Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Veterans' preference points: 2 federal statutes to check

Which two statutes set the veterans' preference points?

The two statutes are 5 U.S.C. 2108 and 5 U.S.C. 3309. The Office of Personnel Management says so in its Vet Guide for HR Professionals: "The following preference categories and points are based on 5 U.S.C. 2108 and 3309 as modified by a length of service requirement in 38 U.S.C."

Key takeaways

  • Check each category against 5 U.S.C. 2108 and 3309, read with the length of service requirement in Title 38.
  • Treat an applicant's claimed preference as a claim to verify, and keep it in a separate column from the score.
  • Confirm that SF 15 and the requested documentation are in the file before you record any 10-point preference.
  • Compare wartime service dates with the definition of "war" in 5 U.S.C. 2108.
  • Record the decision, the statute or guide page you relied on, and the date.

First, the categories and point values come from those two sections. Second, a length of service requirement in Title 38 modifies them, so a category name on an application is not enough by itself. Third, the two sections have to be read together. Do not assign points from memory of either one. Pull the category descriptions from the guide and the statute text before you score anyone.

A list often has a column for the preference an applicant claims, and the applicant usually fills it in. Treat that entry as a claim to verify, not as a finding. The verification steps are the subject of the rest of this post.

Keep the preference column separate from the score column. When the two are mixed, a reviewer who sees a score cannot tell whether the points rest on a verified claim or on the applicant's own entry. Separate columns make it easy to see which entries are still open and which were checked against the statute.

What did the Hubbard Act change?

The Hubbard Act changed the eligibility categories used for veterans' preference when it became law. It was enacted on August 29, 2008, as Public Law 110-317. The Vet Guide states: "On August 29, 2008, the Hubbard Act was enacted as Public Law 110-317." It also states: "The Hubbard Act amended the eligibility categories for veterans’ preference purposes by adding subparagraph (H) to 5 U.S.C. 2108."

A reviewer working from an older checklist, or from a list built before 2008, could miss that category entirely. Check each claim against the current text of 5 U.S.C. 2108.

The same caution applies to older files. If a claim was accepted or denied under an earlier reading of the statute, check the current text before you rely on that result for a new list.

Do not work out who falls under subparagraph (H) from memory. The statute text and the guide's category descriptions answer that question, and the reviewer should cite whichever one was used on the list.

What does "war" mean in the veterans' preference rules?

Under 5 U.S.C. 2108, "war" means only armed conflicts that Congress declared as war, and the definition names World War II specifically.

The definition has two parts, and a reviewer should keep them apart. The first part limits "war" to armed conflicts that Congress declared as war. Service in a conflict that was never declared as war does not fit the definition, however serious that conflict was. The second part names World War II and gives its dates: December 7, 1941, to April 28, 1952. When a service record shows dates in that period, compare them with those two dates, and record the comparison. For any other conflict, confirm the answer in the statute and the guide before you give or deny the category.

The table gathers the dates, numbers, and requirements from this post, so you can compare them side by side.

ItemFact from the quoted passages
5 U.S.C. 2108One of the two statutes the guide cites for preference categories and points
5 U.S.C. 3309 The other statute the guide cites for preference categories and points
Length of service requirementLocated in 38 U.S.C. and modifies the categories and points
Hubbard Act enactmentAugust 29, 2008, as Public Law 110-317
Hubbard Act changeAdded subparagraph (H) to 5 U.S.C. 2108
"War" under 5 U.S.C. 2108Armed conflicts declared by Congress as war, including World War II
World War II period in the definition December 7, 1941, to April 28, 1952
10-point preference claimRequires SF 15 and the requested documentation

What must an applicant submit to claim 10-point preference?

An applicant claiming 10-point preference must complete a specific form and submit documentation. The Vet Guide says: "Applicants claiming 10-point preference must complete Standard Form (SF) 15, Application for 10-Point Veteran Preference, and submit the requested documentation."

Two things follow for a recruiter. The form is part of the claim itself. A 10-point claim with no SF 15 in the file is incomplete on the face of the record, so the file cannot yet support the points. The documentation is what the agency requested, so compare what the applicant sent against your request, item by item. Take the list of documents from your agency's request and the guide rather than from memory.

Holding the points open is a reasonable choice while a file is incomplete. Note the reason on the list so the next reviewer knows why the score is pending.

How should a reviewer handle an unclear veterans' preference claim?

Record the gap and request the missing information instead of guessing at the category. An applicant may mark the preference box and leave the category blank, or describe service without attaching the form the claim needs. A reviewer who fills the gap with a guess has made a decision that the file cannot show.

Note the open item on the list. Send the same request to every applicant with the same gap, so the handling is consistent. Hold the score until the answer arrives. Keep the request and the reply in the file so the record shows what was asked and when it was answered.

Treat service documents as personal records. Store them only where your agency's records rules allow, and share them only with staff who need them to score the claim.

Why do the statute and the form both matter?

They do different jobs, and a claim needs both checked. The statute tells the reviewer what a category requires. For a 10-point claim, the SF 15 and the requested documentation are the applicant's support for it. Checking only one leaves a gap. A reviewer who reads the statute but accepts a claim without the form has a category with no proof behind it. A reviewer who collects the form but never reads the statute has proof with nothing to measure it against.

The same logic applies to the Hubbard Act and the war definition. Each one is a reading rule in 5 U.S.C. 2108, and each needs a record that shows the reading was applied to that applicant's facts.

How should a recruiter apply these rules to a competitive list?

Work through the list one applicant at a time, and use the same steps for every applicant. The steps below follow from the rules quoted above. Finish one applicant's steps before you start the next, because switching back and forth between files makes it easy to carry a reading from one claim into another.

  1. Confirm which applicants claim preference and which point value each one claims.
  2. For each claim, identify the category named and check it against 5 U.S.C. 2108 and 3309, read with the length of service requirement in Title 38.
  3. If a claim depends on subparagraph (H) of 5 U.S.C. 2108, check the Hubbard Act change before you decide.
  4. If a claim depends on wartime service, compare the service dates with the definition of "war" in 5 U.S.C. 2108.
  5. For any 10-point claim, confirm that SF 15 and the requested documentation are in the file before you record the points.
  6. Record the decision, the statute or guide page you relied on, and the date of the decision.

Consistency matters as much as accuracy. If one applicant's service is checked against the definition and another applicant's is accepted without a check, the list is hard to defend when someone questions it. Consistent steps also let a second reviewer retrace the scoring, and that is the main reason to write down the source for each decision. A reviewer who skips a step for one applicant has made the whole list harder to explain. For a scoring layout built for consistent hiring teams, see Interview Scorecard Example for Consistent Hiring Teams.

What should go into the file for each preference claim?

Each file should let a second reviewer reach the same result without asking the first reviewer. At a minimum, the record should show the category claimed, the statute relied on, whether the SF 15 is present for any 10-point claim, which documents were requested and which came back, and the decision with its date.

Keep the notes with the applicant's file, not in a personal spreadsheet that only one person can read. If the reviewer's reasoning lives only in their head, the record cannot answer a later question about the decision. For another example of writing down a decision, see Hiring Decision Debrief: Notes to a Recorded Decision.

What should an applicant be told when a claim is not accepted?

Tell the applicant which element is missing or which rule the claim did not meet, in plain words and in writing. A message that says only "not eligible" gives the applicant nothing to fix and invites a dispute the file cannot answer. Name the statute section the decision rests on, such as 5 U.S.C. 2108 or the SF 15 requirement, and list the documents still needed.

Use the same wording for every applicant in the same position. If the applicant sends more material, review it against the same steps and record the result in the file.

Where the reason depends on a statute section, quote the section number rather than paraphrasing it from memory. That lets the applicant look up the same text the reviewer used.

Who should check the claims before the list goes out?

The person who scores the list should check every claim, and a second person should spot-check the decisions that rest on the hardest readings. A full second check of every applicant may not be practical. A spot-check of the claims that depend on subparagraph (H), on the war definition, or on a 10-point form gives the most value for the time, because those are where readings are hardest.

The second reviewer does not need the applicant's full file for every case. The reviewer needs the claim, the statute reading applied, and the evidence on file. Those three things are enough to tell whether the decision follows from the rule.

Where should a recruiter confirm the rule before scoring?

Start with the Vet Guide for HR Professionals, because it is the source quoted for every rule in this post. Then check the statute text for 5 U.S.C. 2108 and 3309, and ask your agency's human resources office how it applies the rules locally. Record the page and the date you used it.

The guide and the statute are the reference points. A local office may have forms or procedures that add steps, but those steps do not change the statute. If the guide and your office disagree, record the question, ask HR for a written answer, and keep that answer with the file.

Next step today

Open the Vet Guide for HR Professionals and copy the category description for each claim on your current list into its file, with the date you pulled it.

Frequently asked questions

Which statutes set veterans' preference points?

5 U.S.C. 2108 and 3309 set the preference categories and points, as modified by a length of service requirement in 38 U.S.C.

What does a 10-point preference claim require?

It requires the applicant to complete SF 15, Application for 10-Point Veteran Preference, and submit the requested documentation.

What does "war" mean under 5 U.S.C. 2108?

It means only armed conflicts that Congress declared as war, and the definition names World War II, which covers December 7, 1941, to April 28, 1952.

Sources