Skip forward into hiring notes
RosterAcorn

Accommodation paperwork: 2 parts that make it sufficient

Accommodation paperwork is sufficient when it contains two parts: a description of the impairment and a reason the accommodation is needed.

Key takeaways

  • Part one: description of the impairment. The letter must state the nature of the impairment, its severity, its duration, the activities it limits, and the extent of those limits.
  • Part two: substantiation of the accommodation. The letter must show the connection between the described limits and the specific accommodation requested — it must explain why.
  • Both parts are required. A perfect description with no mention of the requested accommodation is an incomplete file; a request with no description is also incomplete.
  • Scope. The doctor writes about the person; the employer writes about the role. Documentation should not become an open-ended interrogation of full medical history.
  • Checklist before deciding: Nature, Severity, Duration, Activities, Extent, Connection. If any box is empty, ask a targeted follow-up for the missing part by name.

What "sufficient paperwork" actually means

The request for an accommodation sits on top of a two-page letter from a clinic. You need to decide, now, whether that letter does the job.

Your question is narrower. Does the paperwork contain the two things the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says make documentation sufficient? EEOC Enforcement Guidance on Disability-Related Inquiries and Medical Examinations of Employees under the ADA answers it directly: documentation is sufficient if it describes the impairment, its limits, and the extent of those limits, and if it substantiates why the requested reasonable accommodation is needed.

Two parts. A description and a substantiation. Everything in this post expands those two parts and shows you where the paperwork typically fails each one.

One framing point before you read further. Reasonable accommodation belongs to qualified applicants and employees with disabilities. Part-time, full-time and probationary status do not change that. The EEOC states this plainly in its Enforcement Guidance on Reasonable Accommodation and Undue Hardship under the ADA. The same guidance notes that, generally, the individual with a disability must tell you an accommodation is needed. That is where your paperwork trail begins.

The two parts in plain words

Part one is a clinical description. It tells you what the impairment is, how severe it is, how long it lasts, which activities it limits, and how far it limits them. It is factual. It needs to give you enough to picture what the person can and cannot do, and to see that picture change over time.

Part two is a bridge. It connects that description to the specific thing the person asked for. Why does an ergonomic chair follow from a back condition that limits sitting tolerance? Why does a modified schedule follow from a fatigue condition with a known morning window? If the letter describes a condition beautifully and never mentions the requested accommodation, you are holding a sufficient description and an insufficient request.

Put the two together and you can make a decision. Keep them apart and you will either deny something you could have granted or grant something you cannot defend.

What part one must contain

Take them one at a time.

Nature of the impairment. What is the condition, in clinical terms? A letter that says only "the patient has medical limitations" fails here. A letter that names the condition and its mechanism passes.

Severity and duration. How bad is it right now, and how long has it been that way? Severity without duration leaves you guessing whether this is a transient issue or an ongoing one.

Activity or activities limited. Which parts of the job or of daily function does the impairment affect? Sitting, standing, lifting, concentrating, hearing, seeing — name them.

Extent of the limit. How far does the limit reach? Extent is where most letters often go soft, and it is where your follow-up questions should go hard.

A note on scope: part one describes the impairment and its limits. It does not have to describe your workplace, your job description, or your staffing. That context belongs on your side of the desk. The doctor writes about the person. You write about the role. For how that line applies to hiring files, see medical facts in a hiring report.

What part two must contain

Part two has one job: substantiate why the requested accommodation is needed. The word "substantiate" is doing real work. It means the letter must do more than mention the accommodation. It must show the link.

Compare two sentences. "The patient would benefit from a flexible start time." That mentions an option. "The patient's morning medication causes drowsiness for approximately two hours after waking, and a start time no earlier than 10:00 would allow the patient to arrive alert." That substantiates. The second sentence takes the severity-and-duration facts from part one and points them at a specific fix.

When you read a letter, check whether it explains how the described limits lead to the requested accommodation.

Illustrative example: both parts in one letter

This example is invented for illustration and describes no real person. Suppose a letter states that a back condition has limited sitting for 6 months, that the employee cannot sit longer than 20 minutes at a time, and that the limit applies on every shift. That covers part one. It then states that a chair with lumbar support lets the employee stand and alternate positions every 20 minutes, so the requested chair is needed to keep sitting within that limit. That is part two. A letter with both halves gives you a description and a reason you can check against the job.

One structural point on how these two parts interact with your own paperwork. The employer-side example in the EEOC guidance shows what a well-formed request looks like from your chair: you ask for documentation that describes the nature, severity and duration of the impairment, the activities it limits and the extent of those limits, and that substantiates why the ergonomic chair is needed. Use it. When the letter comes back matching it, you will know you have both parts without re-reading anything.

A side-by-side look at the two parts

The table below maps the two parts of sufficient documentation against the elements each one must cover. Use it as a reading aid when you first open a file.

Part of the paperworkElements it must contain
Part 1: Description of the impairmentNature, severity, duration, activities limited, extent of the limit
Part 2: Substantiation of the accommodationA stated connection between the described limits and the specific accommodation requested

Where real files fail

Each one breaks a specific element of one of the two parts.

Pattern one: the vague severity line. "The patient has significant limitations." No extent. You cannot compare "significant" to a job duty. Ask for the extent in numbers of minutes, pounds, hours, or frequency.

Pattern two: the missing accommodation. A full two-page description of a condition, then a closing line asking you to "consider appropriate accommodations." No specific ask, no substantiation. Part two is empty.

Pattern three: the accommodation without a description. The mirror image. "Please provide a standing desk." No impairment described, no limits given. You have a request with no part one. This is the easiest file to send back.

The EEOC Technical Assistance Manual on the Employment Provisions (Title I) of the Americans with Disabilities Act draws the line here: an employer must provide equipment needed to perform a job, with no obligation to provide equipment the individual uses regularly in daily life, such as glasses, a hearing aid or a wheelchair. That is not a paperwork gap.

Modifications to existing leave policies and regular work hours may be required as accommodations. When part two of a letter substantiates a schedule change instead of a device, reviewers sometimes treat it as a softer request. It is not. Hold it to the same standard: description first, then the reason.

A further pattern deserves its own note because it is about timing rather than content. Under the EEOC's reasonable accommodation guidance, generally the individual with a disability must inform the employer that an accommodation is needed. That means the accommodation process starts when the individual makes that request.

How to ask for what you need

When a request arrives thin, your first move is a targeted follow-up, not a demand for a full new workup. Ask for the missing part by name, for example: "We have part one. Please send the reason this accommodation is needed." If the file stalls, use the steps after an accommodation request.

Your own request should mirror the structure above. Name the two parts. Name the specific accommodation under review. Keep the inquiry tied to the accommodation process rather than drifting into a general medical exam.

There is a boundary you should respect while asking. Documentation should describe the employee's functioning and the link to the accommodation. It should not become an open-ended interrogation of the person's full medical history. Ask for the two parts, receive them, decide. For more on this, see medical documentation request checks.

When the two parts are present

You now hold a description and a substantiation. The paperwork does not end the discussion. It starts it.

In that conversation you are allowed to explore alternatives. If the doctor substantiates a chair, and a different chair model meets the same need at lower cost, that is a legitimate path. The substantiation tells you the need. Your side decides the vehicle.

If part two substantiates something outside the scope of what an employer provides, the manual's daily-life line applies. Either way, your reasoning should be visible in the file, element by element.

Questions recruiters actually ask

Do I need a diagnosis in the letter? Sufficiency turns on the nature, severity, duration, limits and substantiation the EEOC guidance lists. Ask whether the letter gives you enough to understand the limits. If it does, you have part one.

What if the letter covers part one perfectly and never mentions the accommodation? You have half a file, so send one targeted follow-up asking for the substantiation. Do not send the whole file back for a rewrite.

Who do I ask when a file is genuinely ambiguous? When the sources leave a specific case open, your first call is your own employment counsel or your HR compliance lead. They can read the file against the guidance and tell you whether a follow-up is warranted or whether you already have enough.

Quick checklist before you decide

Each line maps to one element.

  • Nature. The letter names the impairment in clinical terms.
  • Severity. The letter states how severe the condition is now.
  • Duration. The letter states how long the condition has lasted or is expected to last.
  • Activities. The letter names the specific activities the impairment limits.
  • Extent. The letter quantifies or otherwise pins down how far each limit reaches.
  • Connection. The letter explains why the specific requested accommodation follows from those limits.

Six boxes. Two parts. If any box is empty, you know exactly which question to ask next, and you will not send the file around a third time.

When all six are checked, you move to the conversation. The paperwork has done its job. It has given you a description you can act on and a reason you can defend. That is what sufficient looks like.

Sources