The four figures to check in a hiring dispute are a 15-employee federal size threshold, a 300-day Wisconsin filing window, and two state penalty amounts. They are short and easy to quote, which is why they get quoted wrong. A threshold from a federal guide gets applied to a state employer, or a filing window from one state gets copied into a file about a company in another. Either mistake can send a recruiter or team lead in the wrong direction before anyone has read the actual text.
Key takeaways
- Count employees on purpose, and check how the statute defines "employee" before you rely on the 15-employee threshold.
- Count the 300-day window back from the filing date, using payment dates from payroll records.
- Read the full Wisconsin and Maine sections before you answer an agency or a worker.
- Route agency contact through one named legal reviewer, and keep a log of each request.
This post walks through four figures from official sources: one federal size threshold, one filing window, and two penalty amounts from two state laws. Each figure links to its source page. For each one, I explain what the page says, what it leaves out, and what to check before you rely on it.
Does the federal disability law reach a team of our size?
The EEOC's small business primer says the Americans with Disabilities Act applies to all businesses with 15 or more employees. Check this number first when a dispute involves a disability-related question under federal law. If your team is below 15, the federal act's employment rules may not reach the decision, and the next question is whether a state law does.
The same primer describes its own audience. It says the guide is "intended primarily for businesses with 15 to 100 employees and smaller businesses expecting to expand to have at least 15 employees in the near future." It does not add a second threshold. Its reference to expected growth describes the guide's readers.
Many small-team disputes go wrong at the headcount stage, so count on purpose. Check how the statute counts employees, including any period it uses, before relying on a headcount from one payroll date. Then list everyone else who worked for you: part-time staff, seasonal workers, people on leave, and workers supplied through an agency. Do not assume each group counts the same way. A statute defines "employee" in its own terms, so a federal count does not settle a state question. Before you accept any number, read the definitions section of the statute you are checking.
Staffing teams face an extra problem, because a placed worker can be hard to assign to a single employer. How a placed worker is counted depends on the statute and the facts of the placement, so ask counsel before assuming an answer either way. Keep a short written note of how you reached your count, including the dates you used and the sources you read. If the number sits close to the line, that note is the first thing a lawyer will want to see.
Do not treat 15 as a finish line. Other laws set their own thresholds, and a team below 15 may still face state rules. The better question is which law, with which definition of employee, applies to this decision.
How far back can a compensation discrimination claim reach in Wisconsin?
In Wisconsin, a note on the statute's page describes a compensation discrimination claim as actionable if the employee received a payment within the 300 days before the complaint was filed. The note quotes a 1996 decision that "clearly held that compensation discrimination is actionable if an employee received payment within the 300-day period before filing the employee's complaint pursuant to a discriminatory compensation decision." That wording comes from the note, not the operative statute text, so read the full statute and the cited case before relying on it in a formal filing.
The word that does the most work is "payment." The claim ties to a payment received inside the window, made under a discriminatory compensation decision. The date money changed hands can matter as much as the date someone approved the pay decision. A decision made well before the window can still produce a payment inside it. A starting salary set months earlier may still be paid during the 300 days, and each such payment is a date to check.
To run the count, start from the filing date and count back 300 days. Pull the payroll records showing every payment to the employee, with its date and amount. Mark which payments fall inside the window, and note the decision behind each one. Count days rather than rounding to whole months, because rounding can move a payment across the line. A spreadsheet date formula is more reliable than a calendar guess.
Illustrative example: counting the 300-day window
Suppose an employee files a complaint on day 0. Counting back 300 days marks the first day of the window. A payment dated on or after that day falls inside it. A payment dated 5 days before that day falls outside it. Put both payments in the file with the decision behind each one, so the count can be checked line by line.
The 300-day figure applies to Wisconsin. Other states set their own periods, and federal deadlines follow their own rules. Do not carry 300 days into a dispute elsewhere. Your lawyer will confirm which period applies and which date counts as the filing date. For how filing clocks differ by state, see hiring claim filing deadlines in several states.
For team leads, a pay question raised by a worker should prompt an immediate check of payment dates, not only the approval history. Approval records show when someone decided. Payroll records show when money moved. The Wisconsin note is about the second, so the payroll file is the place to start.
What fine applies to interfering with a Wisconsin investigation?
Under Wisconsin section 111.31, a person who willfully interferes with the commission's work can be fined not more than $500, sent to county jail for not more than one year, or both. The statute's text covers anyone who willfully assaults, resists, prevents, impedes, or interferes with the commission or its agents while they perform duties under the subchapter. The penalty reads "a fine of not more than $500 or by imprisonment in the county jail for not more than one year, or both."
The section is about obstruction, not hiring. It penalizes interference with an agency's work and does not describe how to make or defend a hiring choice. Its relevance is narrower. Once an agency looks into a complaint, how your team responds to that agency becomes a legal matter of its own, separate from the original decision.
"Willfully" is the word to focus on. The statute turns on deliberate conduct, which is different from a mistake, a delay, or a misunderstanding. Whether a particular act counts as willful interference is a legal judgment that depends on facts only counsel can weigh. If you are unsure whether something you did or failed to do could be read as interference, take that question to counsel before answering the agency.
The statute's "or both" means a person can face the fine and the jail term together. Managers often remember the fine and forget the jail term, so state both plainly. One practical lesson follows: route agency contact through a legal reviewer rather than handling it informally. Route requests from an investigating agency through one named person, and keep a log of what was requested, when it arrived, and what was sent. Do not alter or delete files that relate to the dispute.
What can an employee collect for a repeat violation in Maine?
For a repeat violation against the same employee, Maine's section 689 provides a civil penalty of $2,000, payable to the affected employee and recovered in a civil action. The section's text says that for a subsequent offense against the same employee, the offender "is subject to a civil penalty of $2,000, payable to the affected employee, to be recovered in a civil action."
The scope is narrow. The provision gives the amount for a subsequent offense against the same employee. It does not give a first-offense figure, so do not fill one in from memory or from another state's rule. Read the full section for first-offense treatment and any conditions attached to the penalty, because a short excerpt can leave out terms that change the answer.
Who collects matters too. The penalty is payable to the affected employee, not to the state, which makes the repeat figure a personal recovery for the worker. A team lead should expect that the worker may be the party pressing the issue, and that questions about what has already happened to that person will come up directly.
Enforcement has more than one route. The same section says "The Department of Labor or the affected employee or employees may enforce this subchapter." A dispute can start with a state labor agency or with a worker directly, so plan for both. A response that works for an agency inquiry may need adjustment when the worker files.
Track prior issues by employee. The "same employee" language means a second violation against someone else does not carry the same figure. A simple record kept by person and by date lets you see quickly whether a new matter involves a repeat against the same individual.
What does a civil action mean for a small employer?
A civil action is a lawsuit brought in court by a private party, rather than a case brought by the state. The Maine penalty is recovered that way, and either the affected employee or the Department of Labor may enforce the subchapter. For a small employer, the penalty figure is only one part of the risk. The cost of defending a case, producing documents, and managing time away from the job can matter as much as the number on the page.
A penalty figure states the amount a successful claim may recover. It says nothing about how likely a claim is to succeed, how long it will take, or what a defense will cost. Keep those questions separate when you talk about exposure, and let counsel estimate the rest.
Because a civil action runs through a court, early decisions matter. Preserve records as soon as a claim is raised, and let counsel decide what to say to the worker. A written response that admits or denies facts too early can shape the case in ways that are hard to undo. Check whether any insurance policy or client contract covers employment claims, and read its notice requirements closely, since a missed notice deadline can matter as much as the merits.
What should we do when a hiring complaint first arrives?
Start by writing down the date you received the complaint, because several of the figures in this post count from dates. Record it alongside the decision records, offers, and payroll entries that relate to it. A clear timeline is one of the most useful things a lawyer can receive in the first week.
Next, confirm which laws may apply. Federal and state rules can both be in play, and each depends on facts such as where the job was located, where the worker was based, and where the company is registered. Ask counsel early instead of assuming the first law you find governs.
Read the primary text, not summaries. For each statute that may apply, read the definitions section, the time limit, and the penalty section in full. A full section can add conditions or exceptions that a shorter excerpt leaves out.
Be careful with written statements. Avoid legal conclusions in email or in a response to a complainant before counsel has reviewed the facts. A short, accurate reply saying the matter is under review is usually safer than a detailed explanation written in a hurry.
Keep a timeline with every relevant date: the decision, the offer, each payment, the complaint, and each response. Counsel uses timelines to check both the headcount date and the filing-window count, so a gap in the timeline is a gap in your defense. For a sheet to record each decision, see Hiring Decision Debrief: Notes to a Recorded Decision.
How do I explain these figures to a hiring manager?
Explain each figure as an answer to one narrow question, because managers often hear a number and assume it settles the whole matter. The 15-employee threshold answers whether a federal disability rule can apply. The 300-day window answers which payments remain in play under Wisconsin's note. The $500 fine and one-year jail term answer what Wisconsin's interference section allows. The $2,000 penalty answers what Maine's section 689 provides for a repeat violation. None of those answers says whether the company did something wrong.
Use plain language. Say "the law applies to employers with 15 or more employees," not "we are covered" or "we are exempt." Say "the window is 300 days before the complaint was filed," and give the exact date that starts it.
Be honest about what is unknown. If the headcount is close, say so and say the count is being checked. If a payment date is missing, say that and name who is pulling it. Managers make better decisions when they know which facts are settled and which are still open.
Keep the conversation on process. Ask what the team needs to collect, who will collect it, and when counsel should see it. Finally, do not let a number become a verdict. A figure can tell you what to check, but it cannot tell you what happened in a particular hiring decision. That work belongs to the people who can see the full file.
Which figure should I check first?
Start with the size threshold, because it decides whether the federal disability rule applies at all. Next check the time window, since it decides which payments and events still count. Read the penalty sections last, because a penalty matters only once you know the claim is within the law's reach.
Keep a one-page reference for the team listing the four figures, each linked to its source page, along with the date the sheet was last checked and the person responsible for the check. Keep it beside the timeline so the figures and the facts are reviewed together.
Verify each figure against its linked page, read the full section, confirm which law applies, and bring your timeline and headcount notes to an employment lawyer before you respond to a complaint. That is the work that turns a quoted number into an answer you can use.
Your next step today: pull the payroll record for any employee tied to an open complaint, and mark each payment against the 300-day window.
Frequently asked questions
Does this post replace an employment lawyer's advice?
No. It explains what each linked official text says and which questions to bring to counsel, but it does not advise on a specific dispute.
Does the Maine $2,000 penalty apply to a first offense?
No. The $2,000 figure is stated for a subsequent offense against the same employee, so read the full section before applying it to any other case.
Does the 300-day window count from the payment date?
No. It counts 300 days back from the date the complaint was filed, and the claim ties to payments received inside that period.