Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Arizona knowingly employ rule: 3 defined terms to check

Arizona's knowingly employ rule rests on three defined terms: knowingly employ an unauthorized alien, unauthorized alien, and employee. The first term points to federal law, so keep that federal section in the same file as the state definitions. The other two terms, unauthorized alien and employee, need their own checks against the role and the offer.

Key takeaways

  • Keep the federal cross-reference, 8 United States Code section 1324a, beside the phrase in your checklist, since the state text ties the phrase to those actions, according to Arizona State Legislature.
  • Test each applicant's status against the question the unauthorized alien definition asks, which is whether the person has the legal right or authorization under federal law to work in the United States, according to Arizona State Legislature.
  • Check each role against the three parts of the employee definition: services or labor, an employer in this state, and wages or other remuneration, according to Arizona State Legislature.
  • Send state questions to the sources named in the help section, because E-Verify does not provide guidance on state or local E-Verify laws, according to E-Verify.

The three terms at a glance

TermWhat the state text says Checklist question
Knowingly employ an unauthorized alienThe actions described in 8 United States Code section 1324a Is the federal section number written beside the phrase?
Unauthorized alien An alien without the legal right or authorization under federal law to work in the United States, as described in 8 United States Code section 1324a(h)(3) Does this person have that right or authorization under federal law?
Employee A person who provides services or labor for an employer in this state for wages or other remunerationDoes the role meet all three parts?

Who the Arizona rule reaches

The employer side of the Arizona definitions covers more than private companies. Employer includes this state, any political subdivision of this state and self-employed persons, according to Arizona State Legislature.

Start by writing down the legal form of the business that will make the offer, then compare that form with each category in the wording above. Keep the employer decision in writing, with a date, so the file shows which category was used.

When a recruiter presents an offer on behalf of another business, record which entity will be the employer on the offer before you apply the definition. The offer is the document a reviewer will check, so the employer name on it should match the entity you assessed.

A category that fits on paper still needs a note of the facts behind it. Write the legal name of the entity, the role title, and the person who confirmed the category, so a later reviewer can trace the decision without rebuilding it from memory.

For wider questions about immigration in hiring, a related guide covers immigration employment rules for hiring across several topics.

The phrase knowingly employ an unauthorized alien

Treat the phrase as a cross-reference rather than a stand-alone test. The state definition is built on the actions described in 8 United States Code section 1324a, according to Arizona State Legislature, so the checklist should point to that federal section rather than paraphrase it.

The state text also says that this term shall be interpreted consistently with 8 United States Code section 1324a and any applicable federal rules and regulations, according to Arizona State Legislature.

For the file, write the federal section number beside the phrase, and list any federal rules and regulations you checked. Save a dated copy of the state text you used, so a later question can be traced to the wording you relied on.

Place the words of the phrase in the checklist exactly as the state text presents them, including the quotation marks around the phrase, so a reader can see where the wording came from. Keeping the exact wording also prevents a reviewer from reading a summary as if it were the definition.

If a question arises about whether an action falls within the federal section, record the question in the file and take it to one of the sources named in the help section, rather than deciding it alone. Because the state text ties the term to 8 United States Code section 1324a, note on the date of review how you read the phrase. A later reviewer can then compare that note with the saved wording.

For checks on employer files, see a guide to auditing recruiting records.

The unauthorized alien definition

The state text defines an unauthorized alien, according to Arizona State Legislature, as an alien who does not have the legal right or authorization under federal law to work in the United States as described in 8 United States Code section 1324a(h)(3).

The definition contains three checks. The first asks whether the person has the legal right or authorization. The second asks whether that right or authorization comes under federal law. The third asks whether it covers work in the United States.

Turn the definition into one question for the file: does this person have the legal right or authorization under federal law to work in the United States? Record the answer and its date beside the offer. A short line in the file can hold the question, the answer, the date, and the name of the person who recorded it.

Avoid substituting another signal for that question. The definition asks about legal right or authorization, so notes about a name, an accent, or a country of origin do not answer it.

Keep the status question apart from pay questions in the checklist, since the definition concerns the right to work in the United States. Mixing the two makes it harder to show which answer came from which source.

Employee and employer terms

The employee definition, according to Arizona State Legislature, turns on three parts: services or labor, an employer in this state, and wages or other remuneration. Each part can be checked separately for each role.

Start with the services or labor part. Describe the work in the checklist using the tasks the person will perform, rather than relying on the job title alone. Write the tasks as short phrases, one phrase for each main task.

Next, check the employer part. Compare the entity named on the offer with the categories in the earlier section, and note which category applies. When the business making the offer is run by a self-employed person, the quoted employer definition names self-employed persons, according to Arizona State Legislature.

Then check the pay part. Write the form of compensation in the offer's own terms, because the definition refers to wages or other remuneration, according to Arizona State Legislature.

Put the employer category and the role title in the same row of the checklist, so the reviewer can match them without opening the offer. Keep one line for each role in the file, so a reviewer can see which of the three parts was confirmed and when.

Each part gets its own answer in the checklist, so a yes on one part does not stand in for the other two. The quoted text describes a person who provides services or labor, so a worker's status should be checked against those three parts rather than assumed from a label. Where a contract arrangement is unclear, record the facts you relied on and take that question to one of the help sources named below.

Illustrative example: one hiring team's file

A hiring team has 3 open roles and 5 applicants. It writes one row for each role with the three employee parts. For the role offered through a recruiter, the team records the business named on the offer as the employer, dates that entry, and then answers the legal-right question for each applicant. Any answer the team cannot support goes to one of the help sources named below, not to a guess.

E-Verify scope and limits

The E-Verify background page gives one historical reference point. According to E-Verify, Congress passed the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRIRA) in 1996.

A second point concerns scope. According to E-Verify, the E-Verify statute limits the scope of E-Verify operations to the United States, a scope that includes the 50 states.

The scope sentence describes the United States, not one state, so do not read it as a statement about Arizona law. Keep a dated record of which federal source you consulted for each federal note, so the notes can be separated from the Arizona definitions in a later review.

Keep the federal notes apart from the Arizona definitions. According to E-Verify, E-Verify does not provide guidance on state or local E-Verify laws, so the notes belong in their own part of the checklist.

A reader who wants to link E-Verify to a state question should write the question first, then check which source the question belongs to. Read the Arizona definitions on their own wording, separate from E-Verify.

For new-hire checks, see a guide to employment verification requirements.

Where to get help on state and discrimination questions

For help with state or local E-Verify laws, according to E-Verify, contact the appropriate state officials, a local Chamber of Commerce, or other legal advisors.

Before a call, write the exact question, the role, and the Arizona term it depends on. The person you reach then has the same wording you are reading. Send a short written summary of the question before any call, so the answer can be checked against the same wording later.

The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services page directs readers with questions about discrimination during the Form I-9 process to IER's employer hotline at 800-255-8155, according to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. The same page lists a TTY line at 800-237-2515 for people who are deaf or hard of hearing, according to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.

The hotline is listed for discrimination questions during the Form I-9 process, so questions about the Arizona definitions belong with the state sources instead.

Record the name or office of each source you contact and the date of the contact, so the file shows who was asked.

The sources used in this guide appear in the table below, with one quoted statement for each publisher.

PublisherSourceQuoted statement
Arizona State Legislature23-211 - Definitions "Employer includes this state, any political subdivision of this state and self-employed persons."
E-VerifyBackground and Overview "E-Verify does not provide guidance on state or local E-Verify laws."
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration ServicesSome Questions You May Have About Form I-9 "For more information about discrimination during the Form I-9 process, contact IER's employer hotline at 800-255-8155 (TTY for the deaf or hard of hearing: 800-237-2515) or visit their website at justice.gov/ier."

Next step: Copy the three definitions into your Arizona hiring checklist, then confirm your firm's state duties with state officials, a local Chamber of Commerce, or other legal advisors.

FAQ: Arizona knowingly employ terms

What does "knowingly employ an unauthorized alien" mean?

The phrase means the actions described in 8 United States Code section 1324a, according to Arizona State Legislature. Read those actions in the federal section itself. Put that section number beside the phrase in your checklist.

Who is an unauthorized alien?

It is a person without the legal right or authorization under federal law to work in the United States, as described in 8 United States Code section 1324a(h)(3), according to Arizona State Legislature. The definition asks about authorization to work, so the file should record that question and its answer. Write the question in the file exactly as the definition states it.

Who counts as an employee for this rule?

An employee is any person who provides services or labor for an employer in this state for wages or other remuneration, according to Arizona State Legislature. The three parts are services or labor, an employer in this state, and wages or other remuneration, so check each role against all three before you make the offer.

Who can I ask about state or local E-Verify duties?

You can contact the appropriate state officials, a local Chamber of Commerce, or other legal advisors, according to E-Verify. The first call may need to go to a state official or an advisor who can point to the right Arizona source. Name the Arizona definition you are asking about in the first sentence of the call.

Sources