirm who receives requests before the next hire starts.
How do I fit these checkpoints into one onboarding process?
Put the four checkpoints on one checklist in the order they usually come up, and give each step a named owner. Progression requirements belong early, because the easiest time to answer an applicant's question about advancement is before the offer goes out. Section 1 follows the applicant's acceptance. Accommodation requests have no fixed place in the sequence, because they can come at any point. The checklist should say where they go and who receives them.
A good test for the finished checklist is to hand it to someone who was not involved in writing it and ask them to walk through a hire from offer to first week. Any step they cannot explain, or any owner they cannot name, is a gap to close before the next applicant arrives.
Owners matter more than the checklist itself. In a small firm, one person may do all of this, which makes it easy for a step to be skipped. Naming an owner for each line means someone is responsible for noticing when a step is due. If one person holds several roles, write down which role they are playing for each step, so the handoffs are visible.
The aim of all four checkpoints is the same: to make the sequence visible. An offer is accepted, a form is completed on time, a need is heard and written down, and a path to advancement is explained. When those steps are on one list with owners, the first day is a routine part of the work rather than a scramble.
Related guides: Form I-9 errors after hire: 3 correction methods · I-9 name mismatch: 4 steps for a new hire's document · New hire benefits: 5 IRS rules and examples.