Plan for a Minnesota discrimination charge in three stages: read the charge and preserve records, prepare your response, and prepare for the determination.
Key takeaways
- Preserve relevant records without changing existing files.
- Base your response on dated evidence, not guesses.
- Discuss possible outcomes and settlement authority with counsel.
If you are a recruiter, a hiring manager, or the owner of a small firm in Minnesota, it is natural to feel alarmed. The better move is to treat the charge as a process with stages. Each stage asks for different work, and each one rewards planning.
This post covers three stages to plan for. The first is the moment the charge reaches you, when you read it closely, preserve records, and set up your internal team. The second is the response stage, when you write your answer, gather evidence, and decide whether an early resolution makes sense. The third is the determination stage, when the state decides how the charge will proceed and what options remain. The process described here comes from the Minnesota Human Rights Act. The section that sets out much of the charge process is Minnesota Statutes section 363A.28.
This is general information, not legal advice. Every charge depends on its facts, and the notice you receive is the first place to look for the exact requirements that apply to your case. Bring in a lawyer who handles employment matters in Minnesota early, ideally before you send your first written response.
Stage one: read the charge and set up your team
Your early decisions about records, people, and communication shape everything that follows.
Begin with the charge itself. Read it more than once, and separate what it claims from what it simply describes. Write down who is named, what action or decision is said to be discriminatory, when it allegedly happened, and what information or remedy is requested. Keep in mind what the charge is. Under section 363A.28, the commissioner may issue a charge that states, in statutory language, an alleged violation of the Act, whenever the commissioner has reason to believe that a person is engaging in an unfair discriminatory practice. Your job at this point is to understand exactly what that statement covers, and what it does not.
Next, look at the time period. The same section allows the commissioner, in a complaint, to seek relief for a class of individuals affected by an unfair discriminatory practice that occurred on or after a date one year before the charge was filed. This class-relief provision is not a general record-retention deadline; discuss the preservation period with counsel. If the charge describes older events, widen the search to match.
Preserve records now. Send a written preservation instruction to everyone who may hold relevant material. That usually includes hiring managers, HR staff, the owner, and whoever administers your applicant tracking system, payroll, or shared drives. The instruction should cover email, text messages, chat tools, calendars, interview notes, scorecards, job postings, applications, offer letters, pay records, and personnel files. Suspend any routine deletion, such as auto-delete settings on email or messaging apps. Do not edit, annotate, or "tidy up" existing files. If you need to talk about the charge internally, keep those conversations limited to the people who are helping you respond, and do not create new commentary about the matter in ordinary email or chat threads.
Decide who runs the response. Name one point of contact for the state, for the other side, and for your own team. A witness should not be the only person writing the answer, and it helps to keep decision-makers and witnesses in clear roles from the start.
Then set clear rules for the people involved. Tell managers not to contact the person who filed the charge about it, not to discuss it with coworkers, and not to change that person's job, schedule, pay, or reporting line without getting advice first. Such changes can look like retaliation even when they were planned before the charge arrived. Put those instructions in writing so managers can refer to them.
Check your insurance. If your firm has employment practices liability coverage, read the policy and notify the carrier in the way the policy requires. Do not wait to learn what the policy says, because late notice can create problems that are hard to fix later.
Finally, put every date from the notice on a shared calendar with reminders well ahead of each one. Confirm the dates with counsel. Missing a deadline is an avoidable mistake that can disrupt your response.
Stage two: write your response and build the record
The second stage is where your written answer matters most. The answer is a document the state will read, and the other side may read it too. The statute provides that the charging party or the party's representative may review the answer that the respondent submits in response to the charge, as set out in section 363A.28.
Write for that audience. Keep the answer factual, specific, and consistent with your records. Do not guess about dates, names, scores, or reasons. If you do not yet know something, say that you are checking and that you will supplement the answer when you have the facts. Do not overstate your position, and do not attack the person who filed the charge. A short answer that is accurate usually does more good than a long one that must be corrected later.
Build your evidence file at the same time. For an employment-related charge, add the personnel file, the pay history, and records of similar decisions made for others in comparable roles. Organize the file by date and by topic so that you can find any document quickly. For a hiring decision, use the hiring decision debrief guide to review how the decision was recorded.
The statute also lists, among the items it covers, whether a charge is supported by substantial and credible documentation, witnesses, or other evidence, as set out in section 363A.28. Expect the state and the other side to ask what your records show about the decision at issue. Be ready to answer with organized, dated records rather than memory. Where your records are thin, say so honestly and explain how you will fill the gaps.
Identify the witnesses too. Make a list of the people who have direct knowledge of the events in the charge, and write a short note about what each one knows. Some witnesses may have their own interests, and some may need separate advice. Counsel may want to speak with them, and you should avoid pressuring anyone to shape their account. Witnesses who are asked to describe what they remember, in their own words, give you a more reliable picture than a set of statements drafted by management.
Now consider resolution. The same section directs the commissioner to try to eliminate an unfair discriminatory practice through education, conference, conciliation, and persuasion, at the place where the practice occurred or where the respondent resides or has its principal place of business. See section 363A.28. Discuss possible resolution with counsel while gathering records. Decide in advance who can approve what. Set a settlement authority, define what outcomes you would consider reasonable, and think through non-monetary options such as training, updated policies, or a revised hiring process. Preparing these answers before a conference keeps you from making rushed decisions when the other side is in the room.
Be careful about what you promise. Any change you describe in conciliation should be one you have approved and can actually carry out. Talk with counsel before you describe a corrective step, so that you do not overstate what has been done or imply an admission you did not intend to make.
Illustrative example: organize a document review
Suppose your initial file contains 10 records: 5 interview notes and 5 emails. Group them by topic, then arrange each group by date. List questions for counsel separately, leaving the original records unchanged. These illustrative counts describe a review task, not a deadline or required file size.
Stage three: determination and what comes next
The third stage is about the state's decision and the path after it. Timing and form depend on the facts of your case, so most of the planning here is about having options ready before the decision arrives.
One outcome to understand early is a finding of no probable cause. The statute says that a decision by the commissioner that no probable cause exists to credit the allegations of an unfair discriminatory practice shall not be appealed to the court of appeals under section 363A.34 or sections 14.63 to 14.68. See section 363A.28. Ask your counsel what, if anything, remains open to the charging party and to your firm in that situation, and whether any other step is worth considering. Do not plan around a particular result in either direction.
If the matter moves forward, discuss possible court proceedings with counsel. The statute provides that, except as modified by its own provisions, the Minnesota Rules of Civil Procedure apply to an application, and the district court has authority to grant or deny the relief sought on conditions it deems just and equitable. See section 363A.28. Ask counsel to explain those conditions in your situation so you can weigh them against any settlement option.
Plan for the cost and the time. Estimate the hours that owners, managers, and witnesses will need to spend on document review, interviews, and depositions. Build that time into the workweek now, so that the business does not stall. Set a realistic budget with your counsel and review it at each stage.
Keep the conciliation track open. Revisit your settlement authority as the facts develop. New documents, a witness who turns out to be stronger or weaker than expected, or a ruling on a procedural question can all change what a fair outcome looks like.
Control what you say publicly. Prepare a short internal message for employees and a one-sentence external holding line for customers, partners, and job applicants. Something like "We take our obligations seriously and are reviewing the matter" is usually enough. Do not comment on the facts in public, and do not discuss the charge on social media. Anything you publish can be read by the charging party and by the state.
Finally, use what you learn. A charge is a stress test for your hiring and employment practices. Once the immediate process settles, review your job postings, interview scripts, scoring sheets, documentation habits, and manager training. Use the interview scorecard guide when reviewing scoring practices for future hiring. A process that records clear, job-related reasons for each decision makes past decisions easier to explain.
Common mistakes to avoid
The first is reading the charge too quickly. A skim can miss the time period, the names involved, or a deadline printed in the notice.
The second is writing a defensive answer full of speculation. Statements like "I'm sure the decision was based on experience" invite follow-up questions you may not be able to answer.
The third is handling the matter informally. A manager who calls the complainant to "clear the air," or who mentions the charge at a team meeting, can create new problems. Route all contact through your point of contact and your counsel.
The fourth is cleaning up records. Deleting old emails, editing scoring sheets after the fact, or rewriting notes can damage your credibility far more than the underlying facts would.
The fifth is assuming the first answer ends the matter. Charges move through stages, and each stage can reopen questions. Keep your file current and your team informed.
The sixth is sharing the charge too widely. Keep a list of who has received the charge and when.
The seventh is treating the process as a formality. Some owners assume the state will simply side with the employer, or that the complainant will simply go away. Neither assumption is a sound basis for planning. Prepare as if the matter will be examined closely, because it may be.
Working with counsel
A lawyer can help you read the notice, prepare the answer, decide what to produce, and weigh a settlement against the costs of continuing. Look for counsel who handles employment matters in Minnesota and who has experience with state agency processes as well as court proceedings. Ask about their experience with charges like yours, how they will communicate with you, and how they will handle the calendar and the document review. Share the full record with them, including the parts you think are unhelpful. An accurate picture early is far more useful than a surprise later.
Your next step today
Read your notice today and make a dated list of its requirements and your questions for counsel. Use that list to organize your first discussion before drafting the answer.
Related guides: Age discrimination: 8 hiring and benefits rules · Job requirement discrimination: 6 steps from EEOC and states · Minnesota minor exemptions: 3 groups to check.
Common questions
Are these stages fixed deadlines?
These are planning stages, not a deadline schedule. Use the dates in your notice and confirm the requirements with counsel.
Should a witness write the response alone?
A witness should not be the only person writing the answer. Assign clear roles for the response and for gathering witness accounts.
What should you do when a record is missing?
Identify the gap honestly and discuss how to address it with counsel. Keep questions about missing material separate from the original records.