Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Holiday pay: 4 checks before writing an offer

Before writing an offer, confirm holiday closures, pay for days not worked, overtime treatment, and any promised rate for holiday work.

Key takeaways

  • Confirm which holidays the business closes for.
  • Separate paid days off from holidays worked.
  • Ask payroll to check overtime wording against the rules for the job.
  • State any promised holiday rate clearly.

A line that says "paid holidays" or "time-and-a-half on holidays" can mean one thing to a recruiter, another to a hiring manager, and something else to the new hire who signs. This post covers four facts to check before you write that line, plus a few questions that come up once the letter is drafted. The examples come from state labor department pages for California and Alaska, and each one is linked where it is used. They show how two states handle the question. They are not a guide to your state, so check your own state's pages too.

Illustrative example of a paid day off

Suppose the firm promises an illustrative payment of $40 for a holiday not worked. If the office closes and the worker does no work that day, record $40 as the promised holiday payment and 0 hours worked. Keep the payment separate from hours actually worked elsewhere in the week when payroll reviews overtime.

Do I have to close the business on a holiday?

California law does not require holiday closure. The state labor department says that "There is nothing in state law that mandates that an employer must close its business on any particular day, if at all." ( California Department of Industrial Relations, "Holidays") The offer letter should describe what your firm actually does rather than assume a day off.

Many small firms stay open on some holidays and closed on others, and a hiring manager may not know which is which until the first holiday arrives. Find out before you draft. Ask the owner or operations lead which days the office closes, which days it stays staffed, and whether the answer changes from year to year. Then put the answer in writing. A new hire who reads "closed on the following days" knows what to expect, and a new hire who reads nothing will assume the usual pattern from their last job.

Can I pay for a holiday the worker does not work?

Yes, in California, the department's answer is that an employer may pay for a holiday the worker did not work. The page includes a worker's account of a business that was "closed for business on Monday to celebrate Memorial Day." It then addresses the case directly: "even though you did not work on the holiday your employer chose to pay you for it, which it has the absolute right and discretion to do." ( California Department of Industrial Relations, "Holidays")

The choice belongs in writing. A recruiter who writes "paid holidays" without a list may create a promise the firm did not plan to keep, because a reader can take those words to mean the firm closes and pays on every holiday in the calendar.

The practical step is to separate two things in the letter: the days the office is closed, and the days the firm pays for. Those are not always the same list. A firm can close on a Monday and pay for it, or close and not pay. Each arrangement needs its own sentence. Each sentence should match what payroll does in the first holiday week after the hire starts, because that is the week when a mismatch becomes visible.

Does holiday work count toward overtime?

Check the rules that apply to the job before promising overtime pay; the California page raises this question through a worker's account. The page includes a worker's note about a single holiday: "Last week I worked eight hours on the 4th of July holiday, which fell on Wednesday." It also includes a worker whose business closed on Monday for Memorial Day, so they "worked Tuesday through Saturday that week, eight hours each day," and was "paid for 48 hours last week at my straight time rate." That worker then asks, "Shouldn't eight of those hours be paid at time and one-half, the overtime rate, since I was paid for more than 40 hours in the workweek?" ( California Department of Industrial Relations, "Holidays")

Two things make this a drafting problem, not only a payroll problem. First, distinguish hours paid from hours actually worked when reviewing a week that includes a paid holiday off. Second, how hours are counted toward a weekly threshold depends on the rules that apply to the job, so the letter should not promise an overtime rate until someone has checked that count against those rules. For related checks, see the guide to state overtime rules.

Ask payroll to walk through a sample week with a worked holiday and a paid holiday not worked. Write down the hours, the rate for each kind of hour, and the total pay the week produces. If the total surprises anyone in the room, check whether the calculation or the letter needs correcting before it goes out. Keep that sample with the offer file so the reasoning is on record if the question comes up later.

What does time-and-a-half mean in an offer letter?

In Alaska's example, time-and-a-half means 1½ times the regular rate for each holiday hour worked. ( Alaska Department of Labor and Workforce Development)

The key word in that example is "promises." The premium is something the employer has promised, which means the letter is where the promise lives. If your offer says time-and-a-half, the worker can point to that sentence. If your offer says only "holiday pay," the sentence is vague, and vague sentences are the ones that cause disputes at the first holiday. Decide the rate before you write the letter, and write the rate in the letter.

Keep one point clear. The Alaska example is about holiday hours worked. Address pay for a holiday not worked in a separate sentence in your letter.

Today, compare the holiday wording in your offer with the handbook and ask payroll to explain any mismatch before you send it.

Does a worked holiday always pay more?

A higher rate depends on the promise in Alaska's example. Check the firm's actual holiday pay arrangement and describe it in the letter. Check your state's wage rules before you pick one.

The easiest way to get this wrong is to write a premium in one place and a flat rate in another. A hiring manager writes "holiday shifts pay double" in an email, the recruiter writes "holiday pay under policy" in the letter, and the handbook says nothing at all. When the worker reads all three, the version they remember is often the most generous one. Pick one source of truth and point the other documents to it, so that a question about holiday pay has one answer no matter who is asked.

Which holidays should the letter name?

List the holidays the firm covers, or explain how the list is set each year. A phrase like "standard holidays observed by the company" leaves the worker to guess, and a guess can turn into a dispute in December. If your firm has a short list, put it in the letter. If the list changes each year, say that the firm publishes the list in writing before the year starts, and then actually do it.

The California holiday examples identify the days involved. That is a useful model for your letter. You do not need to write a long list of dates, but a reader should be able to tell, from the letter alone, whether a given weekday is a paid day.

Also decide what happens when a holiday falls on a weekend. The letter does not have to solve every calendar case, but it should say which rule the firm uses, so the answer does not change depending on who is on shift that week.

Should the offer mention holiday pay at all?

Mention it only if the firm will actually provide it. An offer letter is a promise, and a holiday line that the firm does not honor is worse than no line at all. If the firm closes on some holidays and pays for none, say so plainly, or leave the topic out and point to the handbook for the schedule. A reader who sees "holidays" with nothing else may assume there is a benefit, so explain whether the time off is paid.

If holiday pay is part of the offer, make it a specific term. Give the holiday list, the pay for a holiday not worked, and the rate for a holiday worked. Those three items cover most of what a worker will ask about, and they give the recruiter something concrete to confirm with the hiring manager before the letter is sent.

What happens when a new hire starts in a holiday week?

The letter should say whether a new hire is eligible for holiday pay in their first weeks, and if eligibility depends on length of service, it should say that too. This case can catch small firms off guard when the offer is written months before the start date and nobody checks the calendar when the letter goes out.

Look at the start date and the holidays near it. If a holiday falls in the first week, decide whether the new hire is paid for it, and write that decision into the letter. If the answer depends on something the firm controls, such as a probation period or a waiting period, name that condition. If the answer depends on a rule that differs by state, check the state's labor department pages for that work location before you decide.

Who decides which days count as holidays at my firm?

The person who signs the offer letter should own the holiday list, and that list should be written down before the letter goes out. In a small firm, the list often lives in the owner's head or in a calendar nobody else reads. That is fine until a new hire asks about it, and then the recruiter has to find the answer in a hurry, often from someone who is busy with the holiday itself.

Start by listing what the firm already does. Pull last year's schedule, note which days the office was closed and which days were staffed, and mark any day that was closed but not paid, or paid but not closed. Those marks show the real practice, which may differ from what everyone remembers. Then compare the list with the handbook. If the two disagree, fix the handbook first, because the letter will point to it.

Once the list is settled, give it an owner and a review date. A simple note in the standard offer letter that says when the holiday list was last confirmed, and who confirmed it, makes the next recruiter's job easier. It also means the letter for a new hire in October does not quietly repeat last spring's answer.

Do the holiday terms apply to part-time and hourly staff?

The letter should state whether its holiday terms apply to part-time and hourly staff. Part-time and hourly workers are often the people a holiday line affects most, and they are the people most likely to ask about it. A letter written for a salaried role can leave an hourly worker wondering whether the same terms apply to them, and a vague answer may leave them expecting benefits the firm did not intend.

Consider the schedule. A part-time worker may not be scheduled on a given holiday at all, while a full-time worker is. Decide in advance how the firm handles a holiday that falls on a scheduled shift and one that falls on a day off. Write each case as its own short sentence so the worker does not have to combine two clauses to find the answer.

Also check whether the holiday terms depend on hours worked in the period before the holiday. If they do, name the period and the number of hours in the letter. The worker should not have to guess what counts, and the recruiter should not have to reconstruct it later from a payroll screen.

How should the offer letter word holiday pay?

Use short, specific sentences that name the holiday, the pay for a holiday not worked, and the rate for a holiday worked. Keep each sentence tied to what the firm actually does. A line such as "The company observes the holidays listed in the handbook, and holidays worked are paid at the rate in Section 4" is clearer than a long paragraph about the firm's values.

Avoid words that make a promise sound larger than it is. "Generous," "competitive," and "full holiday benefits" invite a reader to expect more than the firm will pay. Say the number and the rule instead. A worker can argue about a number, but a vague adjective leaves them free to decide what it means.

Use the same terms as the handbook. If the handbook says "paid holiday," do not write "holiday premium" in the letter, and do not mix the two in the same document. Different words for the same pay can cause confusion, because each reader decides which word matters.

What should I check before I send the letter?

Check that the holiday wording matches what payroll will do, that the handbook says the same thing, and that the rules for the work location have been reviewed. If the sample total does not match what the letter promises, change the letter now, not after the hire's first paycheck. Use the related new hire pay checks when reviewing the rest of the first paycheck.

Then ask a second person to read the letter cold. A hiring manager who did not write it should be able to say, in one sentence, what happens on a holiday the worker works and what happens on a holiday the worker does not. If they cannot, the letter needs another pass. If the answer for a particular state is unclear, ask your employment counsel before the letter goes out rather than guessing.

Last, keep the sample calculation and the final letter together in the offer file. When the first holiday arrives and someone asks what was promised, the record should answer that question without a search through old email.

Sources