Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

New York background report limits: 4 look-back rules

New York limits how far back a background report can reach, and jobs paying $25,000 a year or more are exempt from those limits.

Key takeaways

  • Check the annual salary first. At $25,000 or more, the four look-back limits do not apply.
  • Check the date of every item against its look-back limit before you use it.
  • Ask no questions about criminal history until a conditional offer has been made.
  • Treat pending cases as open matters, and get counsel's view before you act on one.
  • Ask your screening provider how it applies the 10-year federal bankruptcy note.

Why the rules come first

If you hire in New York, a background report is one of the most useful tools you have. It is also one of the easiest to misuse. Order the wrong check, order it at the wrong moment, or read a result you were not allowed to use, and a hire you were excited about can become a problem for your company. Many recruiters treat the report as a yes-or-no button. In New York it works more like a filter with limits built in. Those limits control what a reporting company may include, and separate timing rules control when you can ask certain questions.

This post covers the parts that matter most when you decide whether to order a report. It walks through four limits on how far back certain records can reach, the $25,000 salary exception that changes how those limits apply, and the timing rules for asking about criminal history. It is written for the people who make the hiring call, not for lawyers, and it is not legal advice. If your company has counsel or an HR compliance team, bring them in before you change your process.

Most of the specifics here come from a consumer guide on New York background checks published by GoodHire, which summarizes state rules. Where I use a rule, I link to the page. Check the current law yourself before you act on any number. A summary is not the statute, and laws change.

The four look-back limits

Under New York law, as GoodHire summarizes it, a consumer reporting agency (the company that compiles a background report) cannot report or keep certain records in its files. The core rule, in plain terms: under New York state law, CRAs cannot report or keep in their files any conviction records, judgments, and paid tax liens more than seven years old, bankruptcies more than 14 years old, judgments that were paid within the last five years, or arrests that did not lead to a conviction (except for pending cases).

— GoodHire, New York Background Checks for Employment

That sentence holds four separate limits. Each one changes what can show up on a report, so it helps to take them one at a time.

1. Convictions, judgments, and paid tax liens older than seven years

The first limit covers three kinds of record: conviction records, judgments, and paid tax liens. The source says a reporting agency cannot report or keep these once they are more than seven years old. A conviction from eight years ago falls outside that limit. A conviction from six years ago is inside it, so the limit does not remove it.

If a report shows an old conviction, judgment, or paid tax lien, check its date before anything else. If the date is outside the seven-year limit, that item should not have been on the report. Do not make a decision based on it, and raise it with the screening provider so the error can be fixed.

2. Bankruptcies older than 14 years

The second limit covers bankruptcies, and its window is longer: 14 years instead of seven. That difference is easy to miss. A reader who has memorized "seven years" might assume every item works the same way, and that assumption will lead to mistakes. Read each limit by its own number. The 14-year figure also comes with a note about federal law, which gets its own section below.

3. Judgments paid within the last five years

The third limit is the one people most often misread. The source lists judgments that were paid within the last five years among the records a reporting agency cannot report or keep. Read that line closely. It names one category of judgment, the kind that was paid within the last five years. Do not assume the rule covers other kinds of judgment.

When a judgment appears on a report, find out two things from the provider: when it was paid, and whether the report shows the paid date at all. A judgment that cannot be reported is not a judgment you should weigh, so the date is the detail that decides whether it belongs in your review.

4. Arrests that did not lead to a conviction

The fourth limit covers arrests. The source says a reporting agency cannot report or keep arrests that did not lead to a conviction, with one exception: pending cases. A case that is still open is handled differently from one that was closed without a conviction.

This is a point where a recruiter can easily go wrong. A pending case is not a conviction. It is an open matter, and the source's exception exists for it. If a report shows a pending case, do not treat it as proof of anything. Ask counsel how your company should handle it, and make the decision on documented criteria rather than on the headline. If the arrest was closed without a conviction, the limit applies, and the item should not be on the report.

Reading a report line by line

A background report is a list of claims, and each line should be checked before anyone uses it. Work through the report the same way every time, using a background report checklist. For each item, write down four things: the type of record, the date shown, the status as the report presents it, and the limit that applies to that type of record.

Once you have those four details, the decision is usually clear. If the item is outside its limit, set it aside and tell the provider. If the item falls inside its limit, it may be reviewed, but the limit alone does not decide what your company does with it. If the item is a pending arrest or case, flag it for counsel rather than deciding on your own.

If you cannot find a date on the report, do not guess. Ask the provider for the missing detail before you make any decision. A line with no date cannot be checked against a seven-year, 14-year, or five-year limit, and an unchecked line is a risk, not a fact. Keep your notes with the file so the next reviewer can follow the same steps.

Illustrative example: an old conviction on a report

Suppose a report lists a conviction dated 15 years ago. Check the date first. Conviction records more than seven years old cannot be reported, so that item should not be on the report. Do not use it in the decision, and tell the screening provider so the error can be fixed. The same report shows an arrest with the case still open. That is a pending case, so send it to counsel instead of deciding on it alone.

The $25,000 salary exception

The source also gives one exception to all four limits:

> "These restrictions do not apply if the job in question has an annual salary of $25,000 or more."

In plain terms, the four look-back limits described above do not apply to a job with an annual salary of $25,000 or more. For a job below that figure, they do. This makes the salary number the first thing to check on any hire. It decides whether the limits frame the whole report.

Because so much depends on one figure, treat it with care:

  • Use the annual salary. The quote is written in annual terms. If a role is paid hourly, part-time, or with variable pay, ask counsel how your company should turn that into an annual figure and write down the math.
  • Recheck when the offer changes. A salary negotiated after the first interview can move a role across the line. Recheck the figure at the offer stage, not just when the job was posted.
  • Do not set a figure to get a result. Structuring a pay figure so a role lands under or over $25,000 is hard to defend. Set the pay for the job, then apply the rule.
  • Apply the same figure to everyone in the role. If two people are hired into the same job, the same salary figure should decide the same rule for both.

One more caution. The salary exception is tied to the four look-back limits. It is not a general permission to order everything, early, for every job. The timing rules for criminal history are a separate point, and the exception does not change them. Keep the two questions apart when you plan a hire.

When you can ask about criminal history

The timing rule is probably the most practical part of this post, because it governs what you may say in a screening call or on an application form. The source states the rule plainly: employers are prohibited from conducting criminal background checks or asking questions about a person's criminal history until a conditional offer of employment has been made.

The rule has two parts, and both matter. First, you may not run a criminal background check before a conditional offer. Second, you may not ask questions about a person's criminal history before that point. The second part catches more people than the first. A recruiter who asks "any convictions I should know about?" during a phone screen has asked a question about criminal history, even if no check has been ordered.

A workable sequence looks like this:

  • The job posting and the application do not ask about criminal history.
  • Phone screens and interviews stay on skills, experience, and availability.
  • A conditional offer is made.
  • Only after the conditional offer does the company order a criminal history check.

The same source adds a note on practice. It says some employers may choose to wait to conduct all background checks, and that New York City Human Rights Local Law 4 advises against this practice. Read that carefully. The quoted rule is about criminal history, and the note is about waiting on background checks in general. The point for a hiring team is that waiting is not a neutral default. If your company is considering holding every check until the last minute, talk with counsel first, and do not assume that the later timing is the safer one.

If you hire outside New York City, ask counsel which local rules reach your location before you set your process. For timing rules elsewhere, see conviction timing rules.

Bankruptcies and the federal note

The GoodHire summary includes a line that is easy to skip past:

> "Bankruptcies more than 14 years old (note that federal law is stricter, limiting bankruptcy information to 10 years)"

The line gives two numbers. The New York figure is 14 years. The note says federal law is stricter and limits bankruptcy information to 10 years. The state number is not the whole picture. A bankruptcy that is 12 years old falls inside the New York 14-year window, but the note says federal law limits bankruptcy information to 10 years, so the 14-year figure is not permission to report anything older than that. Ask your screening provider how it applies both rules, and ask counsel to confirm.

This is a good example of why a summary should send you to the underlying rules, not replace them. A single number on a page can be right for one question and wrong for the one you are actually asking.

The 30-day written statement

The same page includes a deadline:

> "The employer or licensing agency must provide the written statement within 30 days of the request."

Deadlines are where hiring teams lose track. This line sets a 30-day period that starts with a request. So do not assume it covers every report or every decision.

If a report may lead to a decision about an applicant, ask counsel which written statement applies, who must provide it, and when the 30 days begins. Then put the date on a calendar that the recruiter and the hiring manager can both see. A missed deadline is easy to avoid, and hard to explain afterward.

Common mistakes to avoid

Most problems in this area come from a small set of habits. Watch for these in your own team:

  • Treating every listed item as usable. A report that shows an item is not proof that the item is allowed. Check the date and the type of record first.
  • Asking about criminal history "just to be sure." A casual question in a phone screen is still a question about criminal history, and the timing rule applies to it.
  • Assuming the salary exception switches off every rule. The exception is tied to the four look-back limits, and the timing rule still applies.
  • Skipping the federal bankruptcy note. The 14-year figure is easy to remember, and the note is easy to forget.
  • Letting each hiring manager set their own process. Inconsistent practice creates more risk than any single rule, and it makes it hard to show what your company did and why.

A practical checklist before you order

Use this list as a starting point, then adapt it with counsel.

  1. Write down the annual salary for the role. Note how you calculated it if the pay is hourly, part-time, or variable.
  2. Check whether the $25,000 exception applies. If the figure is $25,000 or more, the four look-back limits do not apply. If it is below, they do.
  3. Remove criminal history questions from the application and the screening script.
  4. Make a conditional offer before you order a criminal history check.
  5. Read every report against the four limits. Check the date of each conviction, judgment, paid tax lien, bankruptcy, and arrest.
  6. Treat pending cases as open matters. Get counsel's view before you act on one.
  7. Confirm how the provider applies the federal bankruptcy note.
  8. Calendar the 30-day written statement deadline when a report may lead to a decision, after confirming with counsel what it covers.
  9. Keep a written record. Use a hiring decision debrief and note the salary figure, the offer date, the report date, and any decision made from the report.
  10. Use one process for every hiring manager. A shared process is easier to defend than a set of personal habits.

What to do next

New York's rules on background reports are specific, and several of them turn on a single number or a single date. That is why the best habit is slow reading. Check the salary before you order. Check the offer before you ask about criminal history. Check the date on every item in the report against the limit that applies to it. When a rule or deadline is unclear, ask counsel instead of guessing.

The four look-back limits describe how far back certain records can reach, and the salary exception sets the line for which jobs those limits cover. The timing rules control the order in which you ask. None of these rules asks you to be less careful. They ask you to be more deliberate, and to decide with the right record in front of you.

Start today by reviewing your current hiring steps against the checklist above.

Frequently asked questions

Does the $25,000 exception switch off every New York rule?

No, it covers only the four look-back limits, and the timing rule for criminal history still applies.

What should I do if a report shows an item past its limit?

Do not base a decision on it. Raise it with the screening provider so the error can be fixed.

Sources