The answer turns on two points: who fills the Form I-9, and whether your company is the employer in practice. A contractor's employees are the contractor's responsibility — unless your company is the real employer in practice.
- First point: If you contract with a company to do work, say renovations, you do not complete Form I-9 for that company's employees — the contractor company is their employer.
- Second point: Weigh who behaves as the employer in practice, not just the label on the contract. If your company directs the daily work, sets hours, and controls the crew, the Form I-9 duty is yours.
- Practical test: Ask who hired the person, whose payroll they land on, and who can fire them. If all answers point to the contractor, note that conclusion in your file.
- State duties run separately: State notice rules, acknowledgment records, and complaint procedures (in Wisconsin and Minnesota, for instance) are each set by that state's own rules and must be checked separately against that state's text.
- If uncertain: Read the agency's published guidance, consider consulting counsel, and document your reasoning in a short file for each contractor engagement.
What the question really is
You brought in a contractor's crew. They are on your site. They use your badge system. They work under your schedule. Now someone asks: do you owe a Form I-9 for each of them?
The answer turns on two points, and the first comes from the same page in the Handbook for Employers. The first point is about who fills the form. The second point is about who the employer actually is.
USCIS poses the question directly: "Do I need to complete Form I-9 for independent contractors or their employees?" The page then answers it through a plain scenario. Let us work through both points and the situations where they matter.
The first USCIS point: a contractor's people are the contractor's responsibility
The clearest line USCIS draws is this. If you contract with a construction company to do renovations on your building, you do not have to complete Form I-9 for that company's employees. That wording comes from USCIS's Handbook for Employers page on common Form I-9 questions.
Read that carefully. The construction company is a separate business. Its workers signed with that company, not with you. The construction company is the employer in the ordinary sense, so it carries the Form I-9 duty for its own people.
This first point settles the easy case: a genuinely independent contractor with its own payroll, its own hires, and its own records. You order a service. They staff it. They verify work authorization. You do not touch their forms.
The practical test you can run in a meeting is simple. Ask who hired the person. Ask whose payroll the person lands on. Ask who can fire them. If the answers all point to the contractor company, the first point is on your side and your file stays clean.
Where the first point stops helping is when the crew looks independent on paper but behaves like your staff. That is the second point.
The second USCIS point: the employer you are matters more than the label on the contract
The agency's focus is on who actually employs the worker in practice.
This is the point recruiters feel first. You brought the crew in. You direct their daily work. You set the hours. You send them home. A careful reviewer will look past the contract's title page and ask who behaves like the employer.
The second USCIS point therefore works as a mirror. Before you decide the first point covers you, hold the arrangement up against the reality of control, pay, and direction. Weigh whether your company behaves as the employer before relying on the first point. Your company owes the form.
Two readings follow, and they pull in opposite directions.
Reading one: the contractor is genuinely separate
Under this reading, the contractor company is a real employer of its own people. It hires, pays, supervises, and disciplines. Your company buys a finished service. The first USCIS point applies without strain, and no Form I-9 sits in your file for those workers.
This is the normal setup for renovation work, janitorial contracts, and similar arrangements where a business delivers a defined service with its own crew.
Reading two: the contractor label is thin
Under this reading, your company does the hiring decisions, sets the shifts, and treats the crew as your own for daily operations. The contract says independent. The working relationship says otherwise.
Here the second USCIS point is the one to weigh. If the employment relationship points at your company, so does the Form I-9 duty. The paperwork should match reality, because a mismatch is exactly what an audit notices.
The honest answer on this reading is that the line between the two readings can be blurry in practice. USCIS gives you the two points and a renovation example, not a full test for every staffing pattern. If your arrangement sits between the readings, seek qualified legal advice before you file anything either way.
A quick side-by-side of the two points
Use this table to see where each point applies before you read the detail below.
| Point | Who completes Form I-9 | Typical arrangement | Your file |
|---|---|---|---|
| First point | The contractor company | Independent contractor with its own employees | No I-9 for their staff |
| Second point | Your company | Your company is the real employer | I-9 required for those workers |
Working the two points through real situations
Once you hold both points in view, most day-to-day cases sort themselves out. Let us walk the ones a hiring manager actually meets.
A renovation contractor sends its own tradespeople. The contractor company hired them, pays them, and supervises the job. The first USCIS point applies directly. Your company completes no Form I-9 for those workers.
A staffing agency supplies temporary workers. The agency hired the workers and runs their payroll. The agency's role in the arrangement needs to be verified against how the work is actually run before you settle on who completes the form.
A subcontractor's crew works under your site foreman all day. Your foreman directs every task. Hours, breaks, and reassignments come from your side. Now the second point is doing the work. Look hard at who behaves as the employer before you assume the first point protects you.
An independent consultant brings a colleague along. The consultant engaged the colleague, and the colleague is not on your payroll. The consultant's side of the line carries the form duty.
A contractor's employee moves onto your payroll later. Once you hire that worker yourself, treat the Form I-9 as your own new-hire obligation. The second point takes over from the first.
The pattern in every case is the same. Start with the first point as your default answer. Then check it against the second point and the real working relationship. Where the two readings diverge, write down both readings and the facts behind each.
What the first point does not decide for you
The two USCIS points answer the federal Form I-9 question. They do not settle every other duty that sits around a contractor's crew, and it helps to know where the boundary is.
Several state and local rules run on their own tracks. They can require notices, records, or complaint procedures that have nothing to do with Form I-9. Those duties attach to whichever party the state rule names, and that party may be you even when USCIS points at the contractor.
Wisconsin's statute at 103.025 shows how a state scheme builds its own definitions and enforcement. 103.06(2)(b) provides power to "Receive and investigate complaints alleging violations of the requirements specified in sub."
Read plainly, Wisconsin sets out state-level requirements that point to rules and to a complaint process of their own. None of that changes who completes Form I-9. It is a separate duty that may land on you regardless of the USCIS answer.
Minnesota shows a different shape.
So the two USCIS points sit inside a wider box. They tell you about one federal form. State notice rules and complaint procedures sit beside it. Check the rules in your own state separately, and treat the USCIS answer as the Form I-9 answer only.
A practical sequence for your next contractor engagement
Here is a working order of steps. Run it before the crew arrives, not after.
- Identify the employer. Ask who signed each worker, who runs payroll, and who can end the assignment. Write the answers down while the contract is fresh.
- Apply the first point. If the contractor is genuinely the employer, note in your file that no Form I-9 is owed for its staff, and record the reasoning.
- Stress-test with the second point. Compare the contract language with how your site actually directs the work. If your company behaves as the employer, treat the duty as yours.
- Check state duties separately. Notice rules, acknowledgment records, and complaint procedures are their own obligations. Each state sets its own notice, acknowledgment, and complaint requirements, so confirm them against that state's statute.
- Fix the arrangement if the two readings conflict. If the paperwork says independent but the daily reality says otherwise, change one of them before an audit chooses for you.
This sequence keeps the two USCIS points in their proper role. They decide the federal form question. Everything else in the box gets its own check.
Documentation that keeps your answer defensible
An answer to the Form I-9 question is only as good as the record behind it. Build a short file for each contractor engagement.
Start with the contract itself. Keep the scope page and the section that describes who supervises the work. Then add a brief note from your meeting: who hires, who pays, who directs daily tasks, who can end the assignment.
If the conclusion is that no Form I-9 is owed under the first point, say so in the file in plain words and name the arrangement you reviewed. If the conclusion is that your company is the employer under the second point, complete the forms the way you would for any hire.
Keep any state notices and signed acknowledgments in the same file. Wisconsin's complaint procedure and Minnesota's signed acknowledgment rule both show that a state may ask for paper of its own. Holding it beside your federal reasoning makes the whole picture easy to show later.
Related guides: Check a green card or EAD on Form I-9 in 3 steps · Form I-9 errors after hire: 3 correction methods · 2 documents an F-1 student shows for on-campus Form I-9.
Questions a hiring manager asks in the first week
Do I complete Form I-9 for a contractor's own employees? Not when the contractor is the employer of those people. The contractor company handles the forms for its own staff.
What if the crew works on my site under my supervisors? Then take a hard look at the second point. If your company is the real employer in practice, the duty follows you.
Your file should record that reasoning.
Where does the renovation example fit? It is USCIS's own illustration of the first point. You contract a company to do the work, and that company completes the forms for its employees.
Do state rules follow the federal answer? They run separately. A state may require its own notice, record, or complaint procedure regardless of who owes Form I-9.
What if I cannot tell which reading applies? Seek qualified legal advice before you decide. One clear answer beats a guess you cannot support later.
Does the answer change mid-contract? It can. Once you are hiring that worker onto your own payroll, treat the Form I-9 as your new-hire obligation.
Should I collect anything from the contractor anyway? Ask the contractor for a copy of its own I-9 records for those workers if you want proof they handled it, and keep the contract, your meeting notes, and any state notices together in your own file. A short, dated file explains your reasoning without effort later.
Bringing the two points together
The first point comes from one USCIS page, and the two readings work as a pair. The first point tells you the default: a contractor's employees are the contractor's responsibility, and the renovation example shows it plainly. The second point tells you when the default breaks, when your company is the real employer behind the contract title.
Run the first point first, because it is the clean answer for genuinely independent crews. Then hold the arrangement against the second point and the way work actually happens on your site. Where the readings agree, your file is simple. Where they disagree, the second point wins.
Keep state duties in their own lane. Wisconsin's rules-based requirements and complaint procedure, and Minnesota's signed acknowledgment record, are separate obligations that do not follow the Form I-9 answer. Check them against your own state's text.
Do the whole check before the first shift, not after. Two points, one file, and a clear record are all you need to answer the question with confidence.