Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

EEOC examples: 4 cases on hiring, promotion and pay

EEOC national origin examples cover promotion, discipline, seasonal hiring and pay; review job-related reasons and consistent treatment before deciding.

Key takeaways

  • Set job-related promotion criteria before reviewing applicants.
  • Compare attendance records before issuing a reprimand.
  • Give seasonal applicants the same screening and job information.
  • Document reasons for pay differences and deductions.

The person who picks someone for a promotion is often the owner, the shift lead or the office manager. That same person may also write reprimands, run the seasonal hiring push and approve pay changes. Each of those calls can raise questions about national origin discrimination, which is covered by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) explains the issue in its enforcement guidance on national origin discrimination.

This post draws on scenarios from that guidance, one for each decision type: promotion, discipline, seasonal hiring and pay. For each one, it looks at the facts the guidance gives and turns them into checks a recruiter or hiring manager can run before a decision goes out. The scenarios are brief, so read the guidance for full context. This is a plain-language summary, not advice about your own business, and the rules that apply to you may depend on where you operate.

Does national origin discrimination only matter at hiring and firing?

No. The guidance makes clear that discrimination can show up in the everyday terms of a job. In its discussion of trafficking cases, it says: "In trafficking cases, it is not unusual for employers to subject trafficked workers to harassment, job segregation, unequal pay, or unreasonable paycheck deductions, all of which are discriminatory if motivated by Title VII-protected status." The same question applies to a promotion, a write-up or a pay rate.

The guidance also notes that trafficking cases "may involve multiple or intersecting bases of discrimination, such as national origin and sex." A problem rarely has only one cause. A worker passed over for a supervisor role may also be the only woman on a crew. When you review a decision, look at the whole pattern, not only the single reason you wrote down.

The practical lesson is that any decision about a worker's job, pay, schedule or discipline may later have to be explained. The question is not whether you meant to treat someone differently. It is whether the reasons you can show are the real reasons, and whether the same reasons would apply to anyone else in the same position.

Can a promotion decision create a national origin problem?

The guidance introduces a promotion decision; the practical point here is process. It describes a case in which "Joseph applies for a promotion to a position in which he would supervise about 25 people performing work similar to his own." Use this setup to review how you choose someone for supervision.

An impression is a starting point, not a record. A manager who says "I know he can handle it" may be right, but if the only support is that the manager likes the applicant, the decision is hard to explain later. Decide what the job needs before you look at who is applying. If the role is to supervise people doing similar work, the skills that matter are concrete: scheduling, training, safety, customer handling and giving direction without creating friction on the crew. Write them down, and use the same list for every applicant, including the quieter or newer people you have not thought about. An interview scorecard can help organize that comparison.

Start with a short description of the supervisor role that covers the duties the person will actually perform, the kind of work the crew does, and the decisions the supervisor makes alone, such as approving time off or assigning shifts. Then ask each finalist the same questions and take notes at the time. If you ask one applicant about leading a team and skip that question with another, you have created a difference you will have to explain.

Finally, look at recent promotions and who was passed over. Make a simple list and ask whether the stated criteria explain the result. If people from one background keep getting promoted while everyone else hears they are not ready, the criteria may be applied unevenly even if no one intended it. Give the applicant a plain, job-related reason in writing. That is easier to defend, easier for the employee to understand, and gives a passed-over worker something to work toward.

What should a manager check before a written reprimand?

Before a written reprimand goes into a file, confirm that the same rule is enforced the same way for everyone in the same position. The guidance describes a tardiness case: "Da'uud, a Somali employee, is given a written reprimand for tardiness after arriving to work at least 15 minutes late on three occasions." The useful question is whether other employees with the same attendance record received the same response.

Attendance discipline can be handled inconsistently. A manager may be strict with one employee because that person was already on the manager's mind, and let the same lateness slide for someone well liked. Over time the record can show the rule meant different things to different people. A reprimand that looks routine alone can look very different next to a list of coworkers who were late just as often and were never written up.

Pull the attendance record for the employee and for a few coworkers in similar roles over the same period. Compare the number of late arrivals, how late they were and what happened next. If the reprimand is out of line with how others were treated, fix the inconsistency before issuing it. If there is a real difference, such as an employee who has missed far more shifts than anyone else, write that difference down and explain why it matters to the job.

Then check the written policy. If it describes consequences for lateness, follow it and quote it in the reprimand. Either write the rule down for everyone before enforcing it against one person, or handle the matter the way the rest of the staff has been handled.

Record each late arrival when it happens, with the date, the scheduled start time and the actual arrival time. Keep the notes factual, and leave out comments about the person's background, accent, language, religion or family. Those comments can turn an ordinary attendance file into evidence that the discipline was about something other than attendance.

Give the employee a chance to respond before the reprimand is final. Listen to any reason they give, such as a transit problem, a child care gap or a medical appointment, and record what they said and whether you took it into account. You do not have to accept every explanation, but a manager who listens and writes down the answer is far better placed than one who issues the reprimand and moves on.

Finally, read the reprimand as a record someone may review later. Would the language make sense to an outside reviewer who has never met either of you? If not, rewrite it until it states the rule, the facts and the consequence in plain terms.

How can seasonal hiring go wrong?

Seasonal hiring goes wrong when the people recruiting and selecting workers move quickly and rely on networks they already know. A seasonal business may need many people in a few weeks, and the easiest path is to call familiar contacts, take the first applicants who respond and hire people recommended by someone already on the crew. Each shortcut can be reasonable on its own. Together, they can produce a workforce that looks very different from the pool of people who could do the job.

The guidance describes seasonal farm hiring: "Veggie Farms hires 75 African American and 145 Mexican seasonal farmworkers for the growing season." The sentence groups the hires by race and national origin, so a reviewer would ask how those workers were found, how they were screened and whether the same process was open to everyone who could do the work.

Start by looking at where your applicants come from. Post openings in more than one place and record where each applicant heard about the job. If every applicant comes through the same referral chain, the pipeline may favor people who share the background of whoever is doing the referring. That is not a reason to refuse referrals, but it is a reason to check whether the rest of the community has a fair chance to apply.

Next, use the same screening for every applicant: the same questions, the same skills check if you have one, and the same pass criteria. Write the job requirements down before the season starts, and check each applicant against those requirements and nothing else.

Tell every applicant the same things about pay, hours, housing if you provide it, transportation and the length of the season. Someone told one thing on the phone and another at the job site may feel misled, and that feeling can become a complaint even when no one meant to mislead them.

Keep counts of applicants, interviews and offers, and review them before finalizing the season's hires. If one group is rarely interviewed or offered work, find out why before the season begins. Counting people by national origin can be sensitive, so ask an employment attorney which records to keep and how to use them.

Finally, give seasonal workers the same basics as year-round staff: the same safety training, the same description of duties and the same explanation of how to raise a concern. A seasonal worker who has a problem and does not know who to talk to is more likely to see it grow.

What does unequal pay look like at its worst?

The guidance describes a severe case involving pay, housing restrictions and threats. It is still worth reading, because it shows where unequal pay can lead when other forms of control are added. The guidance describes a worker who "receives $5 a day for her work, is forced to live in a cramped and unsanitary dormitory on Poultry Plant's property, is prohibited from leaving without supervision, and is under threat of deportation." The pay figure is extreme, and the other facts go well beyond pay. An employer should not treat pay, housing, movement and threats as separate issues. When they appear together, the combination is a serious warning.

Most pay questions at a small firm look nothing like that. They more often involve two people doing similar work at different rates, a raise that went to one worker and not another, or a deduction that appears on one paycheck but not another.

Start by comparing pay for people doing similar work. List each role, the people in it, their rates and the reasons for any difference, such as experience, shift, certification or a documented change in duties. If you cannot give a job-related reason for a gap, close it or be ready to explain it. A gap nobody intended can still look intentional if no one wrote down why it exists. Use the pay equity checks when reviewing a proposed rate.

Next, review deductions. Many small firms deduct for housing, tools, uniforms, meals or transportation. Each deduction should have a written basis, apply to everyone it is meant to cover and appear on the pay record in a way the worker can understand. If one worker is charged for housing and another in the same arrangement is not, find out why before the next pay period.

Then check whether any pay change followed a complaint, a request for leave, a question about wages or a conversation about language or background. A delayed raise or a cut in hours that came right after a complaint may have an unrelated explanation, but the timing will draw attention. Write down the business reason for each change when it is made, not after someone asks.

Finally, make sure every worker can understand how their pay is calculated. Show the rate, hours, deductions and net amount on each pay statement. If a worker's first language is not the language of the paperwork, explain the statement in a language they understand and keep a record that you did.

Illustrative example: compare attendance records

Only the employee received a written reprimand. Compare their roles, the attendance policy and any recorded differences before finalizing the reprimand. If the records do not explain the different responses, review the inconsistency first.

Today, choose a pending decision and write down its job-related reason, the comparison records and who will review it before it goes out.

What should a small firm do before a decision goes out?

Put a short review step in front of every promotion, reprimand, seasonal hire and pay change. The decision-maker should answer a few questions in writing: what job-related reason supports the decision, who else was in a similar position, what records support the answer, and who else reviewed it before it was final. A few sentences each is enough to show that someone thought the decision through and can explain it later.

Who should review the decision?

The review works best when the second reader did not make the decision. That person does not need to be a lawyer or an HR specialist. They need to ask the same questions and write down the answers. An outsider often spots a pattern the decision-maker missed, such as a shift that has never had a promotion or a crew whose pay has not moved in a long time.

How should a firm review staffing agencies?

Treat staffing agencies and temporary labor providers as part of your hiring process. Ask them the same questions you would ask yourself, find out what criteria they use before they send applicants, and tell them which job-related criteria matter to you. If they screen out applicants in ways you would not, the results will still reflect on your business.

What records should a small firm keep?

Keep the records that show how each decision was made: the job description, interview notes, the attendance or performance record behind a reprimand, the pay history and the reason for any deduction. Store them where they can be found later, and keep factual notes separate from opinions. If you are asked about a decision long after it was made, the record should answer the question without relying on anyone's memory.

When should a small firm seek advice?

If a decision is in front of you or a worker has raised a concern, talk to an employment attorney in your state before you act. Read the full scenarios in the EEOC's national origin guidance for context. A short conversation before a decision usually costs less than a long one after a complaint.

Related guides: EEOC ADA examples: 5 essential duty standards · EEOC rules: keep hiring records 1 year, payroll 3 years · State hiring and pay rules: 3 time limits to check.

Sources