Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Harassment and retaliation: 3 complaint checks

When someone raises a harassment or retaliation concern, record the conduct, check what changed afterward, and route both concerns to HR or counsel.

Key takeaways

  • Record the person's words, dates, witnesses, and pending decisions.
  • Check what changed after the concern was raised and why.
  • Capture unwelcome conduct without deciding its legal label.
  • Ask HR or counsel before moving a connected hiring decision forward.

It might come up on a screening call, in the middle of an interview loop, or during a first-week check-in. The person may be nervous about how you will react, and you may not be sure what you are allowed to say or promise. Those feelings are normal. They are also a reason to slow down and use a short checklist instead of reacting on instinct.

Two caveats before you start. First, this is general information, not legal advice. Employment rules differ by state and by agency. The sources quoted here describe rules in two specific states, Maine and Wisconsin, and nothing in this post says those rules apply where you work. Second, your job in the first conversation is usually to collect facts and route the concern to the right people, not to decide whether harassment or retaliation happened. If the concern is serious, bring in your employment counsel or HR team early.

Check what happened after the complaint

Retaliation is its own concern, so check whether anyone treated the person worse after they raised the concern. The original problem still matters, but it is a separate question from what happened to the person once the concern was on the table. An applicant who is quietly moved down a hiring list after raising a concern, or a new hire whose schedule changes the week after a complaint, may be facing retaliation even if the original concern is never settled.

Maine's statute on unlawful employment discrimination shows how one state has written this rule. In Title 5, §4572 of the Maine Legislature's statutes, the relevant text reads:

> "For an employer, employment agency or labor organization to discriminate in any manner against individuals because they have opposed a practice that would be a violation of this Act or because they have made a charge, testified or assisted in any investigation, proceeding or hearing under this Act."

Two triggers appear in that sentence. The first is that the person opposed a practice that would be a violation of the Act. The second is that the person made a charge, testified, or assisted in an investigation, proceeding, or hearing. The first trigger does not mention a formal complaint. That matters in screening and onboarding, because an applicant or new hire may push back on a remark, a request, or a practice in an informal way well before anything is filed with anyone. Treat that pushback as something to look at, not as a tone problem to be managed.

The section also has limits you should keep in mind. It refers to "individuals," and it does not say on its face whether it reaches an applicant who has not started work. It also refers to "this Act," so deciding whether a particular practice violates it requires the rest of the statute and advice from your own counsel. This post does not do that analysis, and you should not treat a quick reading of one sentence as a final answer.

When a retaliation concern comes up, these are the facts to pin down first:

  • The date and the words the person used when they raised the concern, and who heard it.
  • Every decision still pending for the person, such as an offer, a start date, a shift or schedule, a team placement, a reference check, a review, or a probation decision.
  • Whether anything about those decisions has changed since the concern was raised, and if so, what changed and when.
  • Who knows about the concern, including the people who might be named in it and the people who are making the pending decisions.
  • The reason recorded for each decision, along with the date it was recorded.

Timing matters, but timing alone does not answer the question. A change that follows a complaint is worth examining. So is a change that was already planned before the complaint, because the planning record helps show the sequence. Write both down with dates. The purpose of the timeline is to let the people who review the matter see the sequence clearly. It is not a reason to reach a conclusion in the first conversation.

Retaliation does not always look like a rejected offer or a termination. It can be quieter: fewer invitations to meetings, feedback that suddenly becomes harsher, a colder tone from a manager, or a new requirement that does not seem to apply to anyone else. Record those changes the same way you would record a bigger one. Use plain descriptions and specific examples, such as "Interview invitation for the second round was not sent, and no reason was given," and avoid guesses about why it happened.

For applicants in a hiring process, a similar timeline is still useful. Note any change in how the process moves after the concern was raised, including delays, new steps, or different people being added to the loop. Write down who asked for each change and what reason was given at the time, because a reason given later can be hard to tie back to the record.

For related recordkeeping, see hiring decision notes and recruiting records checks.

Under Wisconsin's annotations, sexual harassment may not require a hostile work environment

The annotations on the Wisconsin Legislature's page for this section say:

> "Unwelcome physical contact of a sexual nature and unwelcome verbal conduct or physical conduct of a sexual nature may constitute sexual harassment, even when they do not create a hostile work environment."

That sentence covers two kinds of conduct: unwelcome physical contact of a sexual nature, and unwelcome verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature. The word "unwelcome" appears in both. The sentence does not say how many incidents are needed, and it does not say that a single incident is enough in every case.

This matters in hiring and onboarding because the instinct in a screening call or an interview can be to ask whether the problem was "serious" or "ongoing" before you take it seriously. That question can screen out a real concern. A better first step is to get the facts: what was said or done, by whom, when, and where, whether anyone else was present, and whether the person made clear to the other person that the conduct was unwelcome. Those facts are what the people who review the matter will need.

Keep the scope of this quote in mind. It is about sexual harassment under Wisconsin's annotations. It does not tell you how to assess other kinds of harassment, and it does not tell you how any other state treats conduct that falls short of a hostile work environment. If the concern involves something other than sexual conduct, you still have to gather the facts, but you cannot borrow this sentence as the answer.

Interviews raise a particular version of this problem. An applicant may describe something that happened at a previous job, sometimes in a few sentences and sometimes in more detail than you expected. Write down what they say, using their words where you can. Do not interrogate them about whether it "counts," and do not tell them they may have overreacted. A simple response works well: "Thank you for telling me. I want to make sure the right people hear about this." That line is accurate, and it does not promise anything you cannot deliver.

If the concern involves the person conducting the interview, tell the applicant that the concern will be passed to someone else who can handle it, and step out of decisions about that applicant until it has been reviewed. You should not be the person who weighs the complaint against the applicant's qualifications.

The annotations say that the definition of "sexual harassment" "is broad enough to include battery, when the tort was pled as an unlawful touching, not a discriminatory act."

Wisconsin's annotations also address a second point. They describe the relevant rule this way:

> "Common-law torts recognized before the adoption of the Wisconsin Fair Employment Act (WFEA), if properly pled, are not barred by the WFEA although the complained of act may fit a definition of discriminatory behavior under the WFEA."

The annotation describes how Wisconsin's law treats those claims, so do not extend it to any other state or to every situation.

For a recruiter or interviewer, the practical point is narrow. You are not the person who decides which label applies. What you can do is avoid closing the door on the concern because of a label. A few habits help:

  • Listen for the facts, not the label. An applicant may describe a problem in everyday words rather than legal ones, such as "he kept touching my arm" or "she kept bringing it up after I said no." Capture those words as they were said.
  • Do not correct the label. Avoid statements like "that's not harassment" or "that's a legal question, not ours." Those are conclusions you are not in a position to make at the screening stage.
  • Route the whole concern. If the facts include both conduct and a change that followed a complaint, send both parts to the same place rather than splitting them between two people who may not compare notes.
  • Note how the person described the concern. If they used the word "retaliation," "harassment," "discrimination," or something else, record that word in quotation marks, since it tells the reviewer how the person understands what happened.

Illustrative example: conduct and a delayed interview

An applicant reports unwelcome touching during an interview. The next interview is then delayed. Record the reported conduct, the pending interview, who changed it, and the reason given. Pass both the conduct and the process change to HR or counsel without deciding whether either is unlawful.

Practical steps after the conversation

The steps below are practical habits, not legal requirements, and they are meant to be used alongside your organization's own process.

  1. Listen without interrupting. Let the person finish. Stay calm, and do not argue about whether the conduct counts. Your tone in the first minute can shape whether the person keeps talking.

  2. Thank them for raising it. A short acknowledgment is enough. It signals that you heard the concern without committing to anything.

  3. Do not promise an outcome. Avoid saying that the person will get the job, that a manager will be dealt with, or that nothing will change for their offer. You do not know those things yet, and a promise you cannot keep can create a second problem.

  4. Write notes right after the conversation. Record names, dates, places, exact words where you can, witnesses, and any documents or messages the person mentioned. Mark clearly what the person said and what you observed yourself. Keep your opinions about whether the person is credible out of the notes.

  5. Ask before moving anything forward. If a pending step could reasonably be seen as connected to the concern, such as an offer, a start date, a schedule, or an assignment, ask HR or counsel before it moves forward. Do not make that call alone, and record that you asked and when.

  6. Say what happens next. Tell the person who will contact them, roughly what the next step is, and that you will pass the concern along. Do not invent a timeline you cannot verify. If you do not know when they will hear back, say so.

  7. Keep the notes where the complaint process can see them. Notes that stay in a personal file may not reach the people who need them. Ask how your organization wants concerns recorded, and follow that process.

  8. Do not investigate on your own. It can be tempting to ask coworkers what they remember or to check a colleague's account before anyone else is involved. Asking questions informally can change what people remember and can alert the person named in the concern. Ask the complaint process who should look into it, and let them decide how to proceed.

If you are unsure what your state's rules require, or whether a particular practice falls under them, ask your employment counsel before you respond in detail. The person who raised the concern is trusting you to take it seriously, and getting the process right is the most useful way to do that.

Today, identify who handles complaints in your organization and confirm where to record a concern before your next screening call or new-hire check-in.

What should you do after you hear the concern?

Listen, record the facts in the person's own words, explain the next step, and route the concern through your organization's complaint process.

Does timing alone establish retaliation?

No, timing alone does not establish retaliation. Keep the sequence and the recorded reasons available for review.

No, leave that decision to the people reviewing the concern. Preserve the person's description without correcting it.

Sources